Free Essay

Montana 1989

In: Novels

Submitted By z727629029
Words 1013
Pages 5
Hennessey 1
David Hennessey
Profesor Trump
Writing 130
7 December 2015
Analysis of Racism in Montana 1948
Racism, a mental state that is derived from the divergence of groups, has impacted history through centuries, even in the contemporary world. Racism is a power that can decide the fate of a whole race, or the life of a person. In Montana 1948, Marie, an Indian girl, is a tragedy caused by racism of white people who show prejudice in different levels against Native
Americans. Racism is a theme that the author clearly wants to present in his novel. In this paper I will explore racism and analyze its influence to the plot and characters of the novel.
This novel shows how racism affects individual's behaviors. Among the three people who show racism—Wesley, Julian, Frank—-their prejudice influences the plot in different ways.
Wesley's prejudice to Native is much like an inherent discrimination from a high-status person to a low-status person, which contains less malice compared to the other two characters. Wesley's racism actually does not have significant impact on advancing the plot; however, Julian's discrimination distorts his judgment to the abusive behaviors of his son, Frank. For his prejudice to Native Americans and preference to Frank, he weakens the severity of his son's crime and send his employee to release Frank from the basement of Wesley's house with violence. Last,
Frank' racism is more like a contempt of Native Americans's social status and human rights, and results in his abusive behaviors toward Indian girls and the ignorance of their human rights. His

Hennessey 2 discrimination is not depicted expressly but causes the struggle that derived from divergent attitudes to Frank's crime among family members.
Although Wesley is generally depicted as a positive character, he shows racial behaviors in the first chapter in both explicit and implicit ways. He stereotypes Native Americans as an ignorant, lazy, superstitious and irresponsible race (22); from this explicit discrimination, he considers himself as superior whereas the Native American as inferior. Also, Marie must sleep in a small servant’s bedroom (15), even though there is a empty bedroom at the second floor. This discrimination is not described explicitly, but still reveals that Wesley does not treat Marie in a fair way. His prejudice causes him to consider Marie's unwillingness of seeing a doctor as a
"Indian superstition" (22), and doubts if she ever was seen by a “real” doctor. His "superior" viewpoint causes Marie's encounter with Frank as well as her death. Wesley' s prejudice to native
Americans causes him to stand on his brother’s side initially and thinks Marie probably doesn't know what's supposed to go on in the examination (34), but Wesley is not a deep racism, and most of his racism is presented in the first chapter. Later Wesley abandons his prejudice and reacts to the case from a fair viewpoint.
Compared to his brother, Frank shows intensive racism, though the racism is not specifically depicted in the novel compared to his brother and father. Frank is a blatant racist, which is revealed by his brother who believes that Frank thinks less of Marie than of a dog (144).
Frank' s distorted preference to Native Americans is much more than a mere "preference". This prejudice makes him to overlook the human rights of Indian girl. When he sexually assaults them in the name of diagnose (34), he actually does not consider Native Americans as an equal race to

Hennessey 3
Whites. His reckless criminal behaviors show that his prejudice to Native Americans is much seriously than his brother's, even his is disclosed by Marie indirectly.
The final character who shows racism is Julian. Julian's impression is a stubborn old man who sticks to his racial views. He uses "red meat" (62) as a insulting metaphor of Indian girls and shows extreme antipathy to the fact the Frank is partial to Indian girls (66), also he tolerates his son's behaviors forward to Native Americans, which fuels Frank to commit those crimes.
Even after Julian has been informed of the crimes that are committed by Frank from Wesley, he still dismisses the abuse of Native Americans as unimportant and thinks Frank is supposed to have beaten up some Indians (110). He holds the viewpoint that the assault and victimization of
Native Americans is not a crime worthy of punishment, so he ignores the crime committed by
Frank and send his employee to release Frank from the basement in Wesley' s house. (125).
Julian's racial viewpoint is similar to but much deeper than that of Wesley—a confirmed conception that looks down Native Americans.
Finally, what is worth mentioning is the potential influence of the three people' s racism on David, the narrator of the novel. David, before the main plot in the story, is strange about racism and Native Americans, and his caretaker, Marie, does not match the impression of Native
Americans; however, the elder members of his family affect David' s subjective norms. After
David hears the blatantly discriminatory comments from his father toward Native Americans, he starts to realizes the world is not bright as he once thought. Children are born innocent, and
David is not influenced by racism until he contacts the verbal and behavioral discrimination about Native Americans from his grandpa, father and uncle.

