Free Essay

The Norther Spotted Owl V. Loggin in the Pacific Northwest

In: Science

Submitted By princessM
Words 1039
Pages 5
The Northern spotted owl vs. Logging interest in the Pacific Northwest

The rich ecosystem of the old growth forest provides a home for the Northern spotted owl, and a habitat for the owl’s primary prey. However, these same towering trees of cedars and firs which serve as the owls’ habitat, is also the primary source of a multi-billion dollar logging industry. However, if the forest is destroyed due to logging, the Northern spotted owl will lose its habitat.

The Northern spotted owl has been on the rapid decline, with over half of the population being wiped out. The old growth forest, the home of the spotted owl, has become a huge income earning logging industry that has created jobs for thousands of workers. As a result of logging, approximately only 10% of the original forest remains intact leaving limited space for the already dwindling number of the owls in the region.

In response to this decline, environmentalist petitioned the US Fish and Wildlife Service to place the owl on the endangered species list, arguing that as an indicator species, the northern spotted owl is a gauge of the health of the forest that provides its habitat. Since the main threat to the spotted owl is habitat loss due to logging, the US government declared the owl as a threatened species in 1990, a move which was vehemently opposed by the timber industry, as millions of acres of Pacific Northwest forest was protected to help slow or even reverse the decline in owl numbers.

Thus, a ferocious debate ensued between the environmentalists, wanting to protect the spotted owl, and the timber industry, fighting for their economic survival. Should the Pacific Northwest’s old growth forest and the welfare of the northern spotted owl be sacrificed for the country’s economy, and the jobs of the people in the logging industry? Which should be given priority?

There is a general consensus, save for the loggers and their allies, that the breeding and survival success of the spotted owl is largely dependent on areas of the old growth forest. The forest provides the naturally occurring platforms that the birds used for nesting. These platforms are large enough to hold the female and the young and also high enough to protect the birds from terrestrial predators. Furthermore, the old growth forest provides a multi-layered canopy which creates cooler temperatures which are ideal for the spotted owl.

Moreover, the environmental groups believed that the owl and its habitat are of great value in terms of providing opportunities for future research. To allow their demise would mean the loss of the opportunity to explore this impressive ecosystem, and the benefits generated by new discoveries.

Saving the spotted owl will save an entire ecosystem on which plants, other animals and humans depend. The steady decline of the owl indicates the demise of other species, such as elk and other flying squirrel, that inhabit these forests, and also the disruption of productive forces of nature that sustain human life. The ancient forest plays a crucial role in the prevention of soil erosion, floods, and landslides. It also provides clean water for agriculture and cities, and enriching the soil with vital nutrients and enhancing the green house effect. No amount of reforestation can replace this highly developed and diverse ecosystem, which has taken many, many years to evolve.

While the environmentalist agree that saving the owl’s habitat could cost jobs, they argue that these same jobs will be lost anyway. If clear cutting continues at its current rate of 125,000 acres a year, the old growth forest will be completely gone within 30 years and the mills forced to close down anyhow.

On the other hand, the timber industry maintains that the harm that will be done is greater than the benefits of saving the owl. Should logging in the old growth forest be reduced, many Americans, and in particular communities in the Pacific Northwest, will be harmed. These forest is a primary source of timber for most of the independent lumber mills in the northwest.

If the volume of logging in the old grown declines, many, many jobs could be lost, thereby leading to increased rates of domestic disputes, crime, vandalism, delinquency and other social ills. Additionally, consumer prices for wood will rise significantly.

To further support their cause, the timber industry point out that the use of second growth wood as an alternative is not viable because the second growth is less strong, as well as being knotty and twisted. Consequently, it cannot be used to produce many products, such as fine furniture and musical instruments, requiring the high quality old growth wood characterized by fine straight lines and few knots.

