Premium Essay

Immigration Debate

In: Social Issues

Submitted By letoisha25
Words 995
Pages 4
Courtney Middlebrook
November 24, 2015
Humanities 1101
Professor Sanders
Discussion 4 & 5
The Immigration Debate 1. Why is the proposal to deport 11 million immigrants considered un-American?
Response: According to former Florida Governor, Jeb Bush, the proposal to deport 11 million immigrants would not be possible. Bush stated that deporting 11 million immigrants would not be as embracing of the American values. In his exact words, “It would tear communities apart and would send the wrong signals about America.” While researching and reading the transcript of this debate I felt a sense of political efficacy in regards to the topic on immigration. I am a hard-working American citizen and I have always had mixed feelings about immigrants living here. I believe the real issue lies in the fact that there are more illegal immigrants than there are legal and the ones that are legal are waiting in line who have as presidential candidate, Donald Trump stated, “gone through the process” to get to the United States. The other candidates as well as some American citizens would view the deportation force as un-American because America has always been a “with open-arms” country to willingly let people in to find a better lifestyle for their children and families. Therefore, with all of that being said, to forcefully deport 11 million immigrants back and tear up communities and families would be considered “un-American” but it is something that just has to be done if we want to get this country moving forward as Donald Trump mentioned. 2. Did your research reveal any response(s) from “legal” immigrants? If so, what has the reaction been? If not, what kind of impact do you think this debate has had on the psyche of immigrants in America? Be sure to substantiate your opinions.
Response: According to my research on latimes.com, many people have voiced their…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Immigration

...Adopting Arizona’s Immigration Law in All states Does politics have the upper hand on humanity in Arizona's immigration law SB-1070. This law should be abolished because it is racist, unfair and degrading to legal and illegal Latino immigrants? Immigration has always presented a problem for America and we now find ourselves faced with the issue on a large political scale. On July 29, 2010, the United States of America listened in as Arizona State put into effect their own immigration law. With the backing of Michigan, Alabama, Florida, Nebraska, Pennsylvania, and South Carolina Arizona has set the presence for illegal immigrants to face the law. The new law “directs officers to question people about their immigration status during the enforcement of other laws such as traffic stops, and if there's a reasonable suspicion they're in the U.S. illegally they will be deported”. “Arizona’s illegal alien population is 460,000 and according to a 2008 study by the Federation for American Immigration Reform, Georgia illegal alien population is 490,000”. (Inger Eberhart, 2010). As Americans we need to support Arizona’s efforts to clean house in fight of illegal aliens in the U.S. Most critics are saying that this is the strictest measure in generations for the detaining of illegal immigrants. The key work is “ILLEGAL”. Every American knows that if it is illegal then you should not be doing it, adolescent 101, but we live in a time where people feel that illegal......

Words: 1320 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Immigration

...The population of the United States has increased dramatically, making the United States Bureau of Immigration cut down on the laws of entering the U.S. illegally. Since congress passed the law of allowing a certain amount of immigrants to enter the U.S., they issue them passports and visas. After their passport and visa expire, they have to leave the country. Although this is a law, most immigrants do not leave the country, living illegally. If it were not for the Border Patrol, the American population would be higher than it already is. The Border Patrol regulates immigrants from illegally crossing the border. They patrol the border searching for possible immigrants crossing the border. If an immigrant is caught by U.S. authority, they will deport them and can charge them with additional fines and some jail time. For example, Mexico has the largest population of immigrants coming to America. Mexicans will actually hide from the Border Patrol in bushes, dirt, rubbish etc until they see the right moment and “run for it”. Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) keep the documents of Immigrants who are legal to live in the United States. Immigration and Naturalization Service strictly enforce the law of keeping immigration to a minimum. They only let a small amount of immigrants to come to America each year. The immigrants who can legally come to America are carefully chosen, it sometimes can take years to get approved. Estimated four million immigrants now live......

Words: 359 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Le Moyne College Renea Scott Sociology: Immigration 12 December 2012 President Barack Obama once stated “"We are the first nation to be founded for the sake of an idea—the idea that each of us deserves the chance to shape our own destiny. That’s why centuries of pioneers and immigrants have risked everything to come here .The future is ours to win. But to get there, we cannot stand still." This quote literally and symbolically embodies the dream that America has sold and many have bought. America’s democratic ideals for centuries have placed an emphasis on the unalienable right of every individual to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. However, this dream has led to mass immigration, which is at the center of many of America’s political, social and economic problems. Similar to the past, Legislators have failed in creating a policy that would not only accommodate immigrants but provides stability and security to its citizens. Congress’s inability to provide tangible paths to legalization is an issue that paves the way for the increase in illegal immigrants. The immigration process serves as a detriment for many foreigners that seek to attain legal entry and status. It violates America’s valued premises by preventing foreigners from pursuing happiness. The process of attaining legal status in the United States has proven to be harsh and extremely bureaucratic, which makes access illegal more viable. The legal status process requires a petition, which is......

