Premium Essay

Functionist View on Ethnic Inequality

In: Social Issues

Submitted By apalmer22
Words 1564
Pages 7
Outline and Assess functionalist explanations for ethnic inequality
Functionalists hold the view that ethnic inequality is a dysfunctional for society, and that ethnic minorities need to become more similar to the white majority. This is known as Assimilation theory, which is staunchly criticised by the Marxists who believe racism exists to justify the inequalities that are so wide spread by the Bourgeoisie via Capitalism. Weberianism concurs with Marxists (so they diverge from the Functionalists) to an extent, but they introduce status into the explanation. Postmodernists take a approach antagonistic to all of the afore mentioned approaches, and that is to argue that blanket terms such as ethnicity are no longer relevant in the modern era, where our identities are defined by consumerism and globalisation.
Functionalists outline the Assimilation Theory, suggested by Patterson. Patterson believes that the influx of immigrants into Britain in the 1950s disturbed what was a homogenous society with social stability and a high degree of social integration, leading to a value consensus. The norms and values brought in with the immigrants led to a Cultural Clash, where each different ethnicity were seen to be against the norm. This created many stereotypes e.g. boisterous West Indians. Prejudice also came about, buoyed by xenophobia, competing for jobs between ethnicities and a lack of similarity (Assimilation) with foreigners. Patterson continues by arguing this has caused self-segregation, whereby ethnic minorities separate themselves in certain areas, and this combined with ‘White Flight’ has caused entire areas and schools to be dominated by certain ethnicities e.g. Tower Hamlets and South Hall. However, the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) point out that self-segregation is caused by racism, rather than white flight. Additionally, research has found that…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Assess the View That Ethnic Minority Pupil's Underachievement in Education Is the Result of Teacher Labelling and Racism

...Assess the view that ethnic minority pupil’s underachievement in education is the result of teacher labelling and racism (20 marks) A students ethnicity can be a large influencing factor on their education, many teachers are racist, labelling students on their ‘race’ or ethnicity. A person’s race is the biological differences from person to person, for example skin colour. Whereas ethnicity entirely depends on the individual. Ethnicity is influenced by numerous factors such as ancestry, experience of racism, language, geographical location, and so on. According to the question being of an ethnic minority causes underachievement, meaning that white British students should be achieving highest in the UK. This is not the case, many ethnic minorities achieve better results than white British students. According to government statistics, Chinese and Indian students received the highest percentage of grades of grades A* to C at GCSE in 2010/11. White British pupils are the mid achieving students, with Pakistani and Black Caribbean students achieving the lowest GCSE results. Many teachers label their students, due to stereotypical or racist viewpoints they hold and this can often to lead to underachievement. According to Gillborn and Youdell (2000), teachers are quicker to punish black students than others of different ethnicities for similar behaviour. This leads to many black students being anti-school, rejecting education and then underachieving. Mirza (1992) found after......

Words: 892 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Ethnic

...Evaluating the role of ethnic identity in explaining the occurrence of contemporary civil conflicts in sub-Saharan Africa. High hopes for many newly independent states of Africa became diminished as the 1990s saw over a quarter of the continent's states facing armed insurgencies within their borders (Young, 2002: 534). Commentators often point to pathological, deep-seated hatreds in an African tribal mosaic as the bases of such conflict. The fact is, however, that the continent is awash with political grudges, ethnically-framed and otherwise, but civil wars rarely break out. Thus this essay seeks to take a more nuanced approach to understand the analytical challenge posed by such disorder. Starting out by countering the centrality of ethnic identity, it firstly seeks to demonstrate that ethnic identities do not exist primordially, but that they are constructed on weak foundations. Secondly it endeavours to show that where cleavages do exist along lines of cultural difference, simple heterogeneity is insufficient to account for the outbreak of conflict. Next, it moves to underline the fact that more important in explaining civil conflict is whether such conflict is feasible. This is understood both in terms of the perceived capacity of the state and in terms of the viability of insurgency for would-be rebels. A final conclusion will then be expounded that ethnicity is not a central factor, but that it is simply one of a number of strategies under which conflict may be......

Words: 2475 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Assess the View That, for Minority Ethnic Groups, the Practice of Religion and Membership of Religious Groups in Mainly a Form of Cultural Defence

...Assess the view that, for minority ethnic groups, the practice of religion and membership of religious groups in mainly a form of cultural defence. (33 marks) A question on religion is very hard to answer as religion and how religious ethnic groups are is difficult to measure. For example, when investigating as to whether someone is religious or not we may use a questionnaire that involves questions like, "How often does someone visit a sacred place?” This question can be criticised because a child may go to church every week but only because their parents make them, this doesn't mean that they are religious. Equally a person may not be able to attend for practical reasons but they would still consider themselves religious. Religiosity is not like height, where we have set measurements. It is subjective and not easily operationalised. Ethnicity describes ancestry, heritage, religion, nationality and language. Ethnic groups are sub groups that share cultural characteristics and individuals can decide as to whether they like those characteristics and want to join their group or not. An ethnic minority groups is one which is different from the majority population and whose cultural identity and beliefs differ from the main set of religious practices. Cultural defence is where religion serves to unite communities against external threats. In these situations religion is significant, the reason for this is that religion symbolises groups of collective identity defending......