It is important that the specie is protected as wildlife plays an important role in maintaining the health of the forest. Clear cutting is ecologically unsound as it destroys a complex ecosystem and in the process not only destroy the owls’ habitat, but also endanger many of the species which rely on it. However, the protection of the spotted owl was far from catastrophic as many feared. Despite the loss of jobs in the timber industry, many of the workers found jobs elsewhere, some returned to school and get formal education, and even self-employed. Consequently, the actual number of people who lost their jobs is a far cry from the inflammatory predictions that as many as 100,000 to 150,000 people would be out of work.

In conclusion, reaching middle grounds between the environmentalists and loggers would abate the controversy between the parties; however this has proven to be a difficult feat. The timber industry’s arguments imply that while the owl has the right to survive, the loggers have more right to employment. The Environmental groups do not challenge the right of the loggers; they just ascribe more value to the rights of owl.

As such, if logging reduction in the old-growth forest is in concert with aid to assist those who are entirely dependent on timber, I foresee a viable compromise between the parties. The spotted owl will survive and the loggers will get some assistance to cushion the effect of losing their jobs.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Early Pacific Northwest History

...The first three major eras of the Pacific Northwest show some remarkable changes. What begins with the first people rapidly becomes a barrage of settlers, development and the harvesting of resources. Each period of time in the PNW brings changes in the people, the geography, and the culture. First is the Era of the First People. Scientific theories suggest that man first came to the PNW via land bridges from Russia or perhaps waterways. Some legends suggest a similar nomadic journey following the migrating animals or the work of spirits or Gods who created companions for a lonely human; usually a mother figure. However they came to be, the First People, while split into different geographical and cultural groups, had many things in common. These groups: the Costal, Plateau, and Basin Indians, all used the resources of the PNW to their advantage. For the most part, all depended on hunting and gathering for food and resources. The Basin Indians, with more limited resources, did have to forage for food and resources at times. Salmon was favored heavily for both a food source and in various ceremonies. Each group had domesticated animals: horses, dogs, or sheep. The changes in this era are more focused on the growth of cultures and of population; establishing societies. The Coast Indians were separated geographically from other native peoples. They had their own local forms of society and government involving a very class conscious social......

Words: 1001 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Honda Giken Kogyo Kabushiki Kaisha V Allied Pacific Motor (M) Sdn Bhd

...nda Giken Kogyo Kabushiki Kaisha v Allied Pacific Motor (M) Sdn Bhd [HCM] 11/25/12 [2005] Part 1 Case 14 [HCM] Coram Judgment HIGH COURT OF MALAYA Honda Giken Kogyo Kabushiki Kaisha - vs Allied Pacific Motor (M) Sdn Bhd 22 MARCH 2003 SURIYADI HALIM OMAR J Suriyadi Halim Omar, J 1. The plaintiff has applied for an interlocutory injunction before me relying on infringements of its registered industrial designs and copyright works, by defendants, as the causes of action. Simply put two types of infringement have occurred. The first cause of action i.e. the infringement of the registers industrial designs in Malaysia relates to the following registrations: 1. No MY 01-00265 for a motor scooter (registered on December 7, 2000); 2. No MY 01-00278 for the rear combination lamp (registered on December 7, 2000); 3. No MY 01-00280 for a motor scooter (registered on December 7, 2000); 4. No MY 01-00281 for leg shields of a motor scooter (registered on December 7, 2000); and 5. No MY 01-00290 for handle cover equipped with lights of a motor scooter (registered on December 7, 2000). Hereinafter these 5 designs will be referred to as "the registered industrial designs" or merely "designs"). 2. The abovementioned designs infringement here pertained to parts of a motorcycle and the vehicle proper, embodied in the plaintiffs Honda Wave 125 model, allegedly imitated by the defendants under its own version known as Comel Manja JMP 125 (see...

