Roles of Comparative Law to Legal Interpretation and Application

In: Other Topics

Submitted By thientran
Words 5216
Pages 21
GROUP 6 – CLC35 1/1/2013

Role of Comparative Law to legal interpretation and application

Role of Comparative Law to legal interpretation and application

Table of Contents I. Definition: legal interpretation and application 2 I.1 Legal Interpretation 2 I.2 Legal Application 3 II. Role of Comparative Law to legal interpretation and application 4 II.1 Role of Comparative Law to legal interpretation and application of law as the result of the harmonization and unification of law 5 II.1.1 The harmonization and unification of law 5 II.1.2 Role of Comparative Law to legal interpretation and application of law as the result of the harmonization and unification of law 6 II.2 Role of Comparative Law to legal interpretation and application of law as the result of the transplants of foreign law 8 II.2.1 An overview of Legal transplant 8 II.2.2 Role of Comparative Law to legal interpretation and application of Law as the result of the transplants of foreign law 13 II.3 Role of Comparative Law to legal interpretation and application of Legal rules which are entirely domestic and lack any direct international background or connection 15 II.3.1 Introduction 15 II.3.2 Role of Comparative Law to legal interpretation and application of Legal rules which are entirely domestic and lack any direct international background or connection 16 III. Questions 17


I. Definition: legal interpretation and application
I.1 Legal Interpretation According to Black’s Law Dictionary, INTERPRETATION can be understood as the art or process of discovering and expounding the intended signification of the language used in a statute, will, contract, or any other written document, that is, the meaning which the author designed it to convey to the others.
In my…...

Similar Documents

107-K—Use of Law Journal and Legal Software

...GUJARAT UNIVERSITY SYLLABI OF THREE YEARS LL.B. PROGRAMME WITH CREDIT BASED SYSTEM (As prescribed b y the BAR CO UNCIL OF INDI A and as per the Rules of Legal Education, 2008) Effective from the academic year 2011-12 THREE YEARS’ LL.B. POGRAMME First LL. B. Semester – I FIRST LL.B. - S EMES TER 1 (MONSOON ) PE R WE EK S UBJEC TS LEC TURE S OT HER S T OT AL C RED IT S (SE M)29 CORE COURSE 101 L aw of T ort i ncludi ng MV A cci dent And C on sum er Pr ot ecti on Law s 4 1 5 5 CORE COURSE 102 Crim in al Law P aper – I (General P rinci pl es of P en al Law ) 4 1 5 5 4 1 5 5 4 1 5 5 4 1 5 5 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 2 CORE COURSE 103 CORE COURSE 104 CORE COURSE 105 FOUNDATIO N 106 F SOFT S KILL 107 K Crim in al Law P aper – II (S pec ific Off enc es) L aw of C ont ract S peci al C ontr act C on sti tuti on al Hist ory of I ndi a Use of Law J ournal s and L egal S oftw ar e 1 Semester – I Monsoon Semester CORE CO URSE 101 : LAW OF TO RT I NCLUDI NG M V ACCI DENT AND CO NS UM ER P ROTECTION LAWS Objectives of the Course : Wit h rap id industrializat ion, to rt actio n came to u sed again st manu factu rers and industrial un it fo r p roducts injurious to human beings. Present ly the emphas is is o n extend ing th e principles no t only to acts, which are h armfu l, bu t also to failu re to co mply with stand ards that are......

