Premium Essay

To Clone or Not to Clone

In: Social Issues

Submitted By sps441testuser
Words 1129
Pages 5
Manipulating Life: The Ethics and Science of Biotechnology

The question of whether humans should have the right to clone themselves leads to interesting questions on the nature of human individuality. There is also the ethical question of whether human reproductive cloning in order to replicate ones genetic identity should be allowed at all. If reproductive cloning to create an entire human being were possible, and accessibility and cost were not a factor, should humans have the unrestricted right to clone themselves? The right or even need for humans to clone themselves is as complex a moral or ethical issue as it is a complex bimolecular and genetic procedure. There may be no definitive answer to the ethical or moral dilemmas but in my opinion there is not a reason compelling enough to justify human reproductive cloning of an entire human being, even if it were technically possible at this time. There appear to be too many issues and unknowns in both the science and ethics of human reproductive cloning to allow it even if it were possible. The fear as portrayed in science fiction about armies of replicated humans threatening society and all of our identities being at risk are certainly unfounded as the science proves out (Sommers Smith, 5C - 23). Unlike the renowned geneticist James Watson I am not so certain that having the ability to clone a human would make it a benefit to our society, or should make it a requirement to do so (Grace, pp. 214-215). The unknowns about human cloning seem to far outweigh our suppositions about the results which of course may change as research continues and science and technology in genetics advances. Looking at the example of natural twins there can be an interesting reaction when seeing a pair of identical monozygotic twins dressed identically. Maybe a sense of awe and joy but also a bit of unease or discomfort when…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Human Cloning. Is It Ethical

...means that at this moment, scientists have the right to clone a human if they wanted to. While some believe that, we should not ban cloning in the United States, there are also many that believe that we should, and I am one of them. Within this paper, I will explain my view in order to plead my case that human cloning is unethical and inhumane. Human Cloning, Is it Ethical Human cloning is and has been the subject of moral debate in the United States and around the world, and because of this it has raised many ethical questions. One thing that I do have in common with our previous president Bush is his principle that it is unethical to create human life for destroying it. I never thought about human cloning and its relevance until I watched the movie, called The Island. The Island is a sci-fi action thriller that reportedly cost about $120 million to make. Its powerful message is against creating human life in a laboratory and it truly came through loud and clear despite the ingenious and noisy special effects. The Island tells the story of a government-funded billion-dollar laboratory hidden in the Arizona desert in 2019 where scientists do cloning on a mass scale. They sell $5 million "insurance policies" to rich people who want to live forever by buying replacement body parts. The scientists agree to follow ethical guidelines in their cloning, and falsely tell their customers that the clones are in a "vegetative state" unable to know or......

Words: 1677 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...Philosophy Paper What would the world be like as a clone? Nameless, parentless, with no idea of who you are, why you are here, or what your purpose is? Mankind is getting closer and closer to the point where we can clone humans; however, there are many potential repercussions of this research. Human life has always had some parental identity that allow us to determine our own identity. If we took this away and turned the process of human development into a science experiment there may be serious negative effects for those involved. It is important for us to understand what makes up identity so we take better care of those who are unsure of their own. For the purpose of this paper we will discuss cloning as a movie clone, an immediate exact replica in every way. The two beings have all the same features, physically they will look exactly the same and mentally have all of the same memories. Let's say a man goes into a doctors office for a simple outpatient surgery. Unknown to the patient, he is cloned while unconscious. The clones are put in two identical rooms in the same exact positions. The clone is an exact replica mind and body, but they know nothing of the cloning experiment. The world now has two men who are the exact same in every way and think that they are the original person, as they don't know they are cloned. These two men are the same person while unconscious and even after they awake, they have the same body and same memories. When put in......

Words: 1186 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Attack of the Clones

...Layne Hazam English 101 Prof. Anderson Aug 7, 2010 Attack of the Clones I recall sitting around the dinner table with my family as a teenager and engaging in riveting debates about the numerous possibilities cloning had for our world. In recent years, due to sports injuries and other battle wounds, these possibilities have become increasingly personal for me, even as the technology and the debates have rapidly advanced. It seems that since the discovery of fire humanity has attempted to imitate and manipulate phenomena that nature has had billions of years to develop and perfect. Cloning is a perfect example of such attempts. In nature, cloning is the process by which genetically identical organisms are produced by way of asexual reproduction. With some success, scientists have been working on ways to reproduce this phenomenon through biotechnology, in a laboratory setting. In biotechnology, cloning refers to the process used to create copies of DNA, cells, or entire organisms. Each of these forms of cloning will be described in this paper, which will then explore the issues surrounding cloning from biological, technological and public health standpoints. Molecular cloning, or DNA cloning, is the process of making multiple copies of an isolated sequence of DNA fragments (Strachan & Read, 1999). This form of cloning is most often used in biological research, but is also used in more practical applications such as......