Hennessey 4
In conclusion, Frank's abusive behaviors to Indian girls are the main plot of the novel, and the discrimination of his brother and father fuel Frank's behavior and the tragedy of Marie.
Frank belongs to their family and Marie belongs to the group which they discriminate. Their discrimination distorts their justice, so their judgement deviates from the justice and they turn to support Frank. Racism has been confirmed deeply in the three main characters' minds, and is modeling David's mind. Native Americans face the situation of being treated unfairly, and they are forced to abandon their cultures and accept Western cultures, and this discrimination is inherited from the elders to the kids. 

Hennessey 5
Work Cited
Watson. Larry. Montana 1948. Misseaplonlism, MN: Milkweed Edition. 1993. Print…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Timing Bomb - Analysis of Montana 1948

...Junyu Huang Professor Li WR097 O1 24 November 2012 Timing Bomb -An Analysis of “Montana 1948: A Novel” by Larry Watson The novel Montana 1948, written by Larry Watson, depicts complicated conflicts between family relationship and society responsibility which happened in the family Hayden family in Montana, with a 15-year-old boy David, his father Wesley, uncle Frank and grandfather Julian. The story of conflicts is aroused by the exposure of Frank’s crimes of sexual assaulting Indian girls and finally comes to his death. The author impressively conveys how a single character, Frank, messes up a huge family, just like a bomb blows up and ruins the Haydens’ peace, honor and happiness. Frank is originally presented as a hidden timing bomb – no one yet knows its existence and when it will explode. The author paves the way of conflicts in the very beginning of the novel, where David describes Frank – “handsome”, “a star athlete in high school and college” and “a genuine war hero” (24). Just as what David comments on Frank, Frank is “completely with decorations and commendations”(24) that he seems to be such a super perfect person way better than Wesley, which hints Julian’s Partiality to Frank. Also such Frank is shown as an implicit trigger of the future family conflicts, since it is the perfect image of Frank that its molder will lead to a serious consequence and at the moment barely anyone knows Frank’s true look under his masquerade. And soon the bomb is displayed to......

Words: 887 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

1989: Exxon Valdez Oil Spill

...1989: Exxon Valdez Oil Spill Abstract: A tanker filled to capacity with crude oil ran aground and ruptured yesterday 25 miles from the southern end of the Trans-Alaska Pipeline, spewing her cargo into water rich in marine life. (Shabecoff, 1989) THE BACK STORY THE TRANS-ALASKA PIPELINE SYSTEM After oil was discovered in Prudhoe Bay on the northern coast of Alaska in 1968, the Alyeska Pipeline Service Company was formed by the owner companies: BP Exploration, ARCO, Exxon, Mobil, Amerada Hess, Phillips, and Union. Alyeska determined that the most economic method of transporting oil from Prudhoe Bay to the U.S. west coast was oil transport through a pipeline from the bay to Valdez, followed by oil tanker transport south. President Richard Nixon signed the Trans-Alaska Pipeline Authorization Act on November 16, 1973. The Trans-Alaska Pipeline System (TAPS) consists of an extensive 800 mile pipeline (Figure 6.1), 11 pump stations, and an oil terminal at Valdez; it cost more than $8 billion to build (USDIBLM, 2005). 75 OIL SPILL PREPAREDNESS At the time of the Exxon Valdez oil spill, six contingency plans were in place to coordinate oil spill response efforts. On the national level, the National Response Team (NRT) provided national support for response actions related to oil discharges and hazardous substance releases. NRT supported emergency responders at all levels by means of technical expertise and equipment, assisted in the development of training, coordinated......