Words: 2092 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Illegal Immigration Illegal immigration has been a problem for the United States for a long time. This phenomenon is not new because thousands of illegal immigrants have come into US through either the Mexico border, the Pacific Ocean, or through many other ways. Some people have entered the country legally through a visit visa, but then have stayed illegally and are working in various places. Illegal immigration is a double edged sword; in one hand it provide the local economy with cost benefits as the illegal immigrants are not paid so much, while they are more productive. On the other hand, these illegal immigrants do not pay taxes and their employers also do not pay their taxes. There are both pros and cons of illegal immigration and this paper shall take a look at some facts pertinent to illegal immigration in the United States. Every day thousands of illegals stream across the 2,500 miles of border with Mexico. According to the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service, or INS, the total number of illegals in America from this source increases by 275,000 annually. Already the United States is host to an illegal population of 7 to 12 million, of whom the vast majority are Mexican or Hispanic in origin. These illegal and uninvited guests help themselves to jobs, education, welfare and unemployment compensation. The many whose wages are paid under the table pay little or no taxes. And they are easy prey for unscrupulous employers and politicians (Ted Hayes). The U.S.......

Words: 2191 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Immigration Debate

...Immigration Debate BCOM/275 October 21, 2013 Immigration Debate America always was and still is a nation filled with a diverse group of people, many who have come from different countries. There have always been people on both sides of the fence, even back then on the subject, and we still have the same issue today. People have always been coming into the United States throughout history both legally and illegally. The issue has always been a topic of debate; even more so with each passing day. During the 1870s and on up through the 1920s a huge wave of immigration changed our history. Immigrants came from all over the world in search of both new lives and opportunities in what would be a great new land for them. Many came because their countries were so poverty-stricken they needed to start over. Some of the immigrants had difficulty being accepted into American society due to the oppression and hardships challenging their new start. Racial discrimination and rejection were common among new immigrants. The sudden spurt of immigration and the resistance from natives caused suppression imposed by the US government. The 1924 National Origins Acts drastically cut the number of immigrants allowed to come into the country. When this went into effect immigration, mainly from Asia and Southern and Eastern Europe, ended. During the years between the 1880s and 1920s around 25 million people came to the US which caused it to become a huge melting pot, with a variety of...

Words: 1936 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Immigration Debate

...pay no taxes to ease some of the pressure. However, the greatest cost is our children’s education. While the child is at school, their parents are most likely working. Illegally. These illegal workers are being allowed to work in America due to the soft stance policy makers have taken on immigration. They pay virtually no taxes like we as citizens must pay. The bottom line is by granting babies of illegal immigrants citizenship, we are negatively affecting our economy in a number of ways. 1. We pay out millions for public assistance for illegal immigrants and for their US born children. 2. Their parents who are not on paper and are forced to work illegally, do not pay taxes like everyone else because they are not legal citizens, Meanwhile they are reaping the public assistance that we as legal citizens pay for through taxes. 3. Taking jobs away from hard working Americans who as of recent have been experiencing a job shortage. They take jobs away by working for less money because they aren’t on paper and are forced to accept lower pay. If parents are serious about providing a better life in America, they should become legal citizens We of the proposition are 100% NOT against immigration, in fact, I encourage it. This is absolutely the greatest country of the world, and one of the greatest things is our diversity. All we ask is that you immigrate in observance with our laws and policies. Rather than throwing your child to the mercy of the US government and hoping......

Words: 1194 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Joey Dorion American Immigration II Professor McEvoy Paper 1 The United States has long held the title of a “land of immigrants,” a place where the downtrodden and rejected peoples of the old world could come to ply their trade, to attempt to carve out a meaningful existence for themselves. The American Dream was alive and well in the early waves of immigrants, as they came from the desired parts of Europe: namely England and Western Europe. They came with fire in their spirit, and determination to make a better life for themselves than they were able to have back in the Old World. They adapted, they assimilated, and they were able to become functioning and respected members of American society. It wasn’t until the second waves of immigrants arrived that a major opposition was formed, as fear of the foreigner spurred “old” immigrants and the “old” families of the northeast to preserve their ideals. It was with a deliberate and systematic approach that legislation was passed between the years of 1882 and 1929, keeping out those less than desired groups: Italians, Chinese, those from southwestern Europe. The White Anglo-Saxon Protestant preference was alive and out in the open in the American public, and all other policymaking went towards limiting only those who were thought not to possess the potential to become the epitome of the American citizen. The history of American immigration is one that is littered with racism, and more often than not blatant...

