Is Management Within a Business Ethical?

In: Business and Management

Submitted By brittanyellis21
Words 2956
Pages 12
Is Management within a Business Ethical?
In this essay I am going to argue and focus on how management within businesses and corporations are frequently unethical nevertheless necessary. In Section One I am going to argue that the way in which management is exercised is to some extent designed to be unethical. Through the use of W D Ross and Immanuel Kant (1785) I am going to outline ethics and employ Roberts, J. (1984) and Milgram’s (1974) works to display how management can be seen as not ethical. In Section Two I aim to reveal that not only the exercise of management is dissolute but individual managers themselves operate unethically as well. To confirm this I am going to mainly refer to Knights, D and Roberts, J. (1982) and Morgan, G. (2006) to illustrate how managers can perform unethical acts. On the other hand in Section Three I am going to highlight the necessity for management within Businesses despite the fact that the structure of management and the managers themselves are unethical. To exemplify this I will use the work of Huczynski, A. (1993) to argue that management is essential in spite of being unethical it is still significant even in our day-to-day lives.
Section One: Management is Unethical In order to determine whether management within a business is ethical, an important question needs to be asked, what is ethical? W D Ross (1877-1971) a well recognized Philosopher for his work on deontological conveys his views on ethics. He is best known for “The Right and the Good” (1930) where he differentiates between what is right and good and argues that “moral obligations are intrinsically compelling whether or not they fulfill results in some greater good” - "Productivity of maximum good is not what makes all right actions
 right…"Basically even though the result may be superior the way in which it was executed may not be moral. Consequently should…...

Similar Documents

Ethical Business

...Cheuk Sze Wong Assignment 2 10/20/2012 Ethical business relates to the behavior that a business adheres to in its daily dealings with the world. Providing a clearly Ethics Policy statement protect consumers, employees and to build trust. It makes the entire business more successful, especially internally. Imagine a company without an ethical policy, there are nothing to control employees’ behaviors. When consumers are suffered a bad service, if things continues go on like this, the company will have a bad reputation. Assuming I have a company, here has three majorly policies should be included, honest and ethical conduct, protect customer privacy, and hold high security standards. Firstly, being a company employee should be honest and fair in dealings with co-workers, the company, suppliers, customers, or even competitors. Secondly, based on ethical behavior, employee should not sell customer information to marketing firms even though it is legal. Thirdly, employees have to heavily protect consumers’ credit card numbers, names and addresses from hackers. However, even if the company already formalized the policy and communicated it to the employees, it does not mean that employees can fully understand the policy. At that time, the company should provide training to the employees which could be many ways to test or evaluation the employees can truly understand the key points of the ethical policy. Employees also need to understand that there are......

Words: 785 - Pages: 4

Business Ethical

...Examine your ethical climate and put safeguards in place. Corporations are composed of cultures. Take a good close look at your culture. What are the norms of behavior? What is valued? Are employees rewarded for succeeding at any cost or are they urged to be shepherds of the corporation's reputation as well as its assets? What pressures do they face to commit misconduct? What systemic problems exist that could encourage good people to make bad decisions? Consider conducting a formal assessment of your corporate culture from the perspective of attitudes, perceptions, values, standards of conduct, pressures to commit misconduct, communications, risks and vulnerabilities. Pay particular attention to your corporate values and how well they have been internalized by your Board, senior leadership, employees at all levels and key stakeholders. 2. Don't just print, post and pray. If you have a Code of Conduct or an Ethics Code, printing copies, posting them on the wall and on bulletin boards is not enough. Codes of conduct are an outgrowth of company missions, visions, strategies and values. Thoughtful and effective corporate codes provide guidance for making ethical business decisions that balance conflicting interests. Codes of conduct need to be actual living documents encouraged and valued at the highest levels. Board members and senior executives have to set an example for the type conduct they expect from others. Ethical lapses at the upper echelons of management......

Words: 2232 - Pages: 9

Ethical Business

...Topic: What are the advantages and disadvantages to the business face when they try to behave in an ethical way? With the development of the global economy, business companies are facing many business challenges in the age full of competition. And business challenges will produce some different values, such as child labor, human rights, hours and wages and environmental laws (Luminita and Constantin,2006). Therefore, business companies need to pay more attention to the business ethics. What is more, ethical business is study of business behavior which promote human welfare and the good( Wikipedia).And in business companies, there are some advantages and disadvantages when they behave in an ethical way .However, there are more advantages than disadvantages in such ethical business companies. First of all, let is talk about some advantages. In recent years, one of the most important problems ‘international managers facing today is the ecological impact of industrialization around the world’ (Caliskan, 2010, p49)Therefore, the environment problems were focused by many organizations. However, an ethical business company must follow the environment friendly policy. Here is an example below. Barclays Hire Cycle sharing scheme, which can save energy. In that way, if using cycles instead of cars, there are no worries about fuel and oil resources to damage the environment and caused pollution. What is more, the company plays the social responsibility...

