Functional vs. Dysfunctional Conflict in a Work Group

In: Business and Management

Submitted By nateburkholder
Words 941
Pages 4
Functional Vs. Dysfunctional Conflict in a Work Group

There are several factors that are important in creating an effective and efficient work team. Some, such as diversity, knowledge, and skill are obvious. However, the most important factor in building a strong team is conflict. Most individuals have a negative view of conflict. While there are negative aspects of conflict, it can also draw team members together and create an atmosphere conducive to a creative and thorough problem solving environment. In today’s business world it is extraordinarily important for individuals to work within teams well. Each team member must be able to consider differing opinions and adapt their ideas to make the decisions that benefit the whole team. There are two main types of conflict to consider when working in teams: functional conflict and dysfunctional conflict.
Functional conflict allows for creative ideas and strong team performance. As stated before, many people have a negative view of conflict but it is the very diversity of opinions and ideas within a group that is the most important factor in good decision making. It is these differing opinions that will create alternative solutions, which best utilizes scarce resources. Multiple ideas allow for healthy debate and problem solving. Debate allows everyone with a differing view to state their case and describe why their solution is better, and allows the team to make decisions with more potential solutions. An increased number of solutions will limit the chance of certain factors not being considered in the problem solving process. The discussion and debate of issues will allow for an environment where ideas can evolve, adapt, and ultimately be more beneficial for the team. This kind of conflict leads to thorough well thought out decisions that can be satisfying to the majority of the team.
In most problem solving…...

Similar Documents

Project Manager vs Functional Manager

...sensitive to others' personalities, habits and including but not limited to work style and pace, and also ensuring the project maintains positive equilibrium through team cooperation. Leadership, Ethics and Management Style - refers to a dynamic skill set a project manager must have in order to successfully direct, control and complete projects and effectively manage the project team. Ability to Handle Stress - projects are typically fast paced, volatile, constantly changing scope and direction, and very challenging. Stress is a natural occurrence that naturally arises from managing a project. The Project manager must be able to handle the stress that may arise at each phase of the project life cycle,in order to efficiently manage the project, the team and engage all stakeholders. 3. Discuss the PM's responsibilities toward the project team members. According to Meredith and Mantel, the project manager's responsibilities falls into 3 categories: responsibility to senior management, the project and client and finally the project team members (Meredith and Mantel, 2012, p. 105). The responsibilities that the PM has towards the project team members are as follows: 1. Keep team members informed of potential threats and risks. 2. Keep team members motivated and create and cultivate a high level of team work. 3. Must preserve and actively assist the project team members return back to regular, functional duties. According to Meredith and Mantel, without this......

Words: 859 - Pages: 4

Group, Teams and Conflict

...Groups, Teams, and Conflict Andrew Carnegie said “teamwork is the ability to work together toward a common vision; the ability to direct individual accomplishments toward organizational objectives. It is the fuel that allows common people to attain uncommon results” (Smart Entrepreneur). As one of the Superintendents at Riordan Manufacturing it is my belief that teams are an essential way to distribute job duties and complete a task on time. The teams which have been chosen will begin to form from current employees and some newly hired individuals. The objective of the teams is to start production of the newly designed CardiCare Valve at the Pontiac Michigan facility. The purpose of this paper is to identify the various strategies that make up the teams, the challenges which may occur, and the measures which will be taken to ensure the team is operating successfully. Various Strategies There are various strategies when forming a successful team. As role of Superintendent, I will use the five strategies of effective team building to assist in building the team of individuals to design the CardiCare Valve heart valves for Riordan Manufacturing. Clear expectations “begin by analyzing the team’s mission, developing goals to achieve that mission and creating strategies for achieving the goals” (Robbins & Judge, 2011, p. 327). The first strategy is to choose leaders within each team who will ensure the team know what their role is and then distribute the work evenly among the......