Words: 2102 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Stem Cell Research Paper

...methods and was born to a surrogate mother (“Cloning Fact Sheet”). The methods used to clone Dolly were once considered to be biologically impossible (Wilmut and Highfield 12). Thus, once Dolly’s birth was announced to the rest of the world, an immediate debate over the ethics of cloning began. In particular, reproductive cloning was widely discussed because it could possibly be accomplished through somatic cell nuclear transfer to clone entire humans (“Cloning Fact Sheet”). For medical, social, religious, and political reasons, there are both proponents and opponents of reproductive human cloning and its ethics. Currently, the best way to deal with reproductive cloning is to ban its use because there are many negative consequences that could arise from using cloning technology. There are two different types of human cloning: therapeutic cloning and reproductive cloning. The goal of the former is to obtain stem cells from embryos that can be used to study the growth of the human body and to find possible cures and treatments for various diseases (“Cloning Fact Sheet”). The purpose of the latter, on the other hand, is to create a whole human being through cloning. Specifically, reproductive cloning is done using somatic cell nuclear transfer and can theoretically produce a human that has the same exact nuclear DNA as another individual. Currently, though, this technology has only been used to clone animals and has not yet been successful in cloning humans (“Cloning Fact......

Words: 1407 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Deontology vs. Consequences keeps growing and growing, leading us to be able to do and manipulate things that may not be ethical. My experiment is about human cloning. A group of scientists are able to make human clones, that have identical genetic codes and DNA as the original person. They decide to make a business out of these clones, a “black market” so to say. How their business works is that they have their offices way out where nobody knows and they raised these clones in a controlled civilization. They grow it from a pod, brain washing it about its life, so when it is born as an adult they think they had a past and memories and what not. This is so the clone is more human like and more of an a exact match to their original person. The original person would buy this clone, so in case anything happened to them, like they needed a heart transplant, or got cancer, they would use their clone as a back up for parts or to keep them alive. The thing is though, the “owners” don’t know that the scientist are actually raising the clones as human beings in another life, they were told their exact parts were all just in a genetic sac and were just ready whenever they needed them. Okay, so here is where problems start to kick in. The scientist didn’t think of the consequences of raising actual clones. They are just like human beings, and are able to think, process situations, and develop the brain and become more intelligent. They learn from mistakes, they are seekers to find things out,......

Words: 1521 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


................................................................. 4 EMC TimeFinder/Clone overview .................................................................................. 4 Clone copy sessions ............................................................................................... 5 EMC TimeFinder/Snap overview................................................................................... 6 Snap copy sessions................................................................................................ 7 EMC TimeFinder in virtual environments ....................................................................... 7 EMC Virtual Provisioning overview............................................................................ 8 TimeFinder/Clone for thin devices.............................................................................. 10 TimeFinder/Clone using “copy/precopy” ................................................................ 10 TimeFinder/Clone using “nocopy”.......................................................................... 11 Cloning a TDEV to a larger TDEV ............................................................................. 13 Cloning to and from traditional virtual devices ................................................. 14 Cascading TimeFinder/Clone ................................................................................. 17 TF/Clone emulation in support of thin devices .............................................

Words: 5721 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Ethics and Fears and Wonders of Human Cloning

...REACTION PAPER Ethics and Fears and Wonders of Human Cloning By Dr. Alfredo P. Co What is a clone? According to the Encyclopædia Britannica (1979), “a clone is a population of organisms derived originally from a single individual. By definition clones occur only in organisms capable of asexual reproduction and consist of genetically identical individuals”. There has been a successful recorded experiment which regard to cloning, although it was just an animal (a sheep to be more specific), there has been speculations that Human Cloning is not very far away. Before judging this issue, we should refrain having ignorant thoughts and try to study and understand the issue and detach ourselves from our emotions, religious dogmas and cultural habits/ or entrenched habits. We should see all the possible outcome of this, both positive and negative. Cloning is an issue that cannot be overlooked because everyone will be affected by the decision that would be put upon the issue, lives will either be saved and/or lost. In February 1997, Dolly the sheep, was successfully cloned from an adult sheep. After this experiment, some people were enthusiastic with this successful discovery, because it may be the key to unlocking the ‘untreatable diseases’ that we are currently facing today. It may give life and/or prolong life, it may be the only solution and the only hope for families that are experiencing a very difficult time in watching their loved ones suffer, and it may be the only......