Words: 604 - Pages: 3

Ethical Issues in Management

...Ethical Issues in Management Juanita Bell University of Phoenix Ethical Issues in Management What is business ethics? According to wiseGEEK (2003-2010), business ethics “Is the behavior that a business adheres to in its daily dealings with the world.” (What is Business Ethics? para.1). The ethics of a organization may be discrete, however ethics do not just apply to how the business communicates with the world, but also includes the business’ one-on-one relations with individual clients and employee’s. There are many ethical issues involved in management. Diversity has become a major issue in the management world. Workplace diversity refers to the extent of cultural diversity within a company. “Diversity is generally defined as acknowledging, understanding, accepting, valuing, and celebrating differences among people with respect to age, class, ethnicity, gender, physical and mental ability, race, sexual orientation, spiritual practice, and public assistance status (K.A. Green, M. López, A. Wysocki, & K. Kepner, 2008)”. Diversity in business allows a business to better understand the demographics of its marketplace. Many advertise themselves as “Equal Opportunity Employers”, meaning they maintain a diverse workplace and will not discriminate. Though many ethical issues can be found with in the workplace, the most common is discrimination. Discrimination is one of the main issues currently stopping diversity. “Discrimination occurs whenever something other than......

Words: 1127 - Pages: 5

Developing an Ethical Business Enviroment

...Developing an Ethical Business Environment: A Report to Executive Management Introduction Ethics and business rules always go together. The fact that business policing is based upon the different measures of complete recognition of social norms and social limitations, ethics is indeed a large part of the ways by which business organizations try to strive to be able to become more effective within their operational engagements with regards their aim of being able to influence the society as well. It is indeed certain that the rules and regulation that a business puts up should be able to meet certain standards of social compromises. Any business organization could not afford to be questioned simply because of the fact that the business procedures that they are adapting to are not meeting the set standards for business organizations. (Kuhn, 2005, 12) To be able to have a clearer view of the matter being reported herein, it is first most importantly to be given attention to as to how management is indeed in relation with the actual application of ethical standards within the society. To be able to do this, there are three major points to consider. The said points are as follows: • The effect of organizational culture on ethical operation • The roles and responsibilities of executive management in fostering an ethical operating environment • The impact of ethical standards as they are used in business operations Through the consideration given to these......

Words: 3627 - Pages: 15

Ethical Business

...University of Phoenix Business Ethics Reflection Business Ethics Where I use to work many years ago was a grocery store, which was my first job and had face a ethical dilemma, which does relate a relationship among virtue, values and moral concept. What I believe is that we are taught at a young age about the difference between from right and wrong when facing any dilemma and what to do is right, by making the right decision. “ Business ethics is the study and evaluation of decision making according to moral concepts”( Business Ethics, 2010 ). Company There was a time working in a grocery store, which I started very young and there was a lady in my department who was a manager. This manager was having marriage problems, but also doing drugs, which had a effect on her job performance, by not showing up to work or always late, so what I use to do was to cover her up and do most of her job as a department manager. I knew that by doing her job was not right, but on the other hand I have learn about being a manager at a young age. The next thing that came to...

Words: 836 - Pages: 4

Ethical Business

...Boston Scandal Exposes Backlog Kirsten Williams RES/351 Business Research April 28, 2014 Saba Tahmassebi Ethical business research practises are an integral part of the research process. Conducting research can often seem like an overwhelming task and the temptation to cut corners or to manipulate findings can often lead to criminal behaviour by individuals or companies. Occasionally therefore, ethics may fall between the cracks. When ethics are not considered important a variety of consequences will have a negative impact on the organization as well as individuals. Organizations that employ people to conduct such research must make sure that they adhere to the most paramount level of ethics in every aspect of their business. This essay sets out to discuss an article in which an individual engaged in unethical business research. Boston Scandal Exposes Backlog In an article I found in the University of Phoenix library entitled, “Boston Scandal Exposes Backlog”, forensic chemist Annie Dookhan was, “ charged with obstructing justice by falsifying data in two criminal cases, and of lying under oath about her qualifications.” (Reich, 2012) It was also reported that she, “falsified results and that she had guessed the nature of samples she had been asked to test but a few times she had recorded the results of negative drug tests as being positive.” (Reich, 2012) Behaviour like this not only affects an individual but also the organization they work for, which makes......