Words: 1711 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Inequality and the Sociological Impacts

...Inequality and the Sociological Impacts In modern society inequality is an inescapable fact of life; certain social groups are better positioned than others to take advantage of the opportunities, wealth and power of a society. When Australian society is examined it becomes obvious that indigenous people as a social group are faced with a decided disadvantage when it comes to opportunities, wealth and power. This essay intends to focus on the over-representation of indigenous people in the criminal justice system from a sociological viewpoint. This over-representation becomes sociologically significant when it is seen as an expression of inequality meaning that wider social issues are at play that effect indigenous people specifically. The two major reasons or drivers of this over-representation stem from this inequality; the first is an element of institutional discrimination found in both the courts and the police services in Australia which tend to target indigenous people disproportionately with the facilitation of legislation and practices which indigenous people have little to no involvement in formulating. The second is a set of cultural and social norms that exist amongst indigenous people which clash with the norms of the dominant white culture who are responsible for the laws and regulations that all groups in society are meant to abide by. Furthermore social conflict theories on crime such as those formulated by Turk and Sellin provide a rich theoretical support...

Words: 2420 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

“Outline and Assess the View That Changing the Attitudes and Lifestyles of the Poor Will Reduce Health Inequalities.”

...which merely reproduces the inverse care law. Those that in need of the greatest care often receive fewer resources. Many of the middle and higher class have access to health care and or private healthcare, whereas the working class and the underclass have access to GP’s in many inner cities where they face intensive demands on their funds. During 2000, the Labour government offered services, which are more convenient for citizens; high street health centres were established with the aid of day surgeries, and by also providing a more flexible health care system, which reduces the strain on hospitals. However, this would be unsuccessful without the consideration of other causes of health inequalities and health care across the nation. There are many solutions to the problem of health inequality, Townsend and Phillimore note the relationship between bad housing, poor diet, lack of play areas, overcrowding, poor education and exposure to infection. They conclude that the, “health gap is a consequence of the wealth gap”. The New right theory states that the welfare state has encouraged the growth of a culture where the poor have little motivation and ambition to work, preferring instead to depend on benefits. In the past, the Conservative Government and other sociologists argued that by maintaining welfare condition in its present form does little to help those in poverty. Moreover, it imposes an unbearable burden on business and ordinary taxpayers, whilst discouraging......

Words: 1265 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Social Inequalities

...Inequalities in Society P1 The society that we live in today isn’t equal, inequalities can be seen in every corner of the earth and there are a whole multitude of different explanations and factors that are causing this. When we talk about an unequal society we are referring to the why one person can and will achieve things such as obtaining their dream job and or fulfilling their lives ambition. But another person with just as much drive and determination, ability and intelligence as the previously stated, one who is equal to any other but does not live a life that holds the same opportunities as everyone else. For a very basic example we state that individuals of different ethnicity will have their thoughts and desires held at higher or lesser importance purely because of where they are from, this is called marginalisation. Stereotyping and prejudices are often interlinked but they are different and both play the part in inequalities, stereotyping being the act of assuming an idea and or image of something or someone while prejudice is a preconceived idea or perception that is formed without any actual experience. Discrimination and labelling are also major factors that can breed inequality, treating somebody different or valuing them differently based on a specific factor about them or assigning them to a category for the same reasons. From all of the above people can develop an attitude towards and person or thing, an example of this would be that say an individual is...

Words: 2276 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Assess the View That the Main Function of the Education System Is to Reproduce & Legitimise Social Inequalities.

...Sociology essay Assess the view that the main function of the education system is to reproduce & legitimise social inequalities. Functionalists believe that education serves a purpose and gives everyone an equal chance to achieve and succeed. They believe education has a function to create a fully operational society and allocate roles fitting the correct people. However, a conflict argument (Marxism), disagree. Marxism believe that not everyone at school gets an equal opportunity (The myth or meritocracy) and that social class, gender and ethnicity all impact on what grades you will come out with. They also believe that education system reproduces social inequalities and legitimises them. Functionalists say the education system socialises children to adapt to a meritocratic view of achievement. At home a child is given a status (Particularistic standards) and at school universalistic standards apply, this means your status starts at a level playing field. This status will go up or down based on merit. One theorist who picked up on this was Talcott Parsons, and he suggested that education is a vital part to instil the major value of achievement. Marxist theorist Bourdieu disagrees with this view, he believe once at school not everyone starts at a level playing field and it is the lower classes who suffer most, this is evident in Item A. Item A states “School systematically fail the majority of working class pupils” this is supported by Bourdieu who adds that......