Words: 7165 - Pages: 29

Free Essay

Snowy Owls of the Arctic

...Snowy Owls of the Arctic By BadWolf2 Zoology 101 Description of Snowy Owls Scientific name Recently changed genus General size and markings Differences between males and females Diet Primary diet and quantity Hunting Diurnal, not nocturnal Area of hunting ground Decline of food source Breeding Mates for life Protection of nesting area Normal clutch size Food availability effects on clutch size Migration How far do they travel for food? A population decline or local extinction The snowy owl is a larger raptor type carnivorous bird whose body height is between 20 and 28 inches high. The wingspan of this owl reaches 4.2 to 4.8 feet across and its weight is between 3.5 to 6.5 pounds (“Snowy Owls”, 2012). The genus of this bird has recently been changed from Nyetea Scandiata to Bubo Scandiacus from analyzing their DNA they have found that they are more closely related to the Great Horned Owl which makes them a Bubo ("Snowy Owl," n.d.). The snowy owl is also known by other names such as the Arctic owl or the Great White owl. Most people know the snowy owl from the Harry Potter movies and the character Hedwig. Many snowy owls look this way. The younger owls are white with darker markings and as they age they lose the dark markings and become almost completely white. Females, on the other hand, do not lose all their dark markings. They may become whiter as they age, but still retain some darker or grayish marks on their plumage (“Snowy Owls”, 2012)....

Words: 1316 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Sound Owl

...The story format I would choose for telling this story would be package. I choose packaging as my format because I feel like it will be great with the A roll technique which involves interviewing, which is something I am great at and have prior experience with since I worked as journalist and an editor for my high school news paper, interviewing some of the Ornithologists who have knowledge about this snowy owl would be able to great way to provide better insight on the subject, especially since my angle of the story would be to see why they think the snowy owl has been migrating in an unfamiliar way. Interviewing the Ornithologists will introduce the subject to the audience and will help us come to a conclusion on what is causing the migration. I will also interview some of the locals who have spotted the snowy owl and get their opinion on them as well. Since this is a story for the Cincinnati Enquirer the audience is mainly news watchers so this type of format will be keep the story short and strictly to the point and will help guide the viewers better to the topic as well. I do not think the format of video diary would be great for this story because I do not think that it would be as educational as I would like it to be and I believe that video diary is most effective if the story covers a person about his or her life experiences. Like I mentioned this story is for the Cincinnati Enquirer which has an audience mainly looking for short stories or news and in this case......

Words: 354 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay


...situations, like the law and regulation, stability of the politic situation, exchange rate movements and so on. It is a risk that the corporation may not get the adequate profits from the project they had launched to cover their routine operating expenses. In Norwest’s economic perspective, the economic risk is focuses on the risk to the market value of the corporation’s balance sheet equity against the changing in interest rate, which will affect the corporation’s net worth. The corporation’s present interest rate risk and long term horizon earning trends showed the sensitivity of market value of balance sheet equity to changes in interest rate across the full maturity spectrum of the corporation. The market valuation model was used by the Northwest Corporation to measure the sensitivity of the equity’s market value towards the interest rate changes. The duration analysis is use to examines the sensitivity of the market value of the corporation’s net worth to changes in interest rates. The duration of equity indicates the market value of equity whether will rise or reduce with a change in interest rates. The longer the duration of equity, the more sensitive the market value of equity to changes in interest rates. The difference between the accounting risk and the economic risk is the measurement of risk. In accounting perspective, the simulation model is used to measure the risk instead of the market valuation model that used in economic perspective. Simulation model is a......

Words: 3080 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Northern Spotted Owl Habitat vs. Logging Interests in the Pacific Northwest

...Betty Bates AC1300186 Introduction to Ecology Assignment 8 The Northern Spotted Owl Habitat vs. Logging Interests in the Pacific Northwest The Northern Spotted Owl (Strix Occidentalis Courina) likes to live in older forest growths. It is often thought of as the medium sized owl, but in reality, it is the largest owl in North America. Spotted owls do their hunting at night. The spotted owl’s diet consists mainly of small rodents, other birds and reptiles, but have been seen feeding on cairns, and insects. Owls are usually found in California and the Pacific North West in the United States, where they live in old forest growths. (The Defenders of Wild Life). They will not tolerate habitat “disturbance” and are very protective of their territory in which they live, and hunt. Owls prefer tall trees with broken tops where they can fly under and past these broken tops, where they like to nest and raise their young. The Northern spotted owl is a protected species. Due to extensive logging, the owls and their habitat is swiftly declining at an alarming rate; they were added to the endangered species list in the early “1990s” (The Defenders of Wildlife). Unfortunately, the habitat they prefer is a direct target for the logging industry the cutting of trees in their habitat, conversion of land, wind storms, and wildfires have decreased their numbers“( example: 100 pair in British Columbia, 1200 pair in Oregon, 560 pair in Northern California, and 500......