Words: 957 - Pages: 4

Conflicts at Work

...1. Problems * Conflicts among employees that go unchecked can spoil morale and hamper productivity. A Career Builder article by Rachel Zupek notes that conflicts can become a distraction that keeps employees from focusing on their work. Furthermore, Zupek indicates that conflicts have the potential for ruining teamwork if they cause employees to resent their co-workers or their employer. Gossip may also increase as employees involved in conflicts look for support among co-workers by claiming mistreatment. Some co-workers will take sides, which only raises the level of conflict. Benefits * Conflicts in the workplace can be beneficial if they force people to communicate in a constructive way to resolve their problems. Constructive communication causes people to consider a situation from another person's point of view. For example, Zupek notes that people can misinterpret someone's actions or words because they communicate differently. Perhaps a co-worker feels insulted by something another co-worker supposedly said. A discussion among employees may reveal that the interpretation of another person's comments was incorrect or made worse by gossip. * Sponsored Links * Catch Your Cheater Spouse 1) Enter Their Email Address 2) See Hidden Social Profiles & Pics Now! Employers * Employers who don't make an effort to prevent a bottleneck in communication may contribute to conflicts in the workplace.......

Words: 391 - Pages: 2

Group Work

..._______________Rui Xie_______________ ***************************************************************** Instructor's Grade on Assignment: Instructor's Comments: Reflection Paper I am in the Group 4, they all very kind and gave me a great many of help. This is the second time we get together to do the case. And I found that it is easier than the last time. We just meet after class and allocated the work as last time, it is easier for each person to do the same part what they did before and know how to improve it. We know each other by the first teamwork and this time we don’t need waste time on build a communication line, know each other, or rebuild the trust. It makes the teamwork more effective. What I learn from this group work is that a team needs some time when individuals challenge themselves and re-evaluate their skills. Team members need to learn how to work well with others and to understand that a person is unique; a person has knowledge and energy that can be channeled in a positive way. We do our own work very well, nobody late or forget to do something and we do almost same weight of work in our team. Also, we have some conflict on some little points, but this conflict makes the paper seems better. In USA, everyone in group talks and shares his or her opinion, sometimes they arguing a lot and from their arguing they can learn a lot. In China, we just follow the leader. The leader makes decision and also takes responsibility to......

Words: 438 - Pages: 2

Conflict of the Known vs the Unknown

...CONFLICT OF THE KNOWN Vs THE UNKNOWN The novel What is the What by Dave Eggers depicts the struggle of the Lost Boys during the second civil war in Sudan. Egger writes the book for Valentino Achak Deng, a Lost Boy, who gives us a first hand account of the brutal experiences that the boys encountered. On reading the book, it was very touching, because every incident was carefully described with emotion, and gave us an insight into various conflicts that Achak himself faced. Recently we (The University of Tampa students) were visited by one of the Lost Boys, Atem, and he shared with all of us his first hand experiences when he fled Sudan. Atem was faced with many conflicts. When he was only six years old he fled Sudan. He is currently in Jacksonville, Florida with his family except his dad who was shot. When he fled Sudan he had no idea where his family was, and had lost complete touch with them. In United States, he was later reunited with his family, and his mother was unable to recognize him. Although she eventually realized he was a grown man and she finally acknowledged it was Atem. The Lost Boys faced many conflicting moments and decisions on their way to Ethiopia. One conflicting theme throughout the novel is the idea of the known versus the unknown. For example, on the way to Ethiopia, Achak and all the other boys envisioned Ethiopia to have tall buildings and many healthy people. Achak imagined, “We would have chairs in Ethiopia. I would sit on a chair, and I would......

