Sap Implementation at Metalica: an Organizational Drama in Two Acts

In: Computers and Technology

Submitted By Napzzzz
Words 9247
Pages 37

· r & Fr a nci s G ro SAP implementation at Metalica: an organizational drama in two acts
Department of Information Systems, Weatherhead School of Management, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH 44106-7235 USA

This play attempts to reconstruct the social reality of key players at Metalica during the ® rst couple of years of SAP implementation. Rather than adopting one perspective about the SAP project, we provide the views of different participants using their own words, arguments and ideas as much as possible. The play is constructed from summaries of systematic interviews which were changed only to suit scholarly objectives and a dramatic presentation. At the request of the company involved, the names and locations in this case have been disguised. Act 1 describes the company’ s vision concerning the implementation of an enterprise resource planning (ERP) system, a crisis which emerged during the initial phase of implementation and the actions taken to remedy the shortfalls. Act 2 describes the project management, the dynamics between the implementation team members and the organizational implications of an ERP system implementation. The actual performance of the play and a subsequent discussion among the participants enable students to re-create and experience the thrills, frustrations, dilemmas and concerns originally expressed by the people who inspired this account of SAP implementation. Using theatre in an academic environment opens new avenues for critical observation, integrative sense making and experiential learning.

Act 1
Scene 1: The Vision
11 April 1996 ± at the weekly meeting of Metalica’s executive team in the Pittsburgh corporate of® ce. Spring time. A few scattered cirri cruise in the blue sky and another sunny day blesses the newly dressed trees.


Similar Documents

Organizational Innovation at Sap Labs India

...Organizational Behaviour-II Project On Organizational Innovation at Submitted to Prof. Manish Kumar Submitted by Section C Group: 6 PGP/16/128- Anand Ganesh Patil PGP/16/149- Irshad Anwar PGP/16/150- Mohamed Anas PGP/16/155- Prabhu P PGP/16/159- Ram Kumar Venkatesh PGP/16/171- Shyam Prasath B Organizational Behaviour-II Acknowledgement We would like to thank our Organizational Behaviour-II Professor Prof Manish Kumar for guiding us throughout the project and providing valuable inputs. We would also like to thank the employees and management of SAP Labs India Pvt. Ltd., Bangalore for extending their help to understand the organization and providing us valuable insights about the innovation and change process in SAP. 1|Page Organizational Behaviour-II Table of Contents 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 10. 11. 12. 13. An Overview of the Company ............................................................................................ 3 The Dilemma ...................................................................................................................... 3 Need for Innovation ............................................................................................................ 4 Organizational Innovation .................................................................................................. 4 Technological Changes....................................................................................................... 5 Products &......

Words: 2762 - Pages: 12

Applying Trompenaars Typology of Organizational Culture to Implementation of Csr Strategy

...Journal of Intercultural Management Vol. 3, No. 2, October 2011, pp. 113–125 Adrian Pyszka Michał Piłat Cracow University of Economics Applying trompenaars typology of organizational culture to implementation of csr strategy 1. Introduction Nowadays many authors declare Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) in strategic terms as it is no longer seen as the invention of some social activist but important source of competitive advantage. However various researchers still struggle to figure out what shape and utility should the tools of CSR have and what implementation model could be the best to fulfill the business objectives. The study aims to demonstrate whether Trompenaars bipolar model of organizational culture could prove useful while implementing CSR strategy and to propose some good practice in this case. 2. Theoretical framework Culture A lot has changed in world of management since 80s and many leaders tend to ask a question whether corporate culture is still important. However high interest in that area seems to be a sufficient prove that it still is. According to a recent survey by management consultancy Bain & Company, 9 of 10 senior executives believe that corporate culture is as important as strategy for business - - - - - Electronic PDF security powered by 114 Adrian Pyszka, Michał Piłat success1. Corporate culture is described as general constellation of beliefs, mores, customs, value systems and......

Words: 4847 - Pages: 20

Which Act Is More Disturbing to an Audience Watching ‘the Cut’, Act One or Act Two?