Words: 584 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Spotted Owl

...Petition for Change to Diploma Document Petition summary and background | Since this document represents many years of study and thousands of dollars, we are requesting that a customary scholarly font be used to distinguish the recipient. This will reflect appropriately, the achievements earned at this accredited institution of higher learning. Keeping with the formalities of the ritual of the cap and gown, the scholarly style of lettering is also an academic ceremonial tradition and should not be disregarded. | Action petitioned for | We, the undersigned, are concerned students who urge our BOR to act now to order the change of the current font used for all receipts names, on all future graduation degree documents. In keeping of the academic tradition, we request our names be inscribed on the document in a formal calligraphic font which is appropriate for this application; rather than the currently used plain block primary font. | Printed Name | Signature | Address | Comment | Graduation Date | | | Black Hills State University Student | | | | | Black Hills State University Student | | | | | Black Hills State University Student | | | | | Black Hills State University Student | | | | | Black Hills State University Student | | | | | Black Hills State University Student | | | | | Black Hills State University Student | | | | | Black Hills State University Student | | | | | Black Hills State University Student | |...

Words: 286 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products Lp V. Kimberly-Clark Corporation, Et Al., 647 F.3d 723 (2011)

...Case: Georgia-Pacific Consumer Products LP v. Kimberly-Clark Corporation, et al., 647 F.3d 723 (2011) Facts: Georgia-Pacific has been selling its Quilted Northern brand toilet paper with “Quilted Diamond Design” since the early 1990s and has several trademarks, copyrights, and utility and design patents for the Quilted Diamond Design.In 2008, Kimberly-Clark redesigned two of its brands, Cottonelle Ultra and Scott Kimberly-Clark Professional, using a quilted pattern that Georgia-Pacific believes to be very similar to its Quilted Diamond Design. Georgia-Pacific claimed unfair competition and trademark infringement under the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1051 et seq. and filed suit in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois. Kimberly-Clark filed a Motion for Summary Judgment claiming the design was functional and could not be protected. Virginia M. Kendall, the presiding judge, agreed and granted summary judgment in favor of Kimberly-Clark. Issue: Can Georgia-Pacific hold utility patents, which detail functionality of design, and still have the protection of a registered trademark for its “Quilted Diamond Design”? Rule: Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1052 (e)(5) - No trademark by which the goods of the applicant may be distinguished from the goods of others shall be refused registration on the principal register on account of its nature unless it consists of a mark which comprises any matter that, as a whole, is functional. Analysis: The court looked...

Words: 461 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Owl

...The Owl By Jackie Kay Will a dear kinship´ be the way to adapt to life and overcome fears and challenges? This is by all accounts the case in Jackie Kay's short story "Owl" written in 2012, where the two fundamental characters together experience a youth occasion covering with an experience with an owl. The story lets us know how both of these episodes shapes the fellowship between the principle characters and how it turns into a long lasting walk together in this life additionally a trip into their very own dreamland. The short story is composed in the first individual. This implies the story is told by the fundamental character Barn, or Anita as she is truly called. This dialog is totally in the middle of Barn and (Tawny's real name is Marion). This artistic gadget is an approach to show that it is just about both of them, Barn and Tawny – whatever is left of the world does not by any stretch of the imagination make a difference. The way that we just get a knowledge and catch wind of the two ladies life for instance their youth, makes a closer connection with both of them and in the meantime we as readers gets removed from others. This is additionally why that the storyteller makes intensely utilization of the individual pronoun 'we'. It frames a connection between the reader and the fundamental characters, which is Barn and Tawny. Another thing that is characteristic of the narrative technique is the suddenly change of scenes. This is seen in the following: “I’d......