Words: 1392 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Coors Montana Case Study

...thought and proper analysis. If Larry opens the distribution center in Montana, he will have to decide whether to sell to wholesalers or retailers, as well as the price at which he’s going to sell the beer. SWOT Analysis Strengths The Coors brand recognition. Consumers are already aware of the Coors brand, as it is the 5th largest beer distributor in the United States. It’s stated that Coors doesn’t spend as much money on advertisements as other competitors do because of its already known name. This means that Larry would have to also spend less on advertisements and product positioning in supermarkets because of the awareness of the brand. He will also have to spend less on advertisements promoting the premium product. Another strength is the high demand for the distribution center in Montana. Based on the questionnaire given to potential customers, 81.2% of the people said they will definitely or most likely buy Coors when choosing a beer. Based on this percentage, it’s highly probably that a Montana distribution center will prosper. Another strength for opening the distribution center is the high quality of the product. Larry won’t be pushing a lower-quality product that would need much more advertising and promotion. Weaknesses The price of Coors is a weakness. Although it’s considered a premium product, the people of Montana might not be able to afford it even if they want and enjoy the......

Words: 663 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Hannah Montana

...Hannah Montana / Miley Cyrus Hannah Montana and Miley Cyrus are one of the same, but everyone sees them different, let’s take a long look. Hannah Montana is an American musical comedy series created by Michael Poryes, Rich Correll, and Barry O’Brien which focus on Miley Stewart, who is a teenager living a double life as an average schoolgirl by day and a famous recording artist Hannah Montana by night. The show follows the day-to-day life of Miley, her brother and friends while also starrying Cyrus’ country singer father Billy Ray as her dad. The theme song for the show is “Best of Both Worlds” written by Matthew Gerrad and Robbie Nevil, and performed by Miley Cyrus, Hannah Montana was created or born on March 24, 2006. In 2006, Hannah Montana was nominated for three awards: Teen Choice Awards, Golden Icon Awards, and Casting Society of America, even though she was nominated she did not win an award. In 2007, however, she did come back to win those awards with a few more added on. Destiny Hope Cyrus was born November 23, 1992 in Nashville, Tennessee, to Letitia Jean “Tish” and country singer Billy Ray Cyrus. Her name was derived from her parents’ belief that she would accomplish great things with her life. Do you think they still feel that way? Destiny was given the nickname “Smiley” which was later shortened to Miley. Against the advice of her fathers’ record company, Cyrus’s parents secretly married a month after Cyrus’s birth in November. Her mom had...

Words: 1031 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Lewis and Clark in Montana

...Name: Course: Instructor: Date: Lewis and Clark Expedition in Montana William Clark in December 1803 built the River Dubois Camp on the along river Wood. The camp was set at Rivers Missouri’s and Mississippi’s confluence in Missouri just north of St. Louis. In addition, the camp was at just across River Dubois in Illinois. Clark took up the training of the severally different volunteer men who put themselves forward to undertake the expedition into the Pacific. Therefore, William Clark was keen to make an efficient and useful team from the goons, savages laypeople who had volunteered (Kern, 672). This team was identified as the Corps of Discovery, a sentry sent by President Thomas Jefferson to explore the source of the river and possible navigation into the Pacific. This paper trails Clark and Lewis’ expedition in Montana exploring the various Indian wars and the twist and confusing meander of the river. The Corps of Discovery constituted of strangers to each other aged differently but with an average age of 27. Nonetheless, the team was eager to undertake the presidential decree with zeal, zest and passion. John Shields aged 35 was the oldest of the Corps of Discovery whereas 17 year old George Shannon was the youngest (Lewis and William, 38). Therefore, Clark had to balance his command as he directed the team into building cabins and forts from logs. Clark further taught the team information marching, effective shooting of targets as a team as well as the use of......