Words: 16483 - Pages: 66

Role of Law

... Role and Functions of Law Role and Functions of Law There are several different functions of laws; however laws were designed you have just one role. Laws were designed and set into place to govern a set a rules that each individual is expected to follow, whether pertaining to society or to a business. Laws are set and new ones are always being approved, so that there can not only be a consensus on what is right and wrong, but also so there can be a decision on when to punish someone and how to determine whether they have broken the . Law has an extraordinary role in a successful operation of how a business may run and how a society comes together as one. Laws help control social behavior which helps lead to a society that is ran in an efficient type of way. Laws were put in place to set rules of conduct, different ways to enforce those rules, a mean for settling misunderstandings or disputes, and to supply ethical expectations and standards. Some other important functions of laws are: they outline what the government can do and what it cannot do; brings out justice in society; facilitates orderly change; peacekeeping; and they promote economic growth. Something very important to know is that without laws, the way a business is ran or the way people may act, society would not be able to function effectively, with this being said commerce would likely collapse. Although many of the function of laws seem to be rather simple, The United States Legal System is very......

Words: 873 - Pages: 4

Role and Function of Law

...Role and Function of Law LAW/421 In society as well as business, laws act as a set of rules that individuals must follow for the business or society to run effectively. Although all laws are used to govern behavior, they vary greatly on the types of behaviors that they govern. For instance, our Constitution is the supreme law of the United States and is responsible for governing the fundamental principles of our government, but it has limited powers which can regulate individuals and businesses (Melvin, 2011). The limitations the Constitution has on individuals does not make the powers it does have any less valuable to society. Without the Constitution, and the laws it supplies, we would not have the system of checks and balances we do that protects us, as citizens, from any branch of the government becoming too powerful and running our government as a dictatorship instead of a democracy. On the contrary, states are responsible for making and enforcing laws, known as “police powers” that protect the “health, safety and general welfare” of its citizens “with only general constitutional authorization” (Melvin, 2011, p. 28). Because there are so many laws in America, it is sometimes beneficial to group laws according to their legal functions. Laws are “categorized into three general classifications: criminal law and civil law, substantive law and procedural law, and public law and private law” (Bushman, 2007, paragraph 6). These categories, however, are not mutually......

Words: 739 - Pages: 3

Use of Law Journal and Legal Software

...Knowledge Commission Working Group on Legal Education REPORT OF THE WORKING GROUP ON LEGAL EDUCATION Background 1. The National Knowledge Commission (“NKC”) was established by the Prime Minister of India in 2005 to recommend and undertake reforms in order to make India a knowledge-based economy and society. An important constituent of the NKC’s functions is professional education, particularly in the field of legal education. In light of its significance, the NKC constituted a Working Group on legal education in the country. The members nominated by the Chairperson of the NKC, Mr. Sam Pitroda, to the Working Group are Justice Jagannadha Rao (Chair), Justice Leila Seth, Dr. Madhav Menon, Dr. B.S. Chimni, Dr. Mohan Gopal, Mr. P.P. Rao and Mr. Nishith Desai. The Terms of Reference of the Working Group are as follows: a. Identify constraints, problems and challenges relating to curriculum, teaching, infrastructure, administration and access. b. Recommend changes and reforms to address the problems and challenges relating to curriculum, teaching, infrastructure, administration, and access. c. Explore methods of attracting and retaining talented faculty members. d. Suggest measures to develop a research tradition in faculties of law and law schools. e. Suggest innovative means of raising standards and promoting excellence in legal education situated in the wider social context. f. Suggest ways of incorporating emerging fields of legal education in teaching and......

Words: 11338 - Pages: 46

Application of Public Law

...Application of public health law The study of public health law (1) that emphasizes on the legal issues in the practice of public health and the effects of legal practice on public health has basically three major areas of practice: police power, the population law, and injury and disease prevention. The area of police power is engaged by agencies of the government. This area centers its attention on the growing field of bioterrorism and moreover, this has made the public health lawyers work towards the conception of the Model State Public Health Act and the Model State Emergency Health Powers Act. The area of the population law has its theoretical foundation on the legal analysis based on population. Being a new entrant in the subject of jurisprudence, the law of population has been found analyzing legal problems making use of the tool of epidemiology. The threat to the health of a society taken as a whole, on the basis of population health, is the primary concern of public health. In such situations, the population concerned with this notion can either be a handful of them or even whole of the continent, in case of an epidemic. Through the means of propagation of healthy behaviors and close observation of cases, the public health involvement promotes more of prevention of diseases rather than treating them. But in certain circumstances the treating of the diseases becomes a priority than controlling them through immunization as in the case of outbreak of pandemics. The......

