Free Essay

Silence Is Power

In: Social Issues

Submitted By mollswild
Words 1072
Pages 5
Molly Wilder
Professor Barros
FYS: Revised essay 1
October 5, 2011

Silence is Power

It was a beautiful Sunday morning and the entire church of St. Louis in Batesville, Indiana, was full. There was nothing unusual about the Catholic mass that day—the congregation was alive, music echoed triumphantly, and the sermon was enthusiastic and thought provoking for all. Everything went as it typically does until the end when it was time for the weekly announcements. Instead of news about an upcoming fish fry or a congratulations message for a recently baptized newborn baby in the parish, one of our priests, Father Stephen, came out of the vestibule to the podium. He had recently been “demoted” in his role at the parish, but no one would have expected the extent to which his bitter words would be revealed to the congregation. Father Stephen stood at the podium on the altar while giving his speech of resignation from the parish. It was clear that he was frustrated and annoyed at his recent demotion, and he portrayed this dissatisfaction through a harsh speech. The purpose of this essay is to examine the discourse of the priest’s speech. I will discuss its passionate nature and its brevity--how the speaker conceals information from the listeners and what this means. We will use this evidence to argue how silence demonstrates more power than the actual power the priest possesses. * 1
2
3

1
2
3

“Over the past 25 years of my Priestly ordination and service, I have never struggled with a departing message to the various communities and institutions I served as I did with this message, very short though it is. This is for two obvious reasons. First, because its nature and circumstances are uniquely different from when I would simply announce my transfer! Secondly, because I feel more for you, the good parishioners of St. Louis Parish, Batesville, than I feel for myself.
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
It is no longer news to you about the decision by which my status as Associate Pastor has been changed to Sacramental Assistance. After a careful review of the terms, and other logistics prompted by the said new status, I am clear; this change is disproportionately very unfair to me! * Based on this development, I have decided in full consultation with my Bishop back in Nigeria, to voluntarily withdraw my services from St. Louis Parish, Batesville, and the Archdiocese where I have gratefully served for the past five years; effective at the end of this month, August, 2011.” * Norman Fairclough argues in “Discourse and Power” that language, “in” and “behind” discourse, is the reason individuals possess power-- people are able to manipulate their words (language) to feel as if they are in control. In accordance to Fairclough’s argument, I am able to relate his discussion to Father Stephen’s speech in that hidden power is produced when there is a ‘one-sidedness’ in the discourse—“the actual viewers or listeners or readers have to negotiate a relationship with the ideal subject” (41). * I will begin analyzing the speech by first examining how the speaker holds the power. Father Stephen, the giver/producer of the speech, automatically holds power over his audience, the church congregation, because he is the person in control of the matter at hand. Also, he possesses power because of the position he occupies within the institution of the Catholic Church. This particular situation was not a dialogue—the congregation was not able to respond or react publically following the priest’s speech. The listeners, including myself, felt subordinate, powerless, and unable to do anything to discuss in further detail the message of the speech. The speaker’s motive was to inform the Church of his dissatisfaction, which turned out to be enough to resign from his duties at St. Louis Parish and move elsewhere. * To further our exploration of Father Stephen’s motives, I will examine the speaker’s use of punctuation and emotive diction, although this may initially seem like a minor detail. In his address, Father Stephen was brief, yet passionate. First I will examine the exclamation points throughout the speech. For example, he says “this change is disproportionately unfair to me!” (10) and “because its nature and circumstances are uniquely different from when I would simply announce my transfer!” (5). Father Stephen uses these emotional phrases in an attempt to receive understanding from his subordinate audience, which creates within himself a sense of authority. * What we must be careful not to forget is that the speaker fails to tell his audience why he feels the way he does. Why is “this change disproportionately unfair” to him? Why are “its nature and circumstances uniquely different…”? There is ambiguity in the discourse—he never announces why he is leaving the parish. By omitting this information, the speaker’s “silence”—or lack of explaining the whole truth-- demonstrates more power than the actual power he possesses while giving the speech. * Father Stephen’s discourse can be examined in direct accordance to Fairclough. As seen in Fairclough’s example given in “Discourse and Power” about media discourse, the producers can “determine what is included and excluded, how events are represented, and even the subject positions of their audiences” (42). Father Stephen does exactly this in his own speech: he demonstrates the “power to disguise power…the power to constrain content: to favor certain interpretations and ‘wordings’ of events, while excluding others…a form of hidden power” (43). Ultimately, his message shelters the parishioners from the whole truth because he chose to omit information that the parishioners have the right to know. * Granted the obvious factor that Father Stephen held the power in the situation as described, I have discussed further the existence of a hidden power— silence. The speaker in this case demonstrates the most potency through his silence about certain facts. This power is more valuable because-- as we conclude by studying Norman Fairclough—only the speaker is able to choose what to say and what to refrain from discussing. Thus, the audience is automatically placed at a subordinate level because they are unable to respond or react to the comments stated and are unable to be informed about other vital information because of the way in which the speaker conceals it.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Silence and Solitude