Words: 2333 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Montana Mountain Biking Case

...The Montana Mountain Biking Case The Montana Mountain Biking Case Montana Mountain Biking Company has been in business for 16 years providing guided mountain biking trips at four locations in Montana. The success of the company is linked to retaining its customers. Eighty percent of the customers who sign up for the one week guided mountain biking expedition are repeat customers (University Of Phoenix, 2007). An important part of any marketing plan is to understand the customer relationship because ultimately, all profits come from the customers. The challenges facing the Montana Mountain Biking company is not only retaining customers but to attract new customers. The advances in e-marketing have given Montana Mountain Biking some alternatives to traditional marketing plans. The Five Stages of Customer Loyalty Customer loyalty comes from the personal relationship that is developed between the customer and the business. One method used to understand the customer relationship is called customer relationship intensity and Life-cycle segmentation (UOP, 2007). This process includes classifying all the customer relationships into one of five groups. The first of the five groups includes customers who are aware of the business or service. This is considered the weakest of the groups because in the beginning of the relationship and the customer knows little or nothing about the company. The second group of customers is those who have explored or expressed interest in......

Words: 1382 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Public Transit in Montana

...Public transit in Montana The main goal of this bill is to improve public transportation in Montana. “Considering that the transit systems we know today are more expensive, less convenient, and have greater environmental impacts than driving, this goal is self-defeating. The changes described below could save Montana taxpayers millions of dollars while truly improving transit services for most people.” Urban public transit is often considered the most cost effective and energy efficient means of transportation available, but this perception doesn’t hold true in rural states like Montana. Urban buses use more energy per passenger mile than private vehicles and release more than twice the carbon emissions into the atmosphere than a small truck. The average cost of public transit, meanwhile, is more than 90 cents per passenger mile nationally, with more than 75% of that cost subsidized by non-transit users. The average cost of public transit in Montana, meanwhile, is about $1.76 per passenger mile, with more than 90% of the cost subsidized by non-transit users. Smaller vehicles can save energy and nimbly serve more parts of each urban area. Private carriers can operate at capacity and have routes on demand rather than scheduled. Instead of funding expensive transit agencies to serve only a few people, state and local governments could give transportation vouchers to people unable to drive. Also known as shared taxis, jitneys are a combination of taxis and buses.......

Words: 853 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Povety in Canada Since 1989

...Poverty in Canada since 1989 The poverty rates across Canada have seen a rise and fall since 1989. The poverty rates are based on age, gender and family type. However, the poverty rates have seen a decline since 1989. The poverty for all persons in 1988 was 10.8% and in 2007 it was 9.2% (Statistics Canada, 2009, Table 202-0802). That is a 14.8% decrease in poverty for all persons in Canada over time (Statistics Canada, 2009, Table 202-0802). The decline in poverty could result for many reasons. Education, jobs and the economy of Canada may have improved a lot during the past twenty years. Canada is a developing country and is seeing improvements in social status of people. The class system plays a huge role. Could it be that families across Canada are moving up a class? Persons in economic families had a poverty rate of 8% in 1988 and it dropped to 6% in 2007 (Statistics Canada, 2009, Table 202-0802). It can be seen that there is a 25% decrease in poverty for persons in economic families over time (Statistics Canada, 2009, Table 202-0802). Therefore persons in economic families are doing well compared to how they were in 1989. It is pretty clear that the economy of Canada is developing. This would not be the case if poverty had increased during the past twenty years. Poverty still exists, no doubt about that but it will continue to decline if Canada continues to improve its economic situation. Poverty still exists for many reasons such as people in poor class work as much......