Words: 750 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Assess the View That the Main Function of the Education System Is to Reproduce and Legitimise Social Inequalities

...college. This was primarily based on teaching the children purely manual skills which in turn would be used for manual labour. This system frequently served to reinforce social inequality because it was largely middle class children who went to Grammar school, while the working classes were frequently restricted to either Secondary Modern’s or technical schools. The difference being that middle class families provided their children with advantageous primary socialisation in the form of literature, using a wide vocabulary, etc which resulted in a stark difference in ability at the age of eleven. The system was highly criticised by saying that it did not allow fair opportunity for children from all social backgrounds so in response to this in the 1960’s/70’s the British Labour Government designed and introduced the ‘Comprehensive’. The Comprehensive was intended to reduce class differences in educational attainment. It allowed children to mix from all social backgrounds and therefore provided equal opportunity. Although this system has been highly criticised since it was first introduced there are a number of factors which imply and suggest that although the comprehensive system is less diverse than the tripartite, it still does little to engender social equality if anything, serves to reinforce class inequality. According to the Marxist Sociologist, Bowles and Gintis (Schooling in Capitalist America, 1976), education will always what the curriculum entails and therefore......

Words: 2328 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Assess the View That Ethnic Differences in Achievement Are Primarily the Result of Home Background Factors

...compared to white or Asian children; who are instilled with ambition and a willingness to achieve thanks to the mainstream culture they are brought up in. Family structure varies greatly between ethnic groups, Ken Pryce argues that Asians are higher achievers because their culture is more resistant to racism and gives them a greater sense of self worth, whereas Black pupils have low self esteem due to racism and as such they achieve less in education. Driver and Ballard argue that Asian family structures are more positive to wards education and have higher aspirations for their children so they achieve more. Moynihan for example, states that a lone mother heads many black families and as such her children are deprived of adequate care due to financial pressure, this then becomes a cycle these children fail at school then have children who grow up with the same attitudes and values. However, white working class children under-achieve and have lower aspirations, Lupton found that this was due to lack of parental support. However, Geoffrey Driver criticises CD theorists for ignoring the positive aspects of ethnicity on achievement, and argues that black Caribbean families provide girls with a positive role model to go on to be an independent woman. Furthermore, Lawrence challenges Pryce’s view that black people fail because of their culture and low self esteem, he says they fail due to racism from wider society as well as teachers. However, Material Deprivation (MD) can......

Words: 621 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

A New View of Income Inequality and Business Ethic

...A New View of Income Inequality and Business Ethic Introduction It is believed that almost all employees care about business ethical issues, particularly in the area of equality in the workplace. For instance, people will be more motivated to their positions if they are offered the equal opportunity in terms of individual development in the corporation; however, employees may feel dissatisfied about the unequal pay. The pay gap among different position levels have been noticed which could result in the concern of income maldistribution. By discussing the maldistribution of income in the business, the focus of this article will be the analysis of historical reasons, which may contribute to addressing this ethical issue. Maldistribution of Income during the Great Depression When discovering the reason of the great depression since 1929 in USA, income inequality was seen as one of the main factors that make the system vulnerable to economic shocks (Heilbroner 95). Although American economy created enough potential buying power to purchase what it had produced, the conditions of income maldistribution can be very serious. Those lower-income groups such as farmers and workers, with a limitless desire to consume, did not get sufficient capability to buy because of the failure to distribute the profits of productivity at that time. As Heilbroner stated (96), such extraordinarily intensive incomes among diverse income pyramid displayed a prosperity of unequaled extent with little......

Words: 991 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Asses the View That the Main Function of the Education System Is to Reproduce and Legitimise Social Inequalities.

...Asses the view that the main function of the education system is to reproduce and legitimise social inequalities. Functionalist writers such as Parsons have suggested that social inequality in contemporary societies is based on the principal of meritocracy and equality of opportunity. In meritocracy, social inequality is based on the different abilities, talents and skills individuals have. For most people today, their abilities and talents are demonstrated by their educational qualifications, and everyone should have an equal opportunity to develop and achieve these educational qualifications, regardless of their social class background, ethnicity or disability. However, there is significant evidence that Britain is not meritocratic, and the link between educational qualifications and pay levels is relatively weak. Most sociologists argue that not everyone has the same chance of developing their talents and skills, and that there opportunity in education. Marxists adopt the idea that education serves the needs of the economic foundation of society, along with other principles such as family, mass media, religion and politics. They also believe that the education system does not maintain and reproduce existing social class, ethnic and gender inequalities from one generation to the next. The evidence for this lack of equality of opportunity in education is that, even for students of the same ability, there are wide differences in educational achievement which are......