...tersebut, jenis disiplin rohani solitude dan silence-lah yang jarang dan sulit dipraktekkan dalam rangka mengembangkan spiritualitas Kristen meskipun sudah banyak literatur Kristen yang membahas dan menganjurkan jenis disiplin rohani ini. Sebenarnya, disiplin rohani seperti apakah solitude dan silence itu? Apakah benar-benar Alkitabiah? Mengapa sulit dan jarang dilakukan? Bagaimana membedakan disiplin rohani solitude dan silence dengan praktek-praktek non-Kristen yang hampir serupa? Bagaimana cara mempraktekkan disiplin rohani ini? Makalah ini dibuat untuk menjawab pertanyaan-pertanyaan di atas. Walaupun solitude dan silence dapat dibahas sebagai dua jenis disiplin rohani yang berbeda, tapi dalam makalah ini, keduanya akan dibahas sebagai sebuah kesatuan praktek disiplin rohani. Permasalahan yang dibahas hanya dibatasi pada disiplin rohani solitude dan silence itu sendiri walaupun dalam prakteknya berkaitan dengan disiplin rohani yang lain seperti doa, meditasi dan puasa. Makalah ini juga tidak akan menyajikan perbandingan yang mendetail antara solitude dan silence dengan praktek-praktek non-Kristen yang dikatakan hampir serupa. II. DEFINISI SOLITUDE DAN SILENCE Dallas Willard mengelompokkan solitude dan silence ke dalam kategori disiplin pemantangan/pertarakan (discipline of abstinence). Solitude adalah kegiatan menyendiri untuk sementara waktu secara fakultatif demi mencapai tujuan rohani; sedangkan silence adalah kegiatan abstensi berbicara untuk......

Words: 1999 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Sins by Silence

...Sins by Silence Sins by silence This is a film about women who killed their husbands because of heated passion, prolonged abuse physical and mental. It offers a unique gateway that touches the lives of women who have experienced tragedy in their lives’ worst-case scenarios. These women have committed heinous crimes by killing their abusive husbands. Getting rid of abusive husbands is morally wrong and does not conquer with ethical standards as far as the society is concerned. A good alternative would be to get a divorce or separation where each party would go separate ways without bothering the other. Moreover, there are several solutions of dealing with an abusive husband. One of them would be to sue by presenting him in a court of law. After reviewing the evidence presented, the judges would determine the corrective action, which might either be a sentence or fine. The second way to deal with an abusive husband is to seek for divorce. This would be a good option if both parties are not happy living with each other. A divorce will lead to separation where both parties will lead separate lives the best way they know how. It will also allow the parties to remarry and lead a happy life thereafter. Another way is to seek the help of a counselor. A counselor would offer advice and solution to the affected marriage. He/she might help change the character of the abusive husband, which might change for ever. Committing murder is not a solution. Many women who fall victims......