Words: 1096 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

The Timber Industry in the Pacific Northwest

...The Timber Industry in the Pacific Northwest The timber boom in the Pacific Northwest began in 1900 when Frederick Weyerhauser, along with fifteen partners purchased 900,000 acres of land from the Great Northern Railway. During the early years, the industry had very little concern for the damage they were doing. They concentrated on how to maximize profit and production. The United States Forestry Service’s first attempts at regulating the industry was to strip all “old growth” to allow for “new growth”, but actually did more harm than good. The new trees did not grow fast enough to replace the older trees being removed so the regulation had the opposite effect. With the United States entry into World War II, any attempts at government regulation went by the wayside as the timber industry increased the production to meet the wartime timer demand. The invention of the gas powered chain saw and the availability of heavy equipment sped up the process even more. One harmful effect caused by the removal of the old growth trees was the destruction of the habitat of the Northern Spotted Owl. However, it wasn’t until June, 1990 that this owl was placed on the threatened species list by the United States Fish and Wildlife Service. The plywood mill located in Lebanon, OR changed ownership 4 times between 1941 and 1985. In 1967 it was purchased by Champion International Corporation. In 1985, Champion decided that certain timber areas......

Words: 1444 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

New Pacific Timber V Seneris (Negotiable Instruments)

...New Pacific Timber v Seneris (Negotiable Instruments) NEW PACIFIC TIMBER & SUPPLY COMPANY, INC. v SENERIS G.R. No. L-41764 December 19, 1980   FACTS:   Petitioner, New Pacific Timber & Supply Co. Inc. was the defendant in a complaint for collection of money filed by private respondent, Ricardo A. Tong. In this complaint, respondent Judge rendered a compromise judgment based on the amicable settlement entered by the parties wherein petitioner will pay to private respondent P54,500.00 at 6% interest per annum and P6,000.00 as attorney's fee of which P5,000.00 has been paid. Upon failure of the petitioner to pay the judgment obligation, a writ of execution worth P63,130.00 was issued levied on the personal properties of the petitioner. Before the date of the auction sale, petitioner deposited with the Clerk of Court in his capacity as the Ex-Officio Sheriff P50,000.00 in Cashier's Check of the Equitable Banking Corporation and P13,130.00 in cash for a total of P63,130.00. Private respondent refused to accept the check and the cash and requested for the auction sale to proceed. The properties were sold for P50,000.00 to the highest bidder with a deficiency of P13,130.00.   Petitioner subsequently filed an ex-parte motion for issuance of certificate of satisfaction of judgment which was denied by the respondent Judge. Hence this present petition, alleging that the respondent Judge capriciously and whimsically abused his discretion in not granting the requested......

Words: 849 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Totems on Pacific Northwest

...Alyssa LaFace ARTE 220 3/9/16 Totems of the Pacific Northwest Totems are carved Redwood Cedar trees and used in the Potlatch ceremonies of families of the Pacific Northwest. Paint for the totems comes from pigments in nature, and like the carved animals, colors are symbolic as well. The natural ingredients mixed with oil from salmon eggs created easy application. Totems were carved to represent the emblem of the family as a reminder of its history. A totem is carved and placed to honor its ancestors, the clan’s standings, rights and accomplishments, to record as memorable ceremony or record a spiritual experience. A totem pole is a symbol of the qualities, experiences, and exploits of the clan. The red Earth Museum states, “The totem carvings tells a story, revealed only if one knows the meaning assigned to various animals, fish, birds and designs. There were a number of reasons why a particular figure or design was chosen by a chan. The connection between the clan and the various figured carved into the pole may have been as a result a special gift from the animal, fish, or bird spirits.” Northwest Symbol states, “Understanding the symbolism and stories hidden within the totem pole is more than a simple exercise in learning the attributed meanings of the figures. Each crest or symbol has its own story and is carefully arranged beginning at the bottom. The viewer will recognize the design of each animal depicted, but in order to tell the story, you need to know the story or...

