Free Essay

Thinking Critically

In: Business and Management

Submitted By izzyrose
Words 579
Pages 3
Critical Thinking Scenario
ETH/316
November 30, 2015
Ryan Busch

The scenario that I choose was the, “To Drill or Not to Drill.” The basis of the story is based on the Rocky Mountain range and if the energy companies should be allowed to drill for gas at the expense of endangering the natural wildlife that live in the ecosystem there. The story was put together by Nightline on July nineteen, two thousand and four.

* What is the moral responsibility of all participants?

The moral responsibility of all the participants are to decide if it is morally right to drill for gas in a natural reserve. The government should look at what the land is set aside for, not what they can acquire form the natural reserve. The Bureau of Land Management, and the BLM Field Manager is also responsible because they are the ones that process the applications to drill. The gas companies that wish to drill are responsible for drill in a safe and way that the land and animals are not affected by the drilling.

* What are the stakeholders' moral failings?

The failing of the US government is that they want the energy companies to be able to drill for gas to benefit from the energy and monetary value that this will provide the country. The BLM has the failing in that they rarely deny an application to drill. “How many of those applications have you rejected? Actually, percentage wise very few but I have changed many.” (The BLM Field Manager in Pinedale, 2004).
The failing of the energy companies is that they do not care about the environment that they are drilling in and are causing damage to the ecosystem.

* What ideals or obligations are in conflict?

The obligations that are in conflict is that the land in question is set aside as a natural reserve to preserve a part of the US land in its natural state and keep the animal life that live their intact without human interference. This area is protected by the government, but the obligation to protect the reserve is being neglected by the energy companies, the government and the BLM.

* What is the best outcome, given the consequences?

The best outcome for this situation would be to allow the energy companies limited access to the reserve. Strict regulations set upon the energy companies in order that they dispose of waste properly and do not disturb the ecosystem they are drilling in. This is best because the country can benefit from the gas that is drilled and the animals can continue to strive, even the rare Sage-Grouse.

Critical thinking and ethics go hand in hand because decisions that require ethical compos should be taken seriously. Using all the facts and evaluating the outcomes before making a logical and morally right decision is what critical thinking does with ethics.

In conclusion the ethical and moral responsibility should be governed with a more strict hand. The ecosystem will be affected by any type of drilling and the energy companies are growing in numbers each year. Thinking critically about what is best for the land at hand would require more than one mind to make fair decisions rather than one or two people who fear for their livelihood.

References
To Drill or Not to Drill. (2004, July). Nightline, (), . Retrieved from http://media.pearsoncmg.com/pls/us/phoenix/1269738887/To_Drill_or_Not_to_Drill.html
Nicholas Manias. (2013). Ethics Applied. Retrieved from Nicholas Manias, ETH/316 website.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Apply Chaffee's Problem-Solving Approach on Page 76 of Thinking Critically

...group of upgraded devices needs to be tracked in order to ensure the issue is solved. If there’s still an issue, we need to continue to find solutions in development and put them into action. Frequent communication with the customer is crucial in ensuring their satisfaction with the solution. If the customer is still discussing an alternative vendor after the problem is corrected, a revision in the service level agreement may be considered whereby a nominal financial penalty is involved for similar future issues. Perhaps a small percentage discount on, or refund of, defective devices would be included. As a final effort only, financial concessions might have to be made in order to keep a valued customer. Chaffee, J. (2012). Thinking Critically (Tenth ed.). Boston: Wadsworth....

Words: 289 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Critically Evaluating the News

...Critically Evaluating the News It is important to make a critical evaluation of any news story. People shouldn’t believe everything they hear on the news because it is possible for a reporter to somehow get their information wrong because of someone that is not completely honest or not getting both sides of the story. Although I am sure news reporters try to make sure that they do have all of the correct information there is always that small chance that they don’t. There is also the possibility of maybe having a misprint in the news as well. I feel that the headline I chose “Obama presses Congress for deal to end spending cuts” is very clear and accurate because it goes into detail about what President Obama is trying to do and what can happen if they do not make a deal. It basically states the issue and the consequences of the issue if it is not resolved. I do not really think that there were any facts ignored in this article although I am not one hundred percent into politics and economics to be completely sure. I think that the story had a lot of alternative perspectives because the author mentioned that if a deal was not made Spetalnick (2013), “Thousands of Americans who serve their country would see their wages cut and hours reduced”. It also stated other things that may or will happen as well. The author does assume that there are no signs of negotiation (Spetalnick, 2013). It is very important to make distinctions when doing a......