Words: 753 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

A Clone

...A clone writes Sharing your DNA with someone does not make you the same person, says Lowri Turner By Lowri Turner, Friday January 10, 2003 The Guardian 5 I am a clone. Even writing that feels odd. I might as well say I am a tomato, or a VW Beetle, or a leather three-piece suite with free footstool from DFS for all the resonance the word "clone" has for me. I don't feel like a clone. I don't think I look like a clone. And yet, strictly speaking, I am one. I am an identical twin. I am an exact genetic copy of someone else, or they are a copy of me, depending on your point of view. As the younger twin - my sister Catrin and I were born by 10 Caesarean, so it was more of a queueing system and I was at the back - I tend to accept that it is I who am the copy and my sister who is the original. But then, when you've spent your childhood being given a dead arm for daring to corral Sindy's pony for exclusive personal use, you tend to acquiesce easily to sibling bullying. When you are part of a multiple birth - I have another non-identical triplet sister to confuse 15 matters further - you are used to being a curiosity. As a child, people stared, teachers got confused and my identical sister and I were asked to be bridesmaids a lot. During the mid-70s, when big old-fashioned cinemas had a habit of converting to three smaller screens, my two sisters and I had a lucrative sideline touring north London posing on a three-wheeled bicycle for local papers. As an adult,......

Words: 846 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

It Is Possible to Clone Mammals. Is It Morally Acceptable to Clone a Human Being?

...It is possible to clone mammals. Is it morally acceptable to clone a human being? Defend your answer against those who would not agree with you. By: Martin Pierce Student Number: 1057404 In cloning for medical-research purposes the development of the embryo is halted as soon as a cluster of stem cells develops. The stem cells are then harvested for research purposes. Due to the fact that no infant is born (in fact the embryo never even gets past the blastocyst stage), it is argued that this type of cloning has nothing to do with human cloning. (Hatch Backs Limited Cloning, 2002). For this reason this paper shall take the statement “to clone a human being” as meaning cloning that results in a fully formed human and not on the cloning of embryos for the purposes of research. The issues around cloning are in the main more ethical than theological and yet most of the objections to cloning come from religious sources, even if those objections are not religious in nature. The first objection is that cloning leaves God out of the process of human creation. This only makes sense though if your definition of God is of a being that plays a role in the birth of each member of our species. Even holding to this view it does not necessarily follow that cloning is comparable to playing God (Brannigan, 2001). How can science prevent a......

Words: 2863 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay


...such as the army of clones in the movie Star Wars. What most people don't know is that there is so much more to cloning than creating a living being identical to the original. There are multiple ways to utilize the technology of cloning whether they be beneficial or not. Cloning is a good idea as long as it upholds life and is not allowed to limit the diversity of genetic traits. Cloning is “the asexual production of an exact copy of an original” (“What is cloning”). It is from one parent and results in identical cells. Scientifically speaking, one cell could be cloned, as well as organs, plants, even animals and perhaps humans. Just as varied, are the reasons to clone in the first place. The possibilities of cloning range from medical uses, personal uses, agricultural and livestock improvement to saving endangered species and more. The medical advantages cloning provides extend life, treat illnesses, and produce medications. Research into cell growth and genetics adds understanding into diseases such as cancer and how to avoid hereditary defects. In addition, cloning can improve food sources whether crops or livestock. Cloning also takes part in choosing desirable traits for people, animals, and plant, crops. Once they genetically engineer the plants, they can clone those seeds so that they have multiple identical copies of that same plant. Same with animals or livestock. If a healthy beneficial specimen is breeded just right, their DNA can be used to clone more perfect......

Words: 1822 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay


...artificial cloning and these are gene cloning, reproductive cloning and therapeutic cloning. Gene cloning produces copies of genes or segments of DNA. Reproductive cloning produces copies of whole animals. Different scientists have different reasons and goal unto why they want to clone and the reasons often directly correlate with the type of cloning to be conducted. For instance Rael who is a former French Journalist claims that "Cloning a baby is just the first step. For me, it's not so important," he said. "It's a good step, but my ultimate goal is to give humanity eternal life through cloning. Some scientists who want to clone livestock claim that their ultimate goal is to produce more food for less money. While those who support therapeutic cloning according to the Asia Pacific Economic blog is that “there goal is to create new organs from the existing cell tissues of a medical patient. Because the organs created would be of the person’s own cells, there would be a much reduced risk of organ rejection once a transplant procedure was successfully completed” There are two main techniques used to clone mammals and if scientist are allowed these techniques may be applied in the near future to clone human beings. The first is embryo splitting. An embryo is the early stage of a fetus. Embryo splitting is the artificial division of a single embryo. The same process happens naturally to produce identical twins. The second technique, somatic nuclear replacement, has the......