Words: 1426 - Pages: 6

Comparative Law of Divorce in Bangladesh

...EQUAL RIGHTS IN LAWS RELATING TO DIVORCE: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF DIFFERENT PERSONAL LAWS IN BANGLADESH A Research Monograph Submitted as Partial Fulfillment of Master of Laws (LLM) Degree Submitted By: Examination Roll No. 08239085 Registration NO.3347 Examination: 2012 Session: 2007-2008 DEPATMENT OF LAW UNIVERSITY OF RAJSHAHI BANGLADESH DECEMBER 2012 DECLARATION The researcher, as a candidate for the degree of Master of Laws (LLM), is fully aware of the rules and regulations of the University of Rajshahi relating to the preparation, submission, retention and use of a research monograph. She acknowledges that the University requires the research monograph to be retained in the library for record purposes and that within Copyright privileges of the author it should be accessible for consultation and copying at the discretion of the library authority and in accordance with the Copyright Act 2000. I authorise the University of Rajshahi to publish an abstract of this research. The researcher also declares that this research monograph entitled ‘Equal Rights in Laws relating to Divorce: A Comparative Study of Different Personal Laws of Bangladesh’ is solely the outcome of her own efforts and research for the partial fulfillment of the degree of LLM. No part of this research monograph in any form has been submitted to any other department or institution for the award of any degree or diploma or to any journal for the purposes of......

Words: 10238 - Pages: 41

Role of Law

...The Functions and Role of Law in Business and Society Law/421 Functions and Role of Law in Business and Society On a normal weekday, you wake up, prepare breakfast, take your kids to school and then you join the traffic jam and head to work. It may seem like a typical day, but there were many laws that influenced and allowed these actions. Regulations were followed by the utility companies to service your home. The school adhered to educational regulations for your child to attend. The city followed law regulations for you to be able to commute to work and lastly, your employer followed certain regulations to be able to operate. In Business and Society Laws play a major role in business and society in more ways that we know. Laws influence many areas of business and society that following them requires minimum thought. The purpose of laws is to maintain social control and keep the public safe by resolving issues fairly and safely (“Business Law”, 2014). Laws create and establish order by detailing what is acceptable and unacceptable behavior for society and businesses. They promote good faith dealing amongst merchants and the public. In society, public law includes criminal, administrative and constitutional laws. These laws help keep society protected by establishing what is lawful and what is not. Society feels safe when others who break the law are removed from the population. People are able to enjoy their lives outside of work...

Words: 873 - Pages: 4

Role of Law

...The Role of Law in Business and Society Vernon Padberg III LAW/421 December 23, 2014 Safiya Byars   Impact of Law on Businesses and Society In today’s world, the healthcare law is having an impact on virtually every person in the United States. In the beginning of 2014 those who are uninsured must purchase coverage either on their own, through an employer's plan, or through a health insurance exchange. However, if the individual chooses not to get coverage then that person will end up having to pay a tax penalty, but those that are insured will continue to enjoy key mandates of the law such as free preventive care and coverage of adult dependents up to age 26, but at the expense of higher out-of -pocket costs. Since the Federal preemption in the healthcare industry has grown considerably in the last 10 years, most notably the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act or Obamacare signed by President Barack Obama in 2010, there has been a sweeping change in the healthcare industry. This act preempts many of the state’s laws that have been used to regulate healthcare in the past (Tsai 2011). Furthermore, the relationship between insurance companies and patients is starting to change significantly since the law requires insurance companies to cover all applicants within new minimum standards thus offering the same rates regardless of pre-existing conditions or sex. Also additional reforms are aimed to reduce costs and improve healthcare......