...The Cut is a dystopian play. It’s based around themes such as pain, absence of love and suffering. Both scenes are equally disturbing, however, act one is what kicks off the play and, to an extent, gives the audience an idea of what the play will be about as well as how they should feel and respond to scenes. There is a great deal of uncertainty in act one which makes the audience feel disturbed and uncomfortable. The talk of the Cut, the role of the government and their society in general makes act one a lot more disturbing to watch than act two. Paul and John’s constant mention of the Cut could make the audience feel uncomfortable because of the fact they don’t actually know what it is. “…it’s a ritual, a custom, something we…” – John is referring to the Cut here and he is describing it as though it’s a traditional thing to have done in their society, the use of the word “custom” implies that the Cut is something that their society expects the majority of people to have, the fact that the audience don’t know why makes the thought of the Cut disturbing. Contrary to John’s description of the Cut, Paul describes it as a painful thing – “the great screams as the instruments go in?” From the word “instruments” we can gather that the Cut is a form of surgery – The fact that there are two different attitudes towards the Cut alienates the audience from the play’s plot. It makes the audience question the Cut – is it a good thing or is it a bad thing? The Cut was written by......

Words: 1143 - Pages: 5

Sap for Atlam

...statement. After knowing the weakness, ATLAM has two alternatives which is ACCPAC and Petra’s group-wide SAP. ATLAM has been asked to upgrade its accounting system with the Petra group-wide SAP system. Zulkifli as ATLAM’s finance manager need to critically assess the risks associated with the decision on whether to or not to implement SAP in ATLAM. Zulkifli has arranged a meeting to discuss the new system upgrade. He had invited Sani (Project Manager), Gopal (User Project Manager), Lim (User Representative) and Kamal (Functional Analyst) to discuss about implementing SAP in ATLAM. As it shown in the case, the first meeting have not come to a mutual agreement on whether to implement SAP in ATLAM as Lim has pointed out that implement ACCPAC is a cheaper option compared to SAP that would be incurred a huge cost for ATLAM as it will becomes a financial constraint and burden to ATLAM. In second meeting, Lim stated that the SAP is impractical in ATLAM as the the company don’t even have enough computer to operate SAP and some of the ATLAM staff has never been using computer ever. Thus, even with SAP system, those employees don’t know how to even operate SAP. Zulkifli explained that the introduction of SAP need some time to adjust and suit into the business environment. By using SAP, it actually lightens and make the operation of the business more effectively and efficiently. Kamal also stand in the same view of points with Zulkifli as the SAP will enhance the business......

Words: 1333 - Pages: 6

Case Study Bridging the Two Worlds-the Organizational Dilemma

...time attending to his subordinates. Soon he began to feel very frustrated and exhausted, and often would tell his secretary that “unless the hotel is on fire, don’t let anyone disturb me.” Becker thought that the practice of empowerment would benefit the overall performance of the hotel. However, contrary to his expectations, the business and overall performance of the hotel began to deteriorate. There were an increasing number of guest complaints. In the past, the hotel had minimal guest complaints. Now there was a significant number of formal written complaints every month. Many other guests voiced their dissatisfaction to hotel employees. The number of mistakes made by employees had increased. Becker was very upset when he realized that two of the local newspapers and an overseas newspaper had published negative feedback on the hotel on service standards. He was most distressed when an international travel magazine had voted the hotel as “one of Asia’s nightmare hotels.” The stress levels of the employees continuously mounted after the introduction of the practice of empowerment. Absenteeism due to illness was increasing at an alarming rate. In addition, the employee turnover rate had reached an all-time high. The good working relationships that had established under the old management had been severely strained. The employees were no longer united and supportive of each other. They were quick to point fingers at or to backstab one another when mistakes were made and when......