Words: 647 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

China and the Tian'Anmen Bloodshed of June 1989

...of other foreign policy decisions. In order to gain this understanding as to why certain nation behave in way or why certain foreign policy decisions are made, all levels and perspectives must be taking into consideration and analysed – individual, state and international. Each of these levels all has a relationship; they are not separate. For us to make sense of one entity, we must understand the other levels, and link them to one another. With this knowledge at hand, it is an advantage for states to have an enhanced understanding of how one’s political system is constructed and functions, as well as its strengths and its weaknesses. To understand the relationship between the events of the Tiananmen Square Massacre that took place in 1989, and the behaviours and certain foreign policy decisions made by Chinese politicians, we need to understand the essential characters that make up the culture, values and history. In this text, I will be presenting a number of decision making issues which lead to the event of the Tiananmen Square Massacre, and decision making process after the event: (1) Characteristics, values and problems within the Chinese government, (2) Mass media, and linkages between global civil society and domestic interest groups, and (3) The impact of global treaties and sanctions. Each of these issues and factors will be analysed and considered under the three levels of analysis. China has a long history of political reforms, dating back to the early......

Words: 2423 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Montana Meth Psa

...Brandon Rogers Laura Walter GSW – Essay 4 29 10 14 Montana Meth PSA In this image one can see that there is a girl lying on the floor as if she was in distress. The girl in the photo looks as if she is high off drugs and there is a man grabbing her shoulder trying to have sexual relations with her. This PSA is a great example of struggle and how certain things get down played that are serious. The drug that the girl has been using is called Meth, also known as Methamphetamine. Methamphetamine is a synthetic stimulant that affects a human’s central nervous system (Meth Project). Teenagers0 that think drugs are acceptable need to take this photo into consideration and really understand it because drugs are extremely harmful to your body. This Montana Meth PSA uses pathos and a use of color, text, and body language to show the endangerment when students are using illegal drugs. While looking at a PSA color plays a big part because it has to draw the audience attention as best as possible, so teens can understand what they are getting themselves into. “Colors connect to our feelings in a unique and memorable way, which makes them a powerful marketing tool to keep in mind (Color is Important)”. Humans tend to notice color first before they read any type of text in anything because a color is an attention getter. In the Montana Meth PSA, the man that looks to be assisting her is wearing a red flannel. The color red in advertising can come off as danger while viewing...

Words: 1288 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Power in Montana

...County came to aristocracy. I never consciously traded on the Hayden name, yet I knew it gave me a measure of respect that I didn't have to earn." (Watson p. 126) Throughout the story of Montana 1948 by Larry Watson the Hayden name is a symbol of power and control. David states the reasons that his family has control in the town. “Because my grandfather was wealthy and powerful, because my father enforced the law, because my uncle treated the sick and injured, and because all their wives were beautiful. People had an opinion about the Hayden’s." (Watson p. 126). In this novel there are many different areas of control coming from various characters. Julian Hayden the father of Wes and Frank Hayden has an immense amount of control over them by being their father and having town popularity. Wes and Gail have control over their son because they are his guardians and he is obligated to respect them in every which way. The overall Hayden name has an omnipresent power and status in their community because of their status of enforcing the law and healing the sick for generations.   “I was a Hayden," David states to the readers when he begins his rant on what the Hayden name means in his county (Watson 126). The Hayden family is a well-respected family that holds much power in Mercer County Montana. The power they hold comes from their wealth, occupations, and as David states, beautiful wives. Wesley Hayden being a Sheriff of the entire community has power over all lawful sins of......

Words: 1629 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Crown Cork & Seal in 1989

...Carbonation leaks after 4 month – major issue • Cannot be fully recycled Acquiring Continental Can Canada would have the following pros: • Double in size domestically, increase market share rapidly • Plastic container line would come from this factory • Expansion globally • Increasing bargaining power Acquiring Continental Can Canada would have the following cons: • Bidding war could create too high acquisition price • Conflict with different cultures • Expansion might create unnecessary costs • Increased difficultness of overseeing the company 2, How attractive has the metal container industry been over the years? The metal container industry was representing a 61% market share of all packaged products in the United States in 1989. The industry produced a variety of solutions on how to package a product. These products were metal cans, crowns (bottle caps), and closures (screw caps, bottle lids). Metal cans were made of steel or aluminum, or the combination of both. At the beginning, three-piece steel cans were technologically most advanced and widely used in the industry for packaging mainly beverages. The advancement of new technologies quickly created a two-piece can made of aluminum which quickly took over the marker over the three-piece steel version. The use of aluminum had several advantages over steel; for example, lighter weight, ease of handling, wider variety of graphics options, and consumer preference. The industry’s attractiveness was eliminated......