Words: 646 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Plate Tectonics and the Pacific Northwest

...Plate Tectonics & the Pacific Northwest April Pilcher 7/18/16 GLG/150 Anna Foutz Plate Tectonics & the Pacific Northwest Plate tectonics is a scientific theory that tries to explain the movements of the Earth’s lithosphere that formed all of the landscape features we see today. The theory of plate tectonics says that the Earth’s lithosphere is made up of individual plates that are broken down into over a dozen different sized pieces of solid rock. The theory of plate tectonics was first discovered by Alfred Wegener in the 20th century. Wegener figured out that all of the continents seemed to have similar edges leading him to believe that the continents were once all connected. He called this a supercontinent and named it Pangaea. He believed that the continents of Pangaea started drifting apart about 300 million years ago and was later known as Continental Drift. ("", 2016). The Pacific Northwest has a lot of tectonic activity causing many earthquakes. The three tectonic plates that influence these earthquakes are The North America, Juan De Fuca, and the Pacific plate. These three plates make up what is called the Cascadia Strain. The most common damaging earthquakes in Washington and Oregon are deep earthquakes from Juan De Fuca. These earthquakes occur when Juan De Fuca starts to bend and plunge underneath North America. Stresses cause faults in the down going crustal part of the plate causing it to rupture. The Cascadia Subduction Zone...

Words: 986 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Pacific Northwest History

...Over the course of Pacific Northwest history, there have been various cultural expectations that have influenced the encounters between the many groups of peoples living in the Pacific Northwest. The Native Americans, Europeans, Mexican born Spanish, and American people have encountered cultural differences amongst each other for several centuries. First, curiosity was the driving force behind exploration. The New World still had an undiscovered area in the Northwest, the last frontier. The curious minds of expanding nations would send them on several endeavors to stake claim to this unknown portion of the world. According to Weber, the Spanish were the first to reach the Pacific Northwest, preceding all other European powers in exploring the coastlines of Oregon, Washington, and British Columbia (Terra Northwest, 3). In 1493, through Papal donation, Spain staked claim to the west coast for the sole navigation rights to the Eastern Pacific. As Schwantes described, Spain was the preeminent power in the Pacific basin for nearly three centuries after 1493, but concentrated its attention on the Pacific coast south from Mexico and on equatorial trade routes linking its American empire and the Philippines (Schwantes, 42). Exploratory voyages were deployed on occasion over the next three hundred years. During this time Juan de Fuca discovered the Strait of Juan de Fuca in 1592 and later Juan Perez would explore and claim the Pacific Northwest for Spain in 1774—where the Nootka......

Words: 1475 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Spotted Owl and the Pacific Northwest Loggers

...Northern spotted owl is one of those precious gems. As its population declines due to deforestation, conservationists fight the timber industry. However, pointing fingers at Pacific Northwest loggers, Americans who work hard for their families, doesn’t seem to be solving the crisis. Spotted owls make their homes within the old-growth forests of the Pacific Northwest. Massive trees, (cedars, firs, hemlocks and spruces to name a few), sink their roots deep into the soil. These aging trees serve to prevent landslides, erosion and give homes to the many forest creatures. 150 years of logging has left a mere ten percent of these forests. Fewer trees mean fewer spotted owls. Forced to live in “cluster habitats”, or small pieces of protected forest, young owls have little territory to disperse to and their survival rate has dropped. “If habitat destruction is halted soon, there will therefore be some owls left after 100 or even 200 years, barring other catastrophes ( Doak, 1989.)” Throughout Washington and Oregon about 2,500 to 3,000 pairs of Northern spotted owls still reside in old growth. Their numbers continue to plummet. The Pacific Northwest depends greatly upon independent and large timber companies. As a whole, the multi-billion dollar industry eradicates 125,000 acres of old-growth forest each year. This sturdy wood not only supports U.S. demand, but also supplies wood to lumber-poor countries such as Japan. While environmentalists push for reduced logging, Northwest......

Words: 651 - Pages: 3