Words: 737 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Inequality

...Issues in inequality in non-income dimensions Achin Chakraborty Institute of Development Studies Kolkata 1, Reformatory Street, 5th Floor Calcutta University Alipore Campus Kolkata 700 027 India achinchak@rediffmail.com Abstract There are two basic approaches to measuring inequality in non-income dimensions. One views inequality as variation of an outcome indicator across individuals and the other views inequality as essentially disparities across socioeconomic groups. While the latter view now dominates the inequality measurement in health, measurement of education inequalities has so far taken the first view. In this paper, we have argued the importance of reckoning inequality in socio-economic group terms and advocated use of an ‘education concentration index’ exactly in the same way as the health concentration index measures socio-economic inequalities in health. The index has been applied to the Indian data to reckon two kinds of inequalities in educational attainment (years of education) – one across economic classes and the other across socially identified groups such as the Scheduled Tribes, Scheduled Castes and others. We find a strong correlation between the two types of inequalities across the states of India. We also find, as one would expect, that the inequality index values are negatively correlated with the average years of education. However, in actual policy context, analysis of the outliers...

Words: 5018 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Assess the View That the Main Function of the Education System Is to Reproduce and Legitimise Social Inequalities

...function of the education system is to reproduce and legitimise social inequalities as in Althusser’s view education transmits class inequality from generation to generation and legitimates class inequalities by producing ideologies that disguise the truth. The education system develops a false consciousness in the working class, they are manipulated into thinking that capitalism is reasonable and fair in organising society. Marxists Bowles and Gintis suggest that the economy determines what happens in the education system. They argue that capitalism requires a workforce with particular attitudes and personality-types to suit their roles as exploited workers. Therefore the education system’s main function is to reproduce an obedient workforce that will accept inequality in a capitalist society, as schools provide long hours of work to correspond with what they will encounter once they begin working. From their own study, Bowles and Gintis concluded the hidden curriculum is more important than other aspects of the educational process as it mirrors the relationships and structures found in the workplace. The hidden curriculum is the lessons that are taught in school without being on the official timetable. For example, pupils become accustomed to accepting the hierarchy within school and working for extrinsic rewards. Therefore the main function of the education system is to reproduce and legitimize social inequalities as schools prepare the working-class for their roles as......

Words: 759 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Racial and Ethnic Inequality

...Administration Sociology Key words Racial inequality, ethnic inequality, geographic location, discrimination, cultural orientation Causes of racial and ethnic inequality This discussion looks at the causes of racial and ethnic inequalities in the world. There are a number of causes of inequalities. Some causes are geographical location and discrimination. However inequality is on the decline on a global scale. Racial and ethnic inequality is found in many countries where there are either many races or ethnics or both. In Zimbabwe there is racial and ethnic inequality. There are various reasons for that. Whereas my discussion covers what is basically in my country, I have also researched on ethnic and racial inequalities in United States of America as from 1950s to 1970s, and the current situation. One main cause of inequality is the geographical location. Some people who are located in most remote areas of the country normally become marginalized. There is poor transportation system, poor education and far of from urban centers where technology and industrialization is mainly found. These people who live in remote areas are cut of from the rest of the world. They do not access quality education. Hence they remain marginalized and backward. In Zimbabwe a number of ethnic groups are found at the borders of the country. That is the reason for the inequality. Another cause of this disparity is cultural orientation. Various ethnic groups have varying values. Some......

Words: 683 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Inequalities

...TMA 01 Clare Swan - (B6446618) Outline some of the ways in which inequalities have been made and remade in South Wales. In this essay I will be looking at the inequalities, which is the unequal distribution of valued social resources within a society or between societies and how they have been and remade. I shall be looking at the legacy of coal, gender inequality and the redevelopment of Cardiff Bay. The presence of coal affected many aspects of life. Many different people earned their livelihoods through coal, directly or indirectly. Shops served a thriving community. There were clear inequalities between the roles of the woman and the men. The work in the deep mines constructed a particular sort of masculinity, of the miner being necessarily a physically strong person coping with heavy work, dirt and dust. This was linked with the feeling of honour and being the bread winner. Wives were based at home taking supporting roles to husbands and children. The 1984/5 miners strike marked the transformation of the traditional roles of women and men. Barbra Williams, the wife of a miner tells us that woman were good enough to work behind the bar at the Meardy Social Club but they were not able to sit within the bar. At the same time, both woman and men came together in solidarity during the miners strike. The strike resulted in a high-profile role for the miners’ wives. Whilst the men were on strike the miners’ wives like Barbara Williams felt they had to take......

Words: 1156 - Pages: 5