Words: 1994 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Immigration law should not be restricted America is not gold! Over a million immigrants come to the U.S each year (I.C.E 2007). The U.S has become an attractive zone for immigrants worldwide, and many people wonder why immigrants migrate to the U.S. People migrate to the U.S for different reasons; one of the main reasons why people migrate is family reunification (Deparle2). They don’t migrate because it has tall buildings and big cities, but because of problems back in their countries such as, lack of money, lack of freedom of religion, and because of unstable political condition. Subsequently, immigrants to the United States collaborate to the development of the nation in many ways. They do unwanted jobs and pay taxes. One reason why immigration seems so potent is that, it increased unexpectedly (Depaele3). The United State is the leading country with more immigrants. It has estimated that there are 241milliom migrants across the globe, an increase of about 37% in two decades, with many of them coming from North America (Deparle3). According to recent statistics, over a million immigrants in the United obtain legal permanent residence each year (I.C.E2007). Since the liberalization of immigration policy was passed in 1969, the number of immigrants in the country increased highly, from 9.6 million in 1970 to 38million in 2007. 1,046,539 million people were naturalized as U.S citizens 2008(I.C.E2007). The leading emigrating countries were Mexico, India and......

Words: 1405 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Immigration

...between short and long-term. First, he talks about how benefit immigration workforces can contribute their innovation can help to increase the nation’s welfare. In fact, according to National Science Foundation’s survey of Earned Doctorates show that “the share of PhDs awarded to foreign students rose from one fifth to three fourths in mathematics, computer science…” and many other aspects. As a result, the successful-skilled labor likely to earn more and spend more, which means that tax-contribution will be higher. Second, he tries to weigh out the good and bad influences of low-skilled immigration in a smaller scale, particularly the roles of balancing out workforces though out the country. He states that the low-skilled ones can help to take care of the household jobs so that well-educated portions can focus on their jobs that can help to increase the productivity growth, and they can also use their mobility to ease needs of labors at different regions. Next, he talks about roles of immigration related with the tax burden which is hard to find a complete solution. The fact is that it doesn’t matter There are a lot of debates on government spending linked to immigration, but the problem is hard to solve because of many difficult factors, for example: the cost to reduce illegal immigration is very high that can exceed the overall Reflection: I totally agree with this author about the immigration is not a burden to the US economy. In fact, it has a......

Words: 545 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Immigration By: Landry Evans 11/25/2014 Composition I Immigration By: Landry Evans Thesis: One problem that is becoming a major issue in and around this country is immigration. I. What is immigration and what are some possible solutions? * Define Immigration. * Discuss things such as border control, and monitoring who is coming into this country. * One problem is when people come it is to easy for them to start to fit in, people must make it hard for theses people to discourage this immigration. II. Discuss how upgraded the strength of the border, and who border control can stop people. * The strength of the American border is a major problem. * The border patrol needs to guard the rural areas harder. III. Should children born to illegal immigrants inside the United States be U.S. citizens? * This is where the problem lies. * This gives illegal immigrants a foothold into this country because of their children. Immigration By: Landry Evans There are many things within this country that is beginning to become hot topic issues. There are issues such as: abortion, deforestation, bullying, and terrorism. One thing that is becoming an important issue and that there can be many solutions to is illegal immigration. Immigration at its simplest form is the movement of non-native people into a country in order to settle there (Dictionary). It is leaving one country in order to go to another country, where the person is not a...

Words: 1643 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Immigration

...freedom is a right not a privilege, and there’s no limit to what one man can accomplish. Overall America is probably one of the top countries someone could live in; People go to extreme lengths such as sneaking cross the border or building un-sturdy boats to take on the notorious deep blue sea in hopes of getting to America. This has cause immigration to evolve into a serious situation. Immigration affects the United States in a variety of ways, both good and bad. The Unites States provides numerous opportunities for immigrants, opportunities that may be scarce or not available in their home land. Equal rights laws make it easier for illegal aliens to have an even set playing field when it’s comes to getting a job and/or an education. Illegal immigrants are usually very determined to have a better life or to take care of their families, “they are always ready to take up low wage jobs and are very willing to take up tasks that an ordinary American might hesitate in undertaking. As a result, many companies are benefiting from this because they are getting cheap labor within the country” said Bruce Maureillo in his Weighing Illegal Immigration Pros and Cons article. In that same article he also so said “the US government received $305 million as taxes collected from the illegal immigrants in the US. It is believed that the illegal aliens who reside at borders and other parts of the country help increase business in such areas by purchasing goods. Whenever they purchase a......