Words: 993 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Montana Women in Politics

...disciples. In Montana, women have had major roles in political issues since the beginning. During the 1880s women were starting to gain more access to political positions in Montana. On March 8, 1883 legislature passed a law allowing women to hold office in the county school superintendent. A year later Adda Hamilton was elected Gallatin County Superintendent of Schools. Her opponent was so upset that a woman would dare go against him he ended up calling her names during an election speech and basically handed her the position. At the end of the eighties a women, Ella Knowles Haskell, was the first woman admitted to the Montana bar. About 15 years later, after working her way up the legal political ladder, she was admitted to practice law before the United States Supreme Court (UmLib). Throughout this entire time and into the early 1900s equal suffrage was a major political issue in Montana, not just for women but also Native Americans, African Americans, and basically anyone that wasn't an old white guy. One woman who is very often associated with Montana’s political history is Jeannette Rankin, she traveled all over Montana giving speeches to suffrage groups. On May 2, 1912 she spoke to the Equal Suffrage Club about why women should have the vote, it is said this speech had a large influence on people’s vote when the amendment went to legislature two years later. In November 1914, the amendment that allowed women’s suffrage was passed in Montana, Montana joined......

Words: 844 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...Montana 1948 - Larry Watson Outline: "From the summer of my twelfth year I carry a series of images more vivid and lasting than any others of my boyhood and indelible beyond all attempts the years make to erase or fade them...." So begins David Hayden's story of what happened in Montana in 1948. This summer will change his view of his family. His self-effacing father, a sheriff who never wears his badge; his clear sighted mother; his uncle, a charming war hero and respected doctor; and the Hayden's lively housekeeper, Marie Little Soldier, whose revelations are at the heart of the story. It is a tale of love and courage, of power abused, and of the terrible choice between family loyalty and justice. And he will now realize that his family is different if what he though. David takes on a huge development in personality and throughout the story he gets more and more able to understand why people around him perform certain actions. We see this through his narrative point of view; were he, in the start of the story rarely perceive the simplest of incidents to the end were he reads people as if they were open books. In short it could be said that, David escapes his innocence of being a child, and develops a mature state of mind. David Hayden’s transition to adolescence it also explores possible motivations and explanations behind an individual’s actions. David also learns the moral values of responsibility, maturity, protection and trust. The main problem......

Words: 1474 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Tiananmen Square Protest of 1989

...Tiananmen Square Protest of 1989 The photograph known as “Tank Man” was taken by Jeff Widener but also four other known photographers took a photo of the same man that all encompass one thing, rebellion, against oppression and against the will to succumb. The photo portrays a man blocking the path of tanks as they try to leave Tiananmen Square. The Tiananmen Square protest of 1989 was a series of protests that started out with students in China mourning the loss of communist leader Hu Yaobang in and near Tiananmen Square in Beijing. Students began to congregate in and outside of Tiananmen Square in mid April on the day of Hu Yaobang’s death. Over a period of nearly two months the people protested for political reform, conducted hunger strikes and made monuments in spirit of overthrowing the government but they were defeated on June 4th when The People’s Liberation Army stepped in to take control of the square. They were told by China’s leaders to clear out the square which escalated into a ruthless massacre of China's citizens. The Tiananmen Square Protest of 1989 was a cultural backlash that sought to better the state of China but instead led to a slaughter of its citizens in which the voice of its people was ignored. The death of one man, who had many great ideals and hopes for his country, created one of the largest acts of military brutality against civilians seen in the last two decades. That man was Hu Yaobang. Hu Yaobang was General Secretary of the State for the......

Words: 6074 - Pages: 25