Words: 845 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Silence by Shusako Endo

...Cowley Paper #1 During the sixteenth, seventeenth, and eighteenth century the primary driving force for all cultures can be summed up by one simple word, and that word is greed. Many of the countries that had power at the time were greedy savages and all they wanted was more land and power. Countries that were powerful at the time were Spain, Portugal, Japan, and others. Also in the countries the governing body of them had their way or the highway they did not care what had to be done or who had to be killed. If the ruler of a certain country did not like something they did not care what had to be done to stop it. Powerful countries at the time such as Spain and Portugal only cared about power and one word that sums them up is greed. During the sixteenth, seventeenth, and eighteenth century Spain was one of the most powerful countries. When Columbus set sail in 1492, he founded the Americas and all that came with the, such as gold spices, and other expenses, this is how Spain became extremely rich and powerful. This land that Columbus founded was known as the New World. It is described by Michel de Montaigne in Of Cannibals "  New World so lately discovered: for that almost touched upon Spain, and it were an incredible effect of an inundation, to have tumbled back so prodigious a mass, above twelve hundred leagues." Columbus was known for founding the Americas, the truth was he set sail for the Indies. When he landed in the America's he thought it was the Indies. As...

Words: 1525 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

The Dirty Harry Syndrome/ the Code Silence

...ABSTRACT: This paper will discuss the different types of forced that is used in law enforcement as well how officers demonstrate unethical behaviors, corruption, and crossing the line of misconduct. The Dirty Harry Syndrome and Code of Silence will also be discussed in this paper. As early as twenty-five years ago the primary tools were shot guns, small caliber guns as well limited chemicals sprays and hand guns. Night sticks and black jacks also known as Billie clubs have been in existence for many years and were once the only weapons that were used by law enforcement. As criminal activity has advanced so has technology to fight it. Things such as stun guns, martial arts, aerosol sprays which we know as pepper spray as well as more powerful hand guns are weapons that have been introduced and given to the law enforcement agencies we have today. Even with the latest technology in weapons that is offered agencies still have great difficulty in being able to adequately use them. Due to budget constraints training is not always available and when agencies don’t receive proper training it results in lawsuits due to officers mistakes and possibly misconduct. When an agency cuts back on training lives are lost as well as careers, moral is weakened and overall everyone is impacted. Knowing when and how much force to use is a question and concern many agencies face and often have many dilemmas about. The given avaible......

Words: 866 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Importance of Silence

...The Importance of silence No one should ever underestimate how important silence really is in our lives. It is very important to be silent during performances, no matter what the performance is for. If it is for speech, singing, Broadway, etc., we still need to be silent. No matter what we think, silence is a key role to many things in our lives. We always need to be silent during a performance because we are not the only person there. It is very disrespectful to be talking during a performance because it distracts the people who are actually listening to the performance. If we are talking loudly, the people might not even be able to hear the performance and enjoy it! Also, if we are talking, we will never get the chance to enjoy the performance, either. In the end, we might even have fun, but if we are talking and being disrespectful, we will never know if we would have enjoyed it or not and we could form enemies. Think about if we were the one performing. Would we want somebody being inconsiderate during our performance and not appreciating the performance? Also, we would not want the people talking to distract the other people watching us because, then, nobody will appreciate the hard work we put into to make the performance a great success. As we can see, being silent is very important during performances and if we are silent, the performance will be amazing! In the end, the choir and the program will get the full credit they truly deserve. The performance will be a......