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Immigration

...In today’s world we face a big problem. The ongoing problem is what are we going to do about illegal immigrants. According to Oxford English Dictionary, immigration is “the action of immigrating; entrance into a country for the purpose of settling there” (OED). Immigration is a very hot topic in the United States today. There have been many debates and discussions about the issue in regards to if immigration is beneficial to our country or if it’s not. There are millions of illegal immigrants in the country today. Many people think that these immigrants area big problem for our economy and other factors of the government. In reality these people have been doing the opposite. Immigration is all over the country and you have more than likely encountered some before. Immigration is a very important topic for a reason. The United States has been running well because of it but then again these immigrants are stealing many Americans jobs to an extent. There are many positive benefits that come from immigration. These include an increase in demand, more investment, increased operation, and more jobs being taken (Nadadur 1041). These all affect the economy of the United States in a positive way. Demand for jobs is increased because of the incoming flow of people that are looking for jobs. They come to America with the intent of getting a good job and being able to support their family. These jobs might not always be the best jobs but they still get to do more than they could at......

Words: 1059 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Abstract Immigration is the subject of much debate in the United States. Throughout that debate many differing topics are discussed including politics, national security, financial burden and over population. The topic that many would expect to see here is race but it is not part of the current discussion on immigration. Immigration Immigration has been a controversial subject throughout the history of the United States. In the past much of the conversation about immigration had to do with race and racism. Today the conversation has shifted to topics such as politics, security, financial drain on society, and overpopulation. Race is no longer the driving factor in the current debate over immigration in the United States. Politics If you were to look in the newspaper or online for the topic of immigration most of what you will find is about President Obama’s immigration reform. In November of 2014 Obama enacted an executive order to protect up to five million illegal immigrants from deportation. Since then Obama has been sued by a coalition of 25 states. A Texas court issued an injunction to stop Obama’s executive order from being implemented (Hill, 2015). This injunction was then upheld by a federal court and the Justice Department now plans to appeal that decision (Hill, 2015). Immigration has become a very political issue that both Republicans and Democrats feel requires change. Unfortunately the two parties have yet to come to any sort of agreement as to what those......

Words: 1170 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Immigration Political Issue SOC 315- Cultural Diversity November 23, 2011 Immigration Political Issue The United States have long battle immigration issues over the years with immigrants who take whatever measures necessary to make it to the United States. They take boats, hike across the border at night, are smuggled across the border in vehicles and are stow away on vessels and trains. This paper will present a discussion on the current law that was passed in Alabama regarding immigration policies that went into effect September 1, 2011. In addition, it will review the historical framework on this issue, the political context, the role of the media, the effect on the United States economy and labor force, and management strategies to promote inclusion in the workplace. Immigrants in America, always has been a hot debate. Many Americans believe they should not be allowed to live in the United States illegally. On the other hand others find no problem with them residing illegally as long as they are willing to work and are not living off the government. Generally, immigration is from countries with lower standards of living to those that offer better wages, (Schaefer pg.87). On April 5, 2011 Alabama reformed its immigration policy known as the HB-56 law considered as somewhat harsh changes affecting immigrants in the state illegally. The changes included the checking of undocumented students in schools, penalizing employers who hire undocumented workers, and providing......

Words: 1173 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Running Head: Immigration and Its Impacts on Aspects of U.S Society Immigration and Its Impacts on U.S Society’s Growth Tri N Mai SOC 100 Strayer University 2/8/2012 Immigration and Its Impacts on U.S Society’s Growth 1. Describe how society defines the social issue. Having a self image seen as a “melting pot”, the U.S country is a place where people from other countries come to live, adapt, and take part in U.S culture by distributing their own culture’s special characteristics. However, because of immigration, it is one of the main sources that cause social chaotic and triggers so many endlessly political arguments. So how does society define immigration? “The rational and ideological” are two central perceptions of which society are considered. What it means to be rational here is “the traditionalist position on immigration.” It comprehends a multi-leveled actuality that consists of several gradations of similarities and differences between a range of individuals and cultures. Generally, regarding to immigrants’ cultures and characters, some of them are more alike to U.S country and its people while some aren’t. Also, in a traditionally developed country as U.S, when it comes to politic matters and communal debates of social benefits, relating to immigration and being based on reasonable gradations of similarities and differences, they will cause discrimination amid soon-to-be settler groups. And what’s about “ideological”? According to Lawrence...

Words: 1291 - Pages: 6