Words: 707 - Pages: 3

Conflict in Work Teams

...International Conference page 15 CONFLICT IN WORK TEAMS: PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS Brittany Sikes, Florida Institute of Technology Robert D. Gulbro, Athens State University Linda Shonesy, Athens State University ABSTRACT Conflict is almost certain to occur in work teams due to the fact that they are comprised of different people possessing different perceptions, personalities, and behaviors. Although incredibly effective, work teams may stumble upon barriers which must be overcome to allow for growth and continuation towards the common goals of the group. It is quite possible that a work team may perform without the presence of conflict, but oftentimes certain measures have been implemented to prevent such conflict from occurring. Occasional conflict, if managed appropriately, can lead to creativity, better decision-making, and improved results. However, too much conflict can lead to a decrease in performance and group cohesion. In global organizations there is an opportunity for cross-cultural differences that may increase conflict. Contained herein are both the positive and negative consequences of conflict, as well as courses of action to understand, prevent, and resolve conflict that occurs within work teams or groups. THE VALUE OF WORK TEAMS A work team is defined as an organized group, committed to the individuals within the group, whose members share the same intent of accomplishing a common goal. Managers have become more inclined to utilize work teams when......

Words: 2676 - Pages: 11

Group Work

...reflecting on the effectiveness of working in short term groups who have been brought together in a study environment. My group was formed to work on a presentation where the topic was the way different types of teams communicate. My group consisted of five people: Brendon, Dominic, Bridgette, Kelly and myself. I have worked with everyone in this group before, however not as a group, and was confident that we would make a good team. I have a very dominant personality and tend to take the leadership role in these situations and so I took the lead (Thoms, Moore & Scott 1996), however it was also a collaboration, everyone gave their ideas and all ideas were discussed. I will be exploring the advantages and disadvantages of group work within the University setting based on my own group experiences. According to (Hodgkinson-Williams, Slay & Siebörger, 2008 and Lave & Wenger, 1991) the use of group work is an increasingly recognised way for students to problem solve and develop transferable skills which are necessary for the workplace. Group work can also help with expanding the student’s emotional intelligence (Landau & Meirovich, 2011). Emotional intelligence is a quality that employers are now looking for more and more in their employees, even to the point where learning about emotional intelligence is part of management training and development. ADVANTAGES It is believed that the greatest focus of groups, especially those that have been......

Words: 1795 - Pages: 8

Work and Personal Life Conflict

...A1: An examination of work and personal life conflict, organizational support, and employee health among international expatriates Elisa J. Grant-Vallonea,*, Ellen A. Ensherb Grant-Vallone, E.J., & Ensher, E. A. (2001). International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 25(3), 261-278. doi: 10.1016/S0147-1767(01)00003-7 Abstract: This study analyzes the effect of two types of work and personal life conflict and organizational support on expatriate employees’ mental well-being. Survey data were obtained from a culturally diverse sample of 118 employees working in Europe. Overall, employees reported higher levels of work interfering with their personal life, than personal life interfering with their work. Results demonstrated that work–personal life conflict was related to employees’ depression and anxiety and personal–work life conflict was related to employees’ concern for their health. Organizational support had significant main effects on well-being and conflict; however, organizational support did not buffer the effects of conflict on expatriates’ well-being. Although organizations are often concerned with the reduction of personal life interfering with work for expatriates (e.g., spouse employment, schooling for children), this study suggests that organizations should also concerned with how work is interfering with expatriates personal lives (e.g., reevaluate extensive travel, long hours.) Thus, programs that address both types of conflict are imperative to......

Words: 3091 - Pages: 13

Work Group Conflict

...What are the indications that conflict may be present in a work group? What are two methods for addressing/resolving such conflicts? Justify your rationale. I would like to say that people are able to easily pick up on workplace tension when it is constantly in their mists. Per the ETU website, signs of workplace or workgroup conflict can be: • cliques or factions meeting to discuss issues separately, when they affect the whole organisation • one group being left out of organising an event which should include everybody • groups using threatening slogans or symbols to show that their group is right and the others are wrong • colleagues not speaking to each other or ignoring each other • contradicting and bad-mouthing one another • deliberately undermining or not co-operating with each other, to the downfall of the team The big question though is how to address or resolve these conflicts. Noticing or being on the receiving end of work place conflict is only one side of the situation. Taking action about it can cause further division or at times in extreme cases, causing the group to dissolve. A few suggestions for handling such issues are taken from a blog posted by Pathak. Pathak places emphasis on presenting a “super ordinate goal” to bring pack into perspective the reason the group exists to begin with. “Focusing attention on the higher goals that the groups share or the long-range aims that they have in common tends to make the current......