Words: 648 - Pages: 3

Application of International Law

...Traditionally, international law consisted of rules and principles governing the relations and dealings of nations with each other, though recently, the scope of international law has been redefined to include relations between states and individuals, and relations between international organizations. Public international law, concerns itself only with questions of rights between several nations or nations and the citizens or subjects of other nations. In contrast, Private international law deals with controversies between private persons, natural or juridical, arising out of situations having significant relationship to more than one nation. In recent years the line between public and private international law have became increasingly uncertain. Issues of private international law may also implicate issues of public international law, and many matters of private international law have substantial significance for the international community of nations. Contract law is defined as an agreement made between two or more parties who promise to perform or to not perform specified acts, which agreement creates for each party a legal duty and the right to seek a remedy for breach of that duty. It falls under the category of civil law (concerning relations between individuals or companies), although the state courts may intervene to settle dispute between conflicting parties (International Trade). “One key element of international contract law includes the provision that the......

Words: 995 - Pages: 4

Legal Law

...Electronic Surveillance of Employees Assignment # 1 By Diara Freeman Law Ethics and Corporate Governance Professor Michael Green April 23, 2011 Electronic Surveillance of Employees Explain where an employee can reasonably expect to have privacy in the workplace. The issue of privacy is a big concern in the workplace. With the expanding of new technology, many employees are concerned that their privacy rights are not being protected.   Employers want to be sure their employees are doing a good job, but employees don't want their every sneeze or trip to the water cooler logged. That's the essential conflict of workplace monitoring. New technologies make it possible for employers to monitor many aspects of their employees' jobs, especially on telephones, computer terminals, through electronic and voice mail, and when employees are using the Internet. Such monitoring is virtually unregulated. Therefore, unless company policy specifically states otherwise (and even this is not assured), your employer may listen, watch and read most of your workplace communications. (Harlow, 1999) When an employee is hired at a new company, there are several security measures that are already in place in order to keep their personal information private and/or confidential.   The first being in the Human Resources Department where all the information is gathered by the employee filling out various forms of that are confidential in nature.   This information is kept......

Words: 1221 - Pages: 5

Roles of Law

...Roles and Functions of Laws Kevin Ivery Law 421 November 10, 2014 Nikki Chtaini Roles and Functions of Laws As I have learned throughout my years of attending some form of public education, there has always been a governing body that has instituted some type of law that people and business must abide by. Traces of law that has govern authority can be traced all the back to the beginning of time. The functions and the role of law for business and society differ now in the 21st century. With the endorsement of the 10th amendment, Federal and state powers were separated, which lead to the birth of the Commerce and Supremacy Clause were born. Businesses have headquarters located worldwide and perform services at remote locations. The company I work for is no different and must abide by the law set forth by the government. 10th Amendment On December 15, 1971 the ratification of the 10th Amendment of the Constitution was put into place to separate the Federal and State Government. According to "Findlaw" (2014), "The Tenth Amendment was intended to confirm the understanding of the people at the time the Constitution was adopted, that powers not granted to the United States were reserved to the States or to the people." The delegates of that time were assured that the new Federal Government could not enforce powers that they did not have. The Tenth Amendment also assured the State delegates that when needed they would be able to exercise the reserve power that was......

Words: 831 - Pages: 4

Roles and Functions of Law

...Role and Functions of Law Paper Your Name LAW/421 Date Instructors Name Roles and Functions of Law Law is important in the business environment; companies depend on the laws to protect their business while conducting business. These laws help enforce contractual obligations and protect them from unwarranted lawsuits from vendors, suppliers, and consumers. The concept of the functions of law in society is also critical. The nature of the law needs to be explained along with the disciplines related to law to interpret and apply the law and how the law interacts with the social norms (Raz, 1979).  Firefighting in itself has many standards, regulations and laws that affect the way firefighters perform their duties, to what they wear while performing their job, to the tools they use and interaction with patients. The functions and role of law in business, society, and industry are necessary for maintaining fairness, peace, freedom, justice, and safety. Functions of role of Law in Business Small business and large companies must adhere to same rules and regulations and need legal expertise once in a while. Business law creates guidelines on what companies and businesses can and cannot do, along with certain things that must be accomplished. Business law is a comprehensive control with several fields of the functions of business (Hamel, n.d.).  Business must pay taxes on the income that they earn, and the tax law determines how businesses pay taxes......