Words: 430 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Critically Analyze

...Critically analyze the statement: “Cruise ship tourism- possible economy booster.” An Essay S. Cole January 30, 2013 Introduction A cruise is defined as a voyage on a ship taken as holiday (Oxford English Dictionary). Cruise ship tourism is proclaimed by the sea trade industry to be a privileged thing, yet for the island nations of the Caribbean, the benefits of the expanding industry may be in disagreement with their overall growth and objectives. This essay seeks to highlight the aspect of cruise tourism and how beneficial it is to the economy thus analyzing the advantages and the disadvantages of cruise ship tourism to the Caribbean country. Cruise ship tourism is the top growing sector of the tourism industry, it represents a part of the world economy. It is debatable as to whether or not Cruise ship can boost an economy this paper will argue various views as to whether it is feasible for a cruise ship tourism to do so as well as how vital is a cruise ship to an economy. The tourism industry continues to be amongst the most vibrant economic sectors, generating a wide range of benefits including a growing contribution to Gross Domestic Profit (GDP), tourism is a reliable tool for sustainable job creation. Tourism plays a crucial role in the creation of employment, which is......

Words: 1581 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Assess and Critically Comment on the Idea That Strategic Planning Systems Can Stifle Innovative Thinking in Organisations

...Assess and critically comment on the idea that strategic planning systems can stifle innovative thinking in organisations It is debatable whether strategic planning systems can stifle innovative thinking in organisations. Although strategic planning systems are used in order to make companies work more efficiently, they may restrict organisations from showing their true potential by stifling innovative thinking. There are other theorists that state that listening to closely to markets and strategies can create a barrier to commercialising new technology and lead to reduced competitiveness. (Ferrell and Lukas 2000). In order to truly understand and analyse whether innovative thinking is being constrained by strategic planning systems, it is essential to understand which strategic planning systems are being used, whether their implementation limits the allowance to new and different approaches to organisations, and whether companies in real-life are being affected by this constraint. Before analysing whether innovative thinking is oppressed by strategic planning systems, it is important to define what a strategic planning system is. According to the BNET Business Dictionary (2007), strategic analysis is ‘…the process of conducting research on the business environment within which an organisation operates and on the organisation itself, in order to formulate strategy’. There are many different tools and analytical methods that are used by companies but there are three......

Words: 1745 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Thinking Critically Simulation

...Thinking Critically Simulation Thinking Critically Simulation Several problem evaluation tools and techniques were encountered in the simulation. As each team member completed the simulation, each was able to understand the differences of the tools and techniques that were used, and how they were applied. Discussed here are how these techniques assisted with the evaluations of decision-making processes and outcomes. Further, each team member was able to understand the outcomes that were reached from the simulations, and how the changes of those decision-making techniques offer better results. Many problem evaluation tools and techniques are applied to the Critical Thinking Simulation. The simulation provides a variety of information gathered from both market research and employee interviews. In addition, the founder of Credenhill Industries, Linda James, provides advice and recommendations to assist in the decision-making process. Another problem evaluation tool found within the simulation is the Urgency-Criticality Matrix. An Urgency-Criticality (UC) Matrix is a tool that helps in the decision-making process to sort or sift through current issues and problems. The UC Matrix assists in prioritizing and sorting possible solutions according to the urgency and criticality of each situation. Urgent problems require immediate attention and critical problems are the activities necessary to achieve the objective. The UC Matrix facilitates in......