Words: 404 - Pages: 2

To Manage Group Conflict

...Introduction If a group is going to be productive and successful, the entire group must be able to identify and resolve conflict successfully. Conflict management is a skill that can be learned. The human relationship is a complex and dynamic inter-action. As living creatures, we need and crave the opportunity to interact with other humans by speaking, listening, and spending time with them. Most of this interaction tends to be mutual and cordial. Yet, at times, the interaction can be laced with tension and discord. If left alone, the tension can lead to conflict that may damage the relationship or even become volatile. Conflict between individuals and within groups often occurs because people have differences of opinion, have different values and goals, or receive inaccurate information. Conflict is not always a bad thing. In many cases, conflict can lead to a better understanding of and response to issues. Conflict also can lead to creative problem solving and the initiation of innovative ideas. However, if conflict is sup-pressed and not addressed, it can lead to distrust and greater discord within the group. For a group to be productive and successful, group members and leaders need to be able to identify, address, and resolve conflict successfully. Like any other leadership skill, conflict management can be learned. The overall goal for conflict management is to find common ground (mutual goals and interests that all parties share) within the issue and use that as...

Words: 5768 - Pages: 24

Define Functional Versus Dysfunctional Conflict in a Work Group and Explain How You Can Increase Functional Conflict and Decrease Dysfunctional Conflict.

...Conflict arises when there is some indifference among two parties. In any working group conflict is almost unavoidable. When most people hear the word conflict, they often tend to take the term in negative manner. Almost everyone perceives conflict to be a malefactor and that it often hinders the development process of any group. Although usually people think of it as a bad thing, conflict on the contrary can be a positive occurrence within a group to bring about change. Comprehensively conflict refers to a situation in which there are opposing demands or ideas and a choice has to be made between them. So, it means without conflict there wouldn't be any opposing demands or ideas in which case the choices are obvious and easy. This can often mean there would be no innovation or no opposition to the idea presented hence no alternatives just a straight path ahead. A group must think of all possible ways for an idea to thrive most effectively and efficiently. Hence, conflict not only is salient but also encouraged in a work group. Generally conflict is caused by a number of reasons. For example, conflict can arise because of poor communication among the group members, other reasons can be lack of openness and/or failure to respond to everyone’s need by the head of the group. The belief that all conflict is harmful must be avoided. Conflicts must be believed to be natural and inevitable. It must be dealt accordingly, a conflict can not only be a positive force in a group but it......

Words: 1442 - Pages: 6

Groups, Teams, and Conflict

...Groups, Teams, and Conflict MTG/311 March 4, 2015 Groups, Teams, and Conflict Team Strategy Plan 1. Complete the following table to address the creation of teams at Riordan Manufacturing. Strategy | Strengths | Weaknesses | Forming: Cross-Functional with Common Plan and PurposeIdentify team members, analyze work, develop goals to achieve mission success, and generate strategies to achieve goals (Robbins & Judge, 2013). | High level of communication promotes clearly defined purpose. Proper planning enhances climate of trust and allows common purpose to provide guidance for overcoming barriers (Robbins & Judge, 2013). Enhanced tendency to attain synergy and achieve goals (Wienclaw, 2015). | Personal agendas weaken the common purpose and reduce cohesiveness. Infrequent strategy reviews encourages team confusion (Robbins & Judge, 2013). | Storming: Team Member Commitment | Create structure and processes. Reduced dysfunctional conflict and build trust and cohesiveness (Robbins & Judge, 2013). | Challenges to authority. Some participants may struggle with the limits the team levies on individualism. | Norming: Determine Leadership Hierarchy and Performance Metrics | Clearly defined chain of command promotes normalcy and respect. Clearly communicated performance metrics enhances normalcy (Robbins & Judge, 2013). | New task assignments may cause some members to revert to Storming phase. | Performing: Coach to Goals | Team Manager is able to...