Words: 913 - Pages: 4

Law and Legal

...Group Discussion Leader Chapters 14 & 15 Notes: Age of Majority- when a person is no longer a minor (18 years) Emancipation- when a child’s parent or legal guardian surrenders the right to have control over the child. ** a minor can enter into any contract that an adult can, except contracts prohibited by the law …. Aka purchase of tobacco or alcoholic beverages** Disaffirmance- legal avoidance of a contractual obligation > must be within a reasonable time reasonable time can vary > minors obligations on disaffirmance exceptions: - misrepresentation of age (claiming to be 21 when not) -contracts for necessaries (standard of living) ------------------------------------------------- Parents Liability: not liable for contracts made by a minor acting on their own Intoxication: if the person is extremely intoxicated the agreement may be voidable, but if they understand the consequences of the agreement, the contract will be enforceable ------------------------------------------------- Mentally Incompetent: Void-> court has declared a person to be mentally incompetent and has appointed a legal guardian Voidable-> court did not declare metal incompetency but the person lacks the ability to comprehend the subject matter/consequences (that person can void it ) Valid-> court has not declared a person mentally incompetent and the person does understand ......

Words: 292 - Pages: 2

Legal Areas of Canadian Law

...summary of the four Legal Areas of Canadian Law which affect recruitment & selection. * Identify the protected groups with regards to discrimination. * ------------------------------------------------- Provide at least one example of acceptable discrimination. ------------------------------------------------- During the recruiting and selection process, it’s important to be aware of certain legal issues in order to avoid risk. It is the responsibility of the human resource manager to make sure that all the policies and rules take legal aspects into account. The legal aspects of human resource management play a significant role in strategic planning and decision making. There are 4 major types of legislation that affects employment practices recruitment and selection: * Constitutional Law (Nationwide) * Human Rights Legislation (in ON, there are Ontario human rights commission) * Employment Equity * Labour Laws (including unions as an extension) 1) Constitutional Law (Nationwide): Constitutional Law is the supreme law of Canada. It consists of series of acts and orders passed in 1867 by the British and Canadian Parliaments. It has precedence impact on employment practices and all other legal means. The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedom was passed in 1982. It is the part of the Constitution of Canada; because of this, the Charter is a very powerful document. However in a practical matter, the constitutional law does not......

Words: 1325 - Pages: 6

The Role of Law

...Law in Business and Society LAW/421 September 19, 2011 Law in Business and Society The role of law in business and society The successful operation of business and society is due to the role that law plays. In order for society to run smoothly, laws are needed to regulate social behavior. Ethical standards and expectations are also supplied by laws, while offering rules of demeanor, methods to implement those rules, and processes for settling debates. While the overall functions of law seem to be rather straightforward, the United States legal system is really very complicated. At a broad level, the major function of law is to uphold steadiness in the public, civil and economic structure while at the same time allowing change. The law achieves this essential function by presenting a number of precise functions, including dispute resolution, defense of property, and conservation of the state (Bushman, 2007). Functions of law also provide are: negotiation; checking government power and encouraging personal freedom; assisting planning and the grasp of rational expectations; boosting economic growth via free competition; promoting social integrity; and protecting the environment. Most people will agree that without laws to govern the exploits of people and businesses, society would not be capable of functioning effectively, and business would likely shut down (Bushman, 2007). In the United States, the legal system acknowledges the significance of law in day to day......

Words: 796 - Pages: 4