Words: 1096 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Thinking Critically About Ethics

...Graded Project Thinking Critically About Ethics Graded Project Thinking Critically About Ethics Introduction The National Federation of Paralegal System (NFPA) is a very well known organization who has comprised paralegal association of individual and throughout the Canada and United States. They have their own job responsibilities that reflecting the diversity if parallel profession. This is also the responsibility of NFPA paralegal association that every individual legal supervisor does not break the law and perform their duties under given considerations (Zoubek, 2012, p. 26). On the other hand, ABA Models Rules settled by America Bar Association (ABA) for setting the rules according to the standards lawyer’s professional responsibilities and legal ethics in United States of America. Discussion In this paper, I will review activities throughout the week and identify where Carl and Attorney Howe violate the ethical considerations according to ABA Models rules and NFPA ethical considerations. Monday On the first day when Jane says, she has a side business on the side, and she didn’t pay taxes because the government does not know about it, Carl failed and avoided the ABA MR Rule 2.1; NFPA Rule EC-1.3(a) which is stated that, lawyer must be an independent lawyer and advice candidate according to justice but on that particular time Carl does not provide any instruction to Jane smith about the violation of ABA and NFPA rules. Furthermore, according to ABA......

Words: 551 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

What Is Non-Cognitivism? Critically Evaluate the “Wishful Thinking” Argument Against Non-Cognitivism

...further explain one branch of non-cognitivism expressivism. This particular view of non-cognitivism is mostly targeted by the wishful thinking argument. I will then outline the main problem brought up by the wishful thinking argument. I will then outline the expressionist’s responses to the wishful thinking argument using David Enoch and James Lenman’s solutions to the problem, and show the flaws in their arguments. Therefore I will come to the conclusion that the wishful thinking argument is a valid objection to non-cognitivism. Non-Cognitivism Non cognitivism is the objection to the claim the moral facts express belief. According to this view they are not either true or false, neither do the assert anything about the world. Seeing as moral facts cannot be seen as true and no one can have knowledge of something that is not true, non-cognitivism implies the moral knowledge is impossible. The three main forms of non-cognitivism are; prescriptivism, emotivism and expressivism. In this essay I will be addressing the problems found in the expressivism branch of non-cognitivism. Expressivism Expressivism is the view that sentences about moral facts are not to descriptive terms, and do not relate to the real world problems. They are used for expressing either positive or negative attitude towards the object of the sentence. The Wishful-thinking argument This is an argument that rejects non-cognitivism presented by Cian Dorr (2002). The outline of this argument is the fact......

Words: 1686 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Thinking About Thinking

...Thinking about Thinking Critical thinking is a process of testing an argument or observation for legitimacy. (Moore & Parker, 2012) Critical thinking includes deductive and inductive arguments. One important survival skill humans have is critical thinking. Had our ancestors not had the ability to think critically, we would not be here. When determining the worth of an argument, it is necessary to break an argument into parts. One must determine the premise or premises and conclusion. Had our ancestors not learned that some red berries can kill you, many more would have eaten these berries; destroying the future of the gene pool. We learned that premises are statements of assumed or known facts which should not contradicts each other. (Moore & Parker, 2012) A conclusion is an assumption drawn from the premises. For example; one premise could be that two dogs sit before you. Another could be that both are white with black spots. Both statements suggest that the dogs belong to the same breed. We begin thinking critically by identifying the premises, then examining each for soundness. Any vagueness or uncertainty must be determined within the suggestions. In the case of a deductive argument, the conclusion must be true if the premises are true. (Moore & Parker, 2012) When the truth value of a conclusion is unclear, despite the truth of its premises, it is then an inductive argument. (Moore & Parker, 2012) For example; upon closer observation, one dog is......