Words: 304 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Lies of Silence

...of Silence Written Assignment PAIR WORK Marc & Mikael 2.a. Historical Context The conflict in Ireland and Northern Ireland is a long on going conflict about religion and most importantly whether or not Ireland should be a part of the United Kingdom. The background for the conflict can be dated all the way back to 1169 when the English king Henry the second invaded the country. The conflict in Ireland or the so-called “ The troubles” was a conflict from 1968-1998. On April 10. They made an agreement to a cease-fire. The agreement was called the Belfast agreement and it was a principal agreement of a peace process between the British and Irish governments. The two largest apposing paramilitary groups was the IRA who where fighting for the republic of Ireland and the Ulster defence association (UDA/UFF) who were the largest paramilitary and vigilante group in Northern Ireland. They both conducted terror actions such as bombings etc. against each other and civilians. Sinn Féin is an Irish republican party in Northern Ireland and the republic of Ireland. They are often linked with the IRA, but they refuse any connections between them. Another party is the “New Ulster Political Research Group” which is the political wing of the UDA who has ben active since 1971. Another of the big parties in the Northern Ireland is the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP). The Democratic Unionist Party has since 2007 formed government with Sinn Féin. Repetition of “Lies of Silence” ...

Words: 2105 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Silence Must Be Heard

...Silence Must Be Heard Good morning and AssalamAlekum Ladies and Gentlemen. It gives me great pleasure to represent an elite university at another elite university however as I speak these words, another Christian house has been ransacked, another neighbourhood ravaged, another bus of Hazaras has been shot up, another sole breadwinner eliminated, another family has been shredded by a Hellfire missile, another father and son exterminated for their beliefs. Welcome to the |slamic Republic Of Pakistan where savagery, hate, barbarianism and injustice are the order of the day. All these maladies, all these evils which have eaten through the fabric of this diverse and varied society, hollowing its roots to an extent where the country teeters on the edge of dismemberment and obliteration are of our own making and shoot from one and one spring alone. Silence. Silence of those who were the armor of civilization, silence of those who could’ve vetoed the insatiable massacre of humanity , silence of those who proclaimed themselves selected and most importantly the silence of those who called themselves the children of Adam. This nation, this land, this state which was born from the womb of injustice, of wrong, of prejudice quickly forgot what our forefather had stood on and what slogans they had raised when , we, the populace were the ones being persecuted, subjugated. Today, decades later it is us who are the persecutors; it is us who are the subjugators. Every second ,every moment......

Words: 712 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

A Stormy Silence

...A Stormy Silence I am looking up at the vast and stormy, gray sky. The clouds are heavy; I feel like I can almost touch them from where I stand, in the middle of the school’s parking lot. Soon, the gods will cry. The air is fresh and tingles with the smell of autumn. My eyelids are heavy from days without enough sleep. However, I refuse to close them. I’ll just continue gazing at the upcoming war. … Lately I’ve been having nightmares. They keep me awake, or rather; they make me feel like I never slept at all in the first place. In my dreams, I am always standing in my own kitchen. The window is open, yet I can’t see what’s on the other side. My whole body is covered in bees. They’re swarming. Crawling around on my skin, I can sense their tiny, tickling feet. I think I’m naked, because they are everywhere. No matter how much I want to move, I can’t. If I do, I know they will start attacking me, replacing the unpleasant unawareness with a never-ending, stinging pain. When I wake up, drowsy and unguarded, the feeling of exhaustion lingers my mind. My body is and sore from the already fading memory of standing deadly still in an indefinite time of space. And so, the day begins with me, being more tired than I was the day before. … It’s getting colder, darker. My thoughts are clouded, and I find myself longing for the time of......

Words: 665 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Silence in a World of Sound