Words: 872 - Pages: 4

Business Ethical

...Resolving Ethical Business Challenge Cassandra Daniels Everest University What are the potential ethical issues faced by Acme corporation? The ethical issues faced by this corporation were “the medical supplies industry competitive nature. This caused a few mistakes to be tolerated.” (Ferrell, O.C., Fraedrich, J. & Ferrell, L. (2013) Business Ethics: Ethical decision making and cases. (9th edition) Mason OH: Cengage). Frank wanted the contract to increase, but he has to first figure out if the inventory is at high standard for the company. If the inventory is good then it is possible for Frank to get his increased contract. They did see that inventory did pick up a good bit. Now they are trying to figure out if Acme is a good fit for them. Frank letting Otis knows that their increase is because of Frank’s quality products. There are personal things given to Otis, which would cause problems for Frank and Acme Corporation in the future. What should Acme do if there is a desire to make ethics a part of its core organizational values? Acme should check and see if all the rules are put out and make sure the personnel get them and understand them. They need to provide a rule for giving gifts to customers. Getting into bribery offer that Otis had for Frank could have been prevented if Frank did not accept it. Being that Frank accepted the offer is going to cause problems in the future between the two. There should be an agreement for everyone to sign which is stating......

Words: 516 - Pages: 3

Term Paper on People Management Within the Context of Business Process Management

...Term Paper on People Management Within The Context of Business Process Management By Morris Biko Okello KCA/08/04084 MSC ISM 19TH OCTOBER-2013 to 12th December 2013. TABLE OF CONTENT 1. Introduction………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….…..3 1.1. History of People Management……………………………………………………………………………………...3 1.2. State of Practice……………………………………………………………………………………………………………..4 1.3. Technological Advancement……………………………………………………………………………………………5 2. Review of Literature..….…………………………………………………………………………………………………….6 2.1. Case 1…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….6 2.2. Case 2…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….7 2.3. Case 3…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….8 2.4. Case 4…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….9 3. Conclusion…..…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..10 4. Reference… ….………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….10 1. INTRODUCTION In this paper, I am going to look at the issue of People Management within the Business Process Management. People, in the general sense would mean all humans who come into contact with the business at all levels of the business process. The people could be categorized in these categories:- 1) Customers – the people who pay for goods or services from the business. 2) Business Actors (workers) – the people who work within the structures of the business and are paid for their service to......

Words: 3067 - Pages: 13

Ethical Issues Within Organizations

...Ethical Issues Within Organizations Introduction I have been afforded the opportunity to serve in two distinctly different organizations. In my full-time vocation, I serve as pastor of Seigle Avenue Presbyterian Church. In my part-time career, I am a military officer serving as a chaplain for the 145th Air National Guard. In this paper, I will discuss and examine the United States military and the standards of ethic and integrity within the organization. Specifically, I will the Air National Guard as a backdrop to determine conclusions, access organizational climate and provide feedback as it relates to ethics and integrity. Later in the paper I will name five steps leaders can consider to prevent, control or minimize destructive behaviors. Further, I will create clear distinctions between organizational compliance and organizational integrity and list elements that must be included to improve the integrity of the organization. Finally, I will share my opinion of my personal ethical stance; cultural relativist or universal ethicist. Upon defending my position, I hope to clarify my ethical stance and support this stance in my leadership as a military chaplain and officer. The United State Air Force In 1997, I was commissioned to serve in the Air Force National Guard in the rank of 1st Lieutenant. I joined the Air Guard because I wanted to serve in ministry beyond the local parish. Additionally, I embraced the core values of the Air Force and wanted the integration of......

Words: 2458 - Pages: 10

Ethical and Socially Responsive Business

...Ethical and Socially Responsive Business Debbre` Paige Strayer University Intro to Business Professor: Gwendolyn Wiggins September 5, 2014 Abstract Ethical and Social Responsive Business behavior sets the foreground for business practices. Having good business ethics is the beginning to having a successful business. Being socially responsive lets your patrons know, your business is family and community oriented, and can start a long good relationship with the community. Ethical and Socially Responsive Behavior I am going to discuss Chipotle’s business practices relating to their code of behaviors that is set in place for the employees to adhere by. I am also going to discuss ways businesses can become more socially responsive in the community, where they are located in. Key Areas of Chipotle’s Code of Conduct 1. Compliance with the Code defines the expectations of the employees on how they are to conduct themselves within the business environment. It outlines how they are to comply with the rules and the ramifications of not complying with them. This is a vital part of company policy. It lets the employees know what is expected of them. 2. Ethics and conflicts of interest rules were put in place based on the company’s main value; which is honesty. The policy sets forth the actions that need to be taken to, so you are not in violation of these codes. The policy was put in place to help their employees do the right thing, with......