Words: 1079 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Summary of Don't Send in the Clones

...Diana Rodriguez Clare Foland English 102 23 October, 2015 “Summary of Don't Send in the Clones” In her article “Don’t Send in the Clones”, author Maureen Dowd states the arising issues, according to her with having Facebook applications such as RoomBug and websites such as URoom surf to automatically generate the perfect roommate by matching students with similar interests, ideas, and hobbies; therefore, students averting being surprised with a roommate that is unlike them. Dowd opens with her own personal experience as a college student being paired up with roommates that embodied a different way of thinking. Dowd then describes how “co-habiting with snarly and moody roomies prepared [her] for the working world, where people can be outlandishly cantankerous over small stuff”( 737). As a result, Dowd argues that college is intended for encountering a diverse student population. Additionally, Dowd believes that people will always have differences or similarities; thus, Dowd notes that students should learn to co-opt with students that have a multitude of different ideas, backgrounds, and perspectives. For this reason, Dowd believes this promotes self-growth and prepares students for the working sector. Dowd concludes by encouraging students to not have the same experiences over and over again. Subsequently, at the end of the essay Dowd says, “College is not only where you hit the books. It should also be where you learn not to judge a book by its cover” (737). Hence...

Words: 294 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...Science Fiction movie. Since then, human cloning has become one of the most debated topics in the world. From the schoolhouse to the White House, discussions began regarding the ethical implications of human cloning. In several recent polls by TIME magazine (The Ethics of Cloning, 1998 ), it was shown that 75 percent of the responding population thought that cloning wasn’t a good thing. Furthermore, 74 percent of the respondents believed that cloning was against God’s will, and when asked if they would clone themselves, if presented with the opportunity, 91 percent responded with a “no”. However, when asked to define human cloning, an estimated 95 percent of them couldn’t describe it correctly. As a matter of fact, in a personal interview with Miss. Weber, T.A. (personal interview, November 7,1998) when asked, “What do you think about human cloning?” responded, “I don’t know a lot about it, but I know it’s scary”. Opponents of human cloning argue that it is immoral and unethical to clone human beings for both religious and humanitarian reasons. Moreover, other opponents describe human cloning as a luxury for wealthy people or as a tool for organ market development. Conversely, I believe that human cloning can have many benefits for the human race in terms of helping infertile couples and people with genetic problems. In addition, it can be really helpful for a person with diseases such as kidney and liver defects or cancer. First of all, it seems logical that one needs to......

Words: 1118 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Role Play

...let all of the clones stab him with their blades. After this happening, the clone would smirk as it's face would morph and distort into snakes and slither, falling to the Earth as this happened, the clons probably finally noticing the young Uchiha had a clone fighting this entire time. The real Mikamo was hidden underground, still focusing his energy. As he felt the thunk of the blade of his weapon hit the Earth, he sighed. 'Well, guess my clone wasn't enough...Oh well, time for some real fun, oh and let's not forget my snake..' he said as he performed a few handsigns, signaling the snakes mind to know to move from the gecko, as it slithered away, dirt from above the earth crumpled down onto him and into his hair. 'Oh bother,' he said in a Poo bear style,' looks like that fat gecko landed. And I hope he knows he's not the only one with tricks up his sleeve..' he said as he thrusted his arm upward, his hand pushing through the earth. Knowing that it would be hardly visible, he clawed the earth apart, digging himself out. He was wearing the same attire as the clone from before, except it was smeared with grime from underground, and his katana had been upgraded several times from the clones. As his head was able to reach through the earth, he clawed harder and eventually was able to dig himself out. He stood tall, looking at the three Jato's being confused. He chukcled. 'I told you I had many tricks, Jatomaru.' he said as he took a quick glance at the katana his clone had used.......

Words: 1643 - Pages: 7

Free Essay


...wall. This stage lasts between 4 and 6 days on average. The definition is as simple as that. Now, as most of you can see, the habit of some to use the term embryo so loosely may have lead to a misunderstanding of what it really is. Now that this misinterpretation has been cleared up we can continue on with the first argument. Kass argues in his article, that attempting to clone a human being would be unethical because it will cause harm to the future child, due to the fact that it is still an unperfected procedure in even animals. He may be correct in that statement, but he does not inform people that before we would even consider cloning a human being, we would first make sure that the success rate in animals is to a point where it is almost faultless. Defects that may currently be occurring in animals will be corrected and become seamless before any consideration of human cloning would take place. Even since the infamous “Dolly” was cloned in 1996, there have been advances to correct the defects that she had later in life. He also states in his article that numerous scientists claim if we were to clone a human it would carry immense repercussions such as, malformed and defective children. Just like in the previous statement, he may be truthful, but he is also not bringing up the fact that that is the exact reason cloning is still in its experimental stages and not being used for human reproduction (Longston). It will be many years before we will perfect cloning, but......

Words: 1407 - Pages: 6