...Silence in a World of Sound: The Birds and the Bees of Hearing Impaired Life By Sam Madsen Growing up in a world of sound, I knew nothing other than rushing cars, chirping birds, shouts, screams and laughter. Three years ago, my entire world flipped upside down. I suffered a massive head trauma that led to my journey into the Hard of Hearing world and changed my life forever. When I learned of my hearing loss, I was in shock. Paired with this new lifestyle, I also found out that I have an auditory processing disorder, which would further hinder my ability to understand and comprehend sound. My first question was what many others ask when they lose their hearing late in life: am I disabled, and what will become of my future? In short, yes I am disabled, invisible to the naked eye and the unwilling ear. I do not, however, let my disability cripple me. It’s a funny concept, being invisibly disabled. Looking at me, you do not see someone that is technically disabled: you see me as an able bodied, young nineteen-year-old. I am a shielded crevice of surprises, closed off by an intricate façade, shaped together with good intentions and some not-so-gentile fingers. I put on a face like everyone else and we all have our stories each more detailed than the last. My story is not beautiful or easy to understand; there were medical problems, physical illnesses, and mental incapacitation that has brought me to the place that I currently am resting in. I have adjusted to a soft mumble...

Words: 719 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Power

...Power and Influence in the Workplace The Meaning of Power * Power is the capacity of a person, team or org to influence others * Not the act of changing someone’s attitudes or behaviors * Based on the target perception that the power holder controls * Involves the asymmetric dependence * Depends on some minimum level of trust * Trust indicates a level of expectation that the more powerful party will deliver the resource Sources of Power in Organizations * Legitimate Power * An agreement in orgs that people of certain roles can request a set of behaviors from others * Manager telling an employee what tasks to perform * Restrictions * Range in which power can be asked * Zone indifference (set of behaviors that individuals are willing to engage in at the other person’s request * Employees have this power over their bosses and coworkers through legal and administrative rights and informal norms * Norm of reciprocity: feeling of obligation to help someone who has helped them; informal rule of conduct we are expected to follow * Information Control: potent form of legitimate power * Information is a resource and those who need it depend on the gate keeper * Gate keepers gain power by selectively distributing information * Reward Power * A person’s ability to control the allocation of rewards valued by other to remove negative......

Words: 1425 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

The Silence of the Lambs

...Harris – The silence of the lambs Hannibal Lecter – psychiatrist, psychopath, purveyor of ghastly canapés – is an ambiguous presence in Thomas Harris’s Red Dragon (1981) and its sequels. Rarely the outright villain, he tends to play the role of a genteel monster with whom the reader is, scandalously, invited to sympathise. In The Silence of the Lambs, the best of Harris’s novels, the FBI requires Lecter’s insight in order to catch serial killer Buffalo Bill, who enjoys parading about in the flayed skins of his victims. Clarice Starling, a pretty trainee agent, is sent to visit Lecter in prison and charm him into offering help. Clarice Starling, still doing her years at the training academy and a part of the Bureau's behavioural sciences unit, is called upon to participate in one of the goriest, strangest cases the Bureau has ever seen. She is sent to talk to Hannibal Lecter, an ex-psychologist who is currently residing in a high security mental asylum. Lecter, having been sentenced to a whole life in an asylum due to his cannibalistic tendencies, establishes an odd sort of relationship with Starling. They work together, to track the movements and the thoughts of a fast-moving psychopath. A strange partnership emerges as secrets from Starling's past are revealed. It isn't the fact that there's a man capable of murder on the loose that scares her, it's the man who's safe behind bars that does. There's your run-of-the-mill crime novels, and then there's The Silence of the......

Words: 1201 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Power

...n one of the few in-depth treatments of power in conflict situations, Hubert M. Blalock begins by acknowledging something most of us know but rarely state: "The concept of power is both exceedingly slippery to pin down and yet indispensable in enabling one to analyze...."[1] Having defined power, as in physics, as having both potential and kinetic forms, he opts for the latter usage alone in his text. That is, he acknowledges power as both the capacity of an individual or group to accomplish something, and the actual doing of something, but he limits his discussion to "actions actually accomplished." Additional insights into understanding power are offered by Beyond Intractability project participants. This has two advantages. First, it dovetails with how most of us think about power most of the time. Second, it is easier to quantify. It is much easier to measure something that has occurred than something that is a possibility. An actual occurrence is a fact that can be checked. There may be disagreement on the sources of its occurrence, but the argument about its occurrence is likely to be short-lived if adequate facts can be brought to bear. If one side has won in a disagreement (in that it has gotten the other to do something it wanted), we have prima facie evidence that the first is more powerful -- or at least has exerted more power -- than the second. Since concerns of relative power are important in conflicts, it is helpful to have a clear picture of who......