Words: 948 - Pages: 4

Ethical Management

...Thomas Ayres 19 Nov 11 Ethical Management I. The Role of Managers differs depending on the corporate vision for the business. A. The duties of managers are to lead the company in an ethical manner consistent with the corporate vision. B. The code of conduct for managers is different for each organization. C. The availability of “golden parachutes” allows managers to make decisions that are not in the best interest of their companies. 1. There is no need to be accountable to workers for poor decisions made by managers. 2. The responsibility to shareholders is less of a factor due to the separation packages given to managers when they are hired. II. The enforcement of company ethics is largely left to managers, who aren’t left accountable to answer for their actions. A. Ethics for managers is less important than making a profit for the company. B. There is virtually no accountability for ethics standards in most companies today. C. The violations of company ethics is not taken as seriously as it should be taken. D. The recourse for violation of ethics is for managers to take their “golden parachutes” and move to another job. III. The ethics training and monitoring is non-existent in today’s companies. A. The effectiveness of training is questioned because most is computer based to save money. B. The cost of......

Words: 324 - Pages: 2

Ethical Issues in Management

...Ethical Issues in Management Oscar Puente MGT 216 Organizational Ethics and Social Responsibility August, 30 2010 Kenna Fowler Ethical Issues in Management The complexity of work ethics sometimes is more complicated than expected, the expectations from employees and the conflicts of interest in many cases creates hostile environment and causes irregularities between employees and their piers; the fundamental of social work is attention to the environmental forces, which creates and contributes problems in the living. Social workers can be affected to sensitive in cultural and ethnic diversity. Given the economy of this country the climate and number of Jobs people loses in a daily basis, most citizens are feeling the pressure to work harder. However, in spite of the increasing intensity of the economy crisis, it is not unfortunate to give up in to such pressure, the ethical dilemma of working Americans. The most valuable commodity people have is time and professionalism in their personal life. To employees in general it is known to be wrong spending too much time working in one project with the expense of other equally and critical tasks. The same is for managers taking too long managing one employee and unable to manage others. The most important thing to know is that ethics is not just to know how managers treat others but to learn management in their own selves; it isn’t fair to anyone else or yourself if you have not taking time off from work. You're also......

Words: 1229 - Pages: 5

Ethical Issue and Management Paper

...Ethical Issue and Management Paper XMGT/216 October 23 2010 In today work environment mangers are responsible for hiring, training and motivating their team. Managers are often faced with ethical issues that allow them to make decision based on company policies and federal law. But some mangers don’t always follow company and federal law when it comes to the hiring of employees and are sometimes bias with certain applicant. Part of my job as a manger is to recruit and interview potential candidates for available potions in my company, and by doing this, the first thing I have to do is to screen the applications to see if the applicant meets qualification for the open positions, and if they do the next step is to begin the selection process. There are certain questions an application that refer to age, sex, race and citizenship status that is required as part of the verification process. The application process also calls for prior employment history, as well as the reason for leaving or wanting to leave your current or prior job. Any of the information that the candidate provides is to be used as a lead to gather background information and check references. As a manager I have an ethical responsibility to hiring for the needs of the business as well as hiring the right person for the job. In today’s job market, we’re hiring people with diverse backgrounds to meet the needs of the public, sometimes hiring managers are faced with moral and ethical issues facing......

Words: 973 - Pages: 4

Ethical Issues in Management

...Ethical Issues in Management Charles Hall Axia Student Diversity in the workplace refers to the stark contrast of individuals within the same work environment. Many moral and ethical issues are faced by managers every day concerning diversity. Social Issues and ethically responsible management practices relate to workplace diversity in simple but important ways. Ethically it is irresponsible for managers to manage diversity in the workplace by acting insensitively towards employees. There are many ways that managers can avoid ethical issues concerning diversity in the workplace, but first they must understand the moral and ethical issues that they are faced with. Fifty years ago it was not uncommon to see any workplace filled with nothing but white adult males (Jr., 1990). Today that has changed. Walking into most workplaces will expose a person to an environment of diversity. This environment poses challenges to management that were not even a concern to doing business a generation ago. Programs like Affirmative Action have mandated that organizations heed government set quotas of employing minorities in their workplace (Jr., 1990). This has resulted in a complex new environment for managers where the bottom line is no longer the bottom line. Ethics are now the bottom line in a work environment where diversity plays a major role. Managers need to be in tune with their subordinates’ ethnicity, race, and background. Due to the political correctness (PC) movement of the......

Words: 1184 - Pages: 5