Words: 7856 - Pages: 32

Sap Sd

...KAPIL SHARMA AND ASHUTOSH MUTSADDI Configuring SAP ERP Sales and Distribution ® SERIOUS SKILLS. Configuring SAP ERP Sales and Distribution ® Kapil Sharma Ashutosh Mutsaddi Acquisitions Editor: Agatha Kim Development Editor: Laurene Sorensen Technical Editor: Dheeraj Oswal Production Editor: Liz Britten Copy Editor: Kim Wimpsett Editorial Manager: Pete Gaughan Production Manager: Tim Tate Vice President and Executive Group Publisher: Richard Swadley Vice President and Publisher: Neil Edde Book Designer: Franz Baumhackl Compositor: Craig Johnson, Happenstance Type-O-Rama Proofreader: Word One, New York Indexer: Ted Laux Project Coordinator, Cover: Lynsey Stanford Cover Designer: Ryan Sneed Copyright © 2010 by Wiley Publishing, Inc., Indianapolis, Indiana Published simultaneously in Canada ISBN: 978-0-470-40473-7 No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise, except as permitted under Sections 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 646-8600. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken,...

Words: 176656 - Pages: 707

Sap Implementation

...Inquiry and Design Phase of SAP Software Cody K. Hobson Upper Iowa University Inquiry and Design Phase of the SAP System PB Leiner USA and PB Gelatins have been working for numerous years with software that is not affiliated with another. Every system carries out the essential functions needed to run each plant facility located in different parts of the world yet there is no unified connection, nothing that ties all financials together. The inquiry phase of this paper will demonstrate the areas in which the Action-Learning Team will conduct a review into the corporate wide system of PB Leiner USA and PB Gelatins looking for potential improvement points. The design phase of this paper will demonstrate the creation and process steps of what the ALT formulated based on the PIP discoveries. Inquiry Phase PB Family The PB family is made up of six facilities across the globe and is the third largest gelatin manufacturer in the world. Each PB facility thrives on creating value for customers at competitive prices and is committed to achieving the highest standards of product safety and quality. There are high expectations of close cooperation with customers while offering the necessary technical support to jointly search for solutions that fit customers’ needs in terms of product applications and technology. Possible Improvement Points within PB Each site was initially using its own Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system, which resulted in each site’s...

Words: 2720 - Pages: 11

Bridging the Two Worlds—the Organizational Dilemma

...CASE 05: BRIDGING THE TWO WORLDS—THE ORGANIZATIONAL DILEMMA William Todorovic, Purdue University I had been hired by Aluminum Elements Corp. (AEC), and it was my first day of work. I was 26 years old, and I was now the manager of AEC’s customer service group, which looked after customers, logistics, and some of the raw material purchasing. My superior, George, was the vice president of the company. AEC manufactured most its products, a majority of which were destined for the construction industry, from aluminum. As I walked around the shop floor, the employees appeared to be concentrating on their jobs, barely noticing me. Management held daily meetings in which various production issues were discussed. No one from the shop floor was invited to these meetings unless there was a specific problem. Later I also learned that management had separate washrooms and separate lunchrooms, as well as other perks that floor employees did not have. Most of the floor employees felt that management, although polite on the surface, did not really feel they had anything to learn from the floor employees. John, who worked on the aluminum slitter, a crucial operation required before any other operations could commence, had suffered a number of unpleasant encounters with George. As a result George usually sent written memos to the floor to avoid a direct confrontation with John. Because the directions in the memos were complex, these memos were often more than two pages in length.......

Words: 1176 - Pages: 5

Sap Implementation

...a good example of how leadership plays a pivotal role in the success of IS project. The strategy employed by the senior IT manager at Keda can be summarized by the following points: 1) In 2000, Keda began the process of computerizing the organization, but Keda’s decentralized decision making culture failed to design a sound roadmap for the IT projects. Dr. Fan Zhu, the vice general manager, the then in-charge of the IT department, first designed a five-year computerization plan aligning with company’s strategic goals and prioritized ERP implementation to integrate the organizational structure. 2) Dr. Fan Zhu involved senior management in the vendor selection process, and in decision making. He ensured that the management was kept in the loop on the project progress, and technical and strategic challenges. In doing so, he was able to garner the leadership support to make this project successful. 3) During ERP implementation, managers of various departments collaborated and were held responsible to meet the milestones for their own departments to make the project successful. 4) As departmental managers had to work long hours, senior management started a reward system. Employees were awarded incentives for their contribution to the project. Culture plays an important role in development of the information system and its use (Pearlson & Saunders, pg.89). As ERP systems originally developed for users in North America and Western......