Words: 2563 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Employee Silence

...to overcome employee silence as if it is not overcome throughout the organisations growth, many underlying problems concealed by the silence will appear out of the blue. With the growing culture of intimidation in the workforce there is also the growth of employee silence, and “the only consequence of their (employee) silence is that the blind (employer) lead the blind,” (Heffernan, 2011) this is further supported by Detert and Birrous’ statement that chances are employees are withholding valuable intelligence (2016, p. 85). Regardless whether it is intentional or unintentional from their employers the damages that an employee’s silence only promotes detrimental factors for an organisations’ future. Although employers do not purposely create a fear factor for the employees, the most frequently mentioned reason for remaining silent was the fear of being viewed or labelled negatively (Milliken, 2003 p.2). With the employees supressing of information it can lead to the rise of poorly planned projects and the loss of potential innovation that could drastically benefit the organisation. Furthermore, employee silence not only negatively affects the organisation but also affects the employees, causing the development feeling unvalued, a lack of control and a cognitive dissonance (Jacobsen 2014) from the workplace and a sensation of autopilot, these could produce slack and disregardful behaviour. (danaghey et al, 2011). A contributing factor to employee silence is the widely used......

Words: 1382 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Shaping Character with Silence

...Shaping Character with Silence Rules are not always said upfront. No chewing gum or no bouncing balls are usually signs said out loud, but what about unspoken rules? Some of them are obvious like no talking while a mass is in session. Unspoken rules make you belong; they shape the way you live and act. To belong makes you feel special, like you are not alone. In the movie “Twilight” by Stephanie Meyers there is a good example of the relationship between belonging and unspoken rules. The way the Cullen’s act and how they behave in the real world is not said out loud. The Cullen family does not state rules out loud; it is more of a “you just know how to behave by being with them.” When you are with them you feel as you belong, you feel as you have a purpose in the world. “On Being a Cripple,” Mairs is about the author and how she doesn’t hate everything because she has MS. Mairs gets through life day to day. It seems that she uses unspoken rules how to live. An unspoken rule I feel like she lives by is: Live life, because you only live it once. By doing so she belongs in the world. She knows she has a horrible disease, but it is not going to make her feel like an outcast in the world. Rules are rules whether said out loud or unspoken. When you follow them you know your spot, you know where you belong. Some people might say that unspoken rules do not make you belong there are no such thing as unspoken rules. When you become a freshman in high school there is no rule......

Words: 439 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Power

...The definition of Power as found in the Webster dictionary is said to be- to have possession or control over others; to have political or national strength. Although the theme of power is displayed throughout the plays of Macbeth, Richard III, and the Movie The Final Days, the use of power throughout the three were used and displayed in different ways. Power was used for good and bad. It was also used in different ways for different reasons to get different things done. In the play Macbeth, there are these witches that predict that Macbeth will be made thane of Cawdor and later King of Scotland. They also predict that Macbeth’s companion; heirs would later be crown king. Macbeth was captivated by what the witches told him about becoming King that he did not know what to expect or what he would do when the prediction was to become true, showing that he would not know once he grasp the power of Kingship. Couple nights later Macbeth went to go and have dinner with Duncan castle. Macbeth tells the wife of the prediction of witches about him being king and the wife takes it into her hands to try getting the crown for her husband. Lady Macbeth tells Macbeth to kill Duncan because that is the only way he will become king. She uses her power over her husband and forces him to take action and kill Duncan. When Macbeth arrives at his castle, she persuades him to kill the king that very night. After killing Duncan and the Chamberlin Macbeth receives the crown and becomes King of......

Words: 1890 - Pages: 8