Words: 346 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Thinking Critically About Ethics

...Thinking Critically about Ethics MONDAY Carl was in violation of the following model rules at various times throughout the day. He appears to be in violation of Model rules 1.8, 1.5 as well as the Ethical Considerations that apply being EC- 1.5 (a), EC- 1.7(a), EC 1.6(a) TUESDAY Carl didn’t do much better on Tuesday when he managed to violate Model Rules 1.8, 1.5 and the accompanying Ethical Considerations EC-1.5 (e), EC-1.6 (a) WEDNESDAY Carl appears to have disregard ABA Model rules 1.8, 7.1, 7.3 and EC-1.8 (a) THURSDAY The ABA Model Rules that were disregarded on this day were 1.5 (c), 1.1 and the Ethical Considerations for these were EC-1.1 (a), EC-1.1 (b), and EC-1.5 (f) FRIDAY Carl did not follow ABA Model Rules 1.7 (a), EC-1.7 (a). In addition to the model rules that were broken the attorney that was supervising Carl was commingling funds from the client trust account to pay Carl his paycheck 2. I have reviewed all of the comments I had made pertaining to the 5 days that Carl had spent at the law office and I believe that one of the most serious events that had taken place was when Carl had asked for his paycheck on Friday and Attorney Howe did not have the cash resources on hand to pay him the paycheck so he took the money out of the client trust account which is also referred to as commingling which is not only unethical but is also a criminal offense....

Words: 280 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Thinking Critically Simulation Review

...Thinking Critically Simulation Review Paper MGT/350 July 5, 2011 Thinking Critically Simulation Review Paper Thinking Critically Simulation will test the ability of a manager, in real world scenarios. Using learned knowledge to diagnose the correct problem, while using techniques and other tools to solve the underlining issues. First this simulation applies the decision making techniques and evaluation tools in solving the problems that arise in this business model. Second this simulation teaches mangers in developing the techniques; that will assist them in making decision that will generate a more predictable outcome. Third this simulation will take in account the decision making steps and use the decision making worksheets to evaluate the findings in the simulation. Finally, the assignment will assist future managers on the basic process of managing developing techniques and decision making skills in becoming a better leader and manager that uses critically thinking in making business decisions. The first phase of the simulation the team was designated for the most challenging assignment that Linda James had to offer. Our team took charge of a company with numerous issues. Some issues the company was facing included: declining sales, employee attrition, legal action, inventory, product mix, variable pay, and Wide Area Network (WAN) problems. Aware of the background of this company and knowing the symptoms Credenhill is experiencing, our team identified and evaluated...

Words: 1120 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Thinking Critically

...Alysha Adams SCH-150 Herb Samuels February 8, 2016 Alcoholics Anonymous: The Reality If ever you find yourself in fear of alcoholism, you then become tasked with finding a way out of the downward spiral that your life has or will become. There are many programs and rehabilitation strategies that have claimed to have a great benefit against alcoholism. Being an alcoholic used to be a war that you fought alone, but after attending an Alcoholics Anonymous meeting, I now know that group support can be a great benefit towards the battle to sobriety. At Alcoholics Anonymous, you no longer need to be afraid of fighting alcoholism alone and in the dark. The ideals that the program upholds hold the keys to helping you get back to who you need and deserve to be. What is Alcoholics Anonymous Alcoholics Anonymous is a recovery program that focuses on one prime objective. The group has no leader or governmental structure. They are not looking to sway you to a certain religious purpose or any political stance. Alcoholics Anonymous’ primary purpose is to help others with a problem with alcoholism to get sober. Alcoholics Anonymous began in Akron, Ohio in 1935. At this time there were only two men with a brand new idea. These two men were problematic alcoholics and found that helping others get sober helped them stay sober. After four years of helping and encouraging more and more to get sober, the nameless society grew and released its first......

Words: 1440 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Thinking Critically About Ethics

...Graded Project Thinking Critically About Ethics By Mike Wilson, Esq. Reviewed by Brian Bastyr, Esq. All terms mentioned in this text that are known to be trademarks or service marks have been appropriately capitalized. Use of a term in this text should not be regarded as affecting the validity of any trademark or service mark. About the Author Mike Wilson is a freelance writer and college instructor who has had wide legal and educational experience. He graduated with his Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Kentucky in 1976, and three years later received his law degree from the same school. He has been a partner in a law firm, a solo practitioner, and has done work in General and Family Mediation. He has also been a fulltime instructor in Paralegal Studies at Sullivan College, Kentucky. He was given the “Teacher of the Year” award in 1997. Mr. Wilson has published a number of papers on law-related topics in scholarly and popular journals. About the Reviewer Brian Bastyr is a senior attorney editor for West Group, a legal publishing company. He earned a bachelor’s degree at the University of Illinois, and a Juris Doctor from the University of Illinois College of Law. He is currently a member of the Illinois bar, and has published a number of articles in legal journals. Copyright © 2000 by Penn Foster, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of the material protected by this copyright may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by......