Words: 426 - Pages: 2

Case Sap

...CASE: SM-153 DATE: 08/08/06 SAP AG IN 2006: DRIVING CORPORATE TRANSFORMATION Success can be seductive. It can trick us into focusing too rigidly on long-established patterns of thought. That’s why it is often so tempting to recycle yesterday’s ideas to form the guidelines and dogmas of tomorrow. I hope that we can use the right vision and strategy to avoid this trap. ⎯Henning Kagermann, CEO, SAP AG INTRODUCTION On a windy April evening in Walldorf, Germany, Henning Kagermann took a sip of his tea and picked up the 60-page document lying on his desk. Several months earlier, Kagermann, CEO of SAP AG, had tasked his Corporate Strategy Group with preparing a strategic analysis, informally nicknamed the “Sun-Tzu document” in deference to the legendary Chinese general. It outlined the strategic opportunities and challenges that SAP should expect to face between 2006 and 2010, and examined the prevailing forces shaping the enterprise software industry in 2006: technological change, consolidation, and shifting customer needs. Kagermann believed that emerging Internet-based technologies and standards known collectively as “Web services” soon would transform the $79.8 billion enterprise software applications industry, in which SAP held the leading market position.1 Although sales of SAP’s existing products had begun to rebound in 2004 after a multi-year slowdown, Kagermann had committed SAP to deploy new Web services-based technology on a massive scale by the end of 2007. (See......

Words: 19177 - Pages: 77

Sap Sap Sap Sap

...infrastructure compared to Europe and Japan. This is because ATLAM was relied on a customized single-user system which was solely for accounting entries, and it is not functioned to generate financial reports. The 1997 privatisation of ATLAM to become a subsidiary of PETRA Group of Company has provided it with an access to better IT facilities. In year 2001, the management had been asked to upgrade accounting system with the PETRA group-wide SAP system. SAP was an integrated business application package that covered most functions of an organization. This system included comprehensive functions of financial accounting, controlling, asset management, sales and distribution, materials management, human resources, plant maintenance, project system, BASIS system and so forth. Therefore, the Finance and Accounts Manager of ATLAM, Zulkifli Osman, has been asked to review the plan of implementation the SAP in ATLAM and decide whether they can upgrade their accounting system. He had to assess the risk associated with the decision as the implementation of SAP system seems to be giving big impact on the company’s financial status. Zulkifli terminate Lim is a wrong decision because Lim was contributed a lot when having the discussion. Lim is very experienced and he brought the issues that are important and should be take into consideration. Zulkifi cannot simply terminate Lim because Lim has some specify knowledge that other people don’t have. If Zulkifli terminate Lim because Lim......

Words: 345 - Pages: 2

Organizational Performance and Organizational Development Are Two Sides of the Same Coin

...ASSIGNMENT “Organizational Performance & Organizational Development are Two sides of the same Coin” Submitted to: Mr. Muhammad Ather Submitted by: Ahmed Fazeel Ghumman Muhammad Omer Sher Rana Asif Sardar Muhammad Salim Qaz INTRODUCTION Charles Perrow in his article “ The Short and Glorious History of Organizational Theory ” talks about forces of light and darkness. The forces of darkness have been represented by the “Mechanical school of organizational theory” with characteristics like Centralized authority, Clear lines of authority, Specialization and expertise, Marked division of labor, Rules and regulations, Clear separation of staff and line. And forces of light represented as “Human relations school”. and enumerates their characteristics as: Delegation of authority, Employee autonomy, Trust and openness, Concerns with the whole person and Interpersonal dynamics. Now this describes the difference between the organizational perspective of 20th century and 21st century, Forces of darkness represents the “Organization as Rationale Systems” and Forces of Light represents “Organizations as Open systems”. These two concepts of organizational theory......