Words: 1238 - Pages: 5

Groups Teams and Conflict

...Groups, Teams, and Conflict MGT/311 January 19, 2015 CardiCare Valves Project Riordan Manufacturing is a Fortune 1000 company specializing in the design and manufacturing of custom plastics. Current customers include companies from the health care and food and beverage industries. The purpose of the following project presentation and plan is to accommodate the production of the newly designed CardiCare Valve heart valves. The company is currently planning to gear up for production under their current model, borrowing resources from varied divisions while expecting to hire an undetermined number of new employees. As one of the newly hired superintendents hired to assemble and lead new teams to begin this new production for Cardicare Valves, the research into the issue has been undertaken and the potential strategies have been identified to implementing a successful ramp-up and shift in production. Strategies The available strategies to build successful teams include the following: clearly defining the goals of the team and the skills required, selection of team members, ensuring valuable communication, promoting a productive workgroup, resolving conflicts, and managing motivation (Robbins & Judge, 2013). There are, of course, several challenges that could be barriers or obstacles to success. For instance, there might be personal or professional differences between team members and/or managers, chosen communicators may fail to properly communicate the goals......

Words: 1073 - Pages: 5

Group Conflict

... What are the indications that conflict may be present in a work group? What are two methods for addressing/resolving such conflicts? Justify your rationale. Read "Challenges Facing PBL Tutors: 12 Tips for Successful Group Facilitation" by Azer from Medical Teacher (2005), located at Anytime a group of people works together, there is going to be conflict. We all come from different cultural and educational backgrounds. We all have different goals, though often toward the same end. Even with the same goal, there are so many “right” ways of accomplishing that goal. Like our Instructor, Anna Auler stated in Lecture 2, “As nurses lead teams of health care providers, they will truly understand that the role of group participants is vital to the group's success.” Everyone on the team needs to feel appreciated and heard. Devaluation, real or imagined, breeds resentment, which can lead to poor job performance and interpersonal conflict. Lack of communication is both a cause and symptom of a conflict. Lack of cohesion, team effort, and exclusion of individuals is also a sign of conflict within a group. The first step in conflict resolution is root cause analysis to determine if the cause is environmental (work load, supplies, atmosphere, etc), or interpersonal issues. If the cause is found to be the latter, ask the individual group members for input into changes that are required to resolve the......

Words: 467 - Pages: 2

Group Work

...Tuckman’s Model of Group Development Forming: in which the group is just coming together. It is often characterized by shyness, uncertainty and diffidence among the members, although extravert members may rapidly assume some kind of leadership. Maintenance concerns predominate Storming: in which, having been established, there is a period of jockeying for position, authority and influence among the members. In classes, this is the period of "testing-out" the teacher. Disagreements appear or are manufactured and roles are eventually allocated. The initial leaders may not survive this period: it is the most uncomfortable phase of the group's life—a sort of group adolescence. Norming: having sorted out its internal structure, there is then the issue of what the group stands for. What kind of behavior and contribution is acceptable and what isn't? Members explore behind the power processes of storming and begin to form some idea of the group's identity: the "group in the mind". This is rarely done explicitly, of course, and it can readily slip back into Storming, Performing: after all that, the group can begin to get some work done, on the basis of a relatively stable structure. Adjourning: This is about completion and disengagement, both from the tasks and the group members. Individuals will be proud of having achieved much and glad to have been part of such an enjoyable group. They need to recognize what they've done, and consciously move on. Some......

Words: 254 - Pages: 2