Words: 3548 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Reading Critically

...Chapter 4 How do I read critically? "Critical Reading" VS. just "Reading" In this chapter, you will learn how to approach a variety of reading situations with a critical eye . How to Analyze Text: Recognize the following Five Stylastic Features: ⦁ Sentence Type, Length, and Complexity ⦁ Word Choice ⦁ Tone ⦁ Point of View ⦁ Intertextuality Ask Youself... Who is the Audience? Is the text written for a general audience or a specific audience? By knowing who the audience is, we can determine what the author is trying to accomplish Where was it published? Is the text written to persuade? What does the written want us to do or think afte reading their text? What do we know about the authors background or credibility? What promoted the author to write this text? Some ways that we we identify what promoted the author would be an event, circumstance, or social practice. Guidelines for the Reading Process 1. Remember what we learned about the text from what questions we had about the text. 2. Preview the text and ask youself questions about what you're reading that will help you dig deeper into the text. As you read: 1. Pay close attention to all aspects of the text and take notes 2. Identify the category 3. Identify how the ideas of the author is organized (Any pattern of development) 4.Identify Stylistic Features After you read: Identify the rhetorical context of the text by answering the following questions 1. Who is the author writing for? ...

Words: 316 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Thinking Critically

...Thinking Critically Thinking Critically An asset is someone or something that is a viable liquidity that expresses a positive value. Being a positive value to a company is a person who can analyze and execute decisions. In this simulation our team had to establish ways to overcome adversity that happens in everyday business. Establishing a value to these problems helps the understanding of how to solve intricate problems in business. Using several tools and techniques helps to develop a clear concise simulation outcome to better business. Evaluation Tools and Techniques The problem solving tools and techniques used in the simulation are importance weighting, criteria matrix, and benchmarking. In the beginning of the simulation the user is asked to categorize the problems of the store into four different categories. These categories are: urgent and critical, non-urgent and critical, urgent and non-critical, and non-urgent and non-critical. This is both an example of importance weighting and criteria matrix because the user is asked to place importance on the problems faced and then asked to place them into a matrix based on that importance. Benchmarking came in at the end of the simulation when we’re being asked to choose the metrics that will be used to measure the impacts of the decisions made previously. The problem solving tools that I would have chosen are histograms, mind mapping, and cause-and-effect (fishbone) diagrams. First I......

Words: 864 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Thinking Critically About Ethics

...MONDAY: Attorney Howe violated ABA Model Rule 1.3 by not acting with reasonable diligence and promptness in representing the clients because he was not present. He also violated ABA Model Rule 5.5(b) after Carl told him they had a new case and did not respond correctly to Carl's actions. Carl failed to present himself and his position as a paralegal which violates EC-1.7(a). Carl also accepted the case, set fees and gave legal advice to the clients, which demonstrates Unauthorized Practice of Law violating EC-1.8(a). Carl inadvertently disclosed other client’s information by letting Zeke use the phone where documents were in sight. This violates EC-1.5(a) because Carl was aware of the confidential information. Carl violated ABA Model Rule 1.6 by telling Jane not to forget about the alimony in the reception area. He also learned that Jane has a small business that the government is unaware of and pays no taxes. He did not disclose this fraudulent activity to Attorney Howe which violates EC-1.3(f), ABA Model Rule 1.6 (b2) and 4.1(b). TUESDAY: Carl continues to avoid the income issue with Jane again violating EC-1.3(f), ABA Model Rule 1.6 (b2) and 4.1(b). He is also letting her fill out the interrogatories with false statements thus violating ABA Model Rule 4.1(a). Carl answered the phone and began to repeat the client’s information while Jane was still present which violates EC-1.5(a) and (f). Carl recorded his meeting as two hours when it should have been one hour and......

Words: 571 - Pages: 3