Words: 3084 - Pages: 13

Hul Sap Implementation

...BUSINESS OPTIMISATION GOALS WITH SAP QUICK FACTS “With SAP NetWeaver PI, we have finally streamlined, advanced and integrated our process capability. This goes a long way in enhancing HUL’s ability to meet the demands of the modern trade.” KS Arunkumar, IT Group Manager, Hindustan Unilever Limited Summary Name: Hindustan Unilever Limited Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra, India Industry: Consumer Products Employees: 15,000 Website Key Challenges Arrival of modern trade in India Legacy systems and business infrastructure were unable to meet transaction and process capability requirements of the modern trade Project Objectives Optimise business operation and simplify IT management Achieve process consolidation internally and across the value chain Preserve investment of legacy inventory and cash-to-order management system for business partners Integrate with business partners’ IT infrastructure quickly and seamlessly Solutions and Services Phase 1: SAP ERP Central Component 5.0, SAP NetWeaver Process Integration (SAP NetWeaver PI), SAP NetWeaver Portal, SAP Supply Chain Management (SAP SCM), SAP Solution Manager, SAP NetWeaver Business Intelligence (SAP NetWeaver BI), SAP NetWeaver Composition Environment (SAP NetWeaver CE) Phase 2: SAP Customer Relationship Management, SAP Advanced Planning & Optimisation Production Planning and Detailed Scheduling, SAP Transportation Planning and Vehicle Scheduling Implementation Highlights Rollout in two phases. Phase 1......

Words: 1554 - Pages: 7

Chapter Two the Organizational Environment

... Chapter TWO THE ORGANIZATIONAL ENVIRONMENT CHAPTER CONTENTS Overview of the Chapter 2 Learning Objectives 2 Key Terms 2 Lecture Outline 3 Learning Objectives Revisited 9 Lecture Enhancers 10 Notes for Topics for Discussion and Action 12 Notes for Building Management Skills 16 Notes for Management For You 17 Notes for Small Group Breakout Exercise 17 Notes For Managing Ethically 19 Notes For Web Exercises 19 Notes for You’re the Management Consultant 19 Notes for Management Case 20 Notes for Management Case in the News from the pages of Business Week 21 Overview of the Chapter This chapter examines the organizational environment in detail. It identifies the principal forces—both task and general—that create pressure and influence management and thus affect the way organizations operate. It concludes with a study of several methods that managers can use to help organizations adjust and respond to forces in the organizational environment. Learning Objectives 1. Explain why being able to perceive, interpret, and respond appropriately to the organizational environment is crucial for managers’ success. 1. Identify the main forces in an organization’s general and task environments, and describe the challenges that each force presents to managers. 1. Discuss the main ways in which managers can manage the organizational environment. Key Terms barriers to entry brand loyalty command economy competitors customers demographic forces ...

Words: 9140 - Pages: 37

Organizational Behavior - Name Two Motivating Factors at Rbs.

...Need Answer Sheet of this Question paper, contact ARAVIND – 09901366442 – 09902787224 Organizational Behavior   Q1. Do you believe people are really getting smarter? Why or why not? Q2. Which of the factors explaining the Flynn Effect do you buy? Q3. Are there any societal advantages of disadvantages to the Flynn Effect? Q4. What performance problems is the captain trying to correct? Q5. Use the MARS model of individual behavior and performance to diagnose the possible causes of the unacceptable behavior. Q6. Has the captain considered all possible solutions to the problem? If not, what else might be done? Q7. Identify the stressors in John Breckenridge’s life. Which ones could he have prevented? Q8. What were the results of the stress? Would you consider these to be typical to stress situations and lifestyle choices John made, or was John Breckenridge unlucky? Q9. Assume you are a career coach retained by John Breckenridge to guide him through his next decisions. How would you recommend that John modify his lifestyle and behavior to reduce stress? Should he change jobs? Do you believe he is capable of reducing his stress alone? If not, where should he seek help? Q10. What type of team was formed here? Was it necessary, in your opinion? Q11. Use the team effectiveness model in Chapter 9 and related information in this chapter to identify the strengths and weaknesses of this......

Words: 737 - Pages: 3