Earning Quality

In: Business and Management

Submitted By redhairshank
Words 58742
Pages 235
Journal of Accounting and Economics 50 (2010) 344–401

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Journal of Accounting and Economics journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jae

Understanding earnings quality: A review of the proxies, their determinants and their consequences$
Patricia Dechow a, Weili Ge b, Catherine Schrand c,n a b c University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, United States
University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, United States
University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104, United States

a r t i c l e i n f o


Available online 4 November 2010

Researchers have used various measures as indications of ‘‘earnings quality’’ including persistence, accruals, smoothness, timeliness, loss avoidance, investor responsiveness, and external indicators such as restatements and SEC enforcement releases. For each measure, we discuss causes of variation in the measure as well as consequences. We reach no single conclusion on what earnings quality is because ‘‘quality’’ is contingent on the decision context. We also point out that the ‘‘quality’’ of earnings is a function of the firm’s fundamental performance. The contribution of a firm’s fundamental performance to its earnings quality is suggested as one area for future work.
& 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

JEL classification:
Earnings quality
Earnings management

1. Introduction
Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 1 (SFAC No. 1) states that ‘‘Financial reporting should provide information about an enterprise’s financial performance during a period.’’ Borrowing language from SFAC No. 1, we define earnings quality as follows:
Higher quality earnings provide more information about the features of a firm’s financial performance that are relevant to a specific decision made by a specific…...

Similar Documents

Earnings Quality

...Introduction to Earnings: Earnings are the fundamental indicator of a company’s value. Also referred to as ‘the bottom line’ and the ‘net income’, a company’s earnings is seen as the most important figure in a company’s financial statement as it is the summary measure of a company’s performance using the accrual basis of accounting. The theoretical value of a company’s stock is the present value of future earnings, or its ability to generate profit in the future (Lev, B. (1989). Earnings have a corresponding relationship with the projected value of a company with increased earnings representing an increase in company value which is inversely so for companies with lower earnings. Part A: Earnings Quality Although it is very common for investors to look at earnings in terms of quantity, the amount that the company has earned, developing an understanding of the quality of those earnings is vital to forecasting the quantity and credibility of future earnings of the company (smith). As reported earnings are a predominant driver of success, the reporting of earnings is a crucial business area that requires focus and direction. As so much of a businesses future and value is reflected in its earnings, it is very important that investors are provided with information that is free from mistakes and manipulation in order to get a true illustration of that company’s performance. The extent to which the financial performance is free from these errors and manipulations refers to......

Words: 2518 - Pages: 11

Wal-Mart‘S Earnings and Financial Quality and Report How This Process Relates to the Ethics of Professional Accountancy.

...Wal-Mart‘s earnings and financial quality and report how this process relates to the ethics of professional accountancy. Most public companies are required to file its financial documents and annual reports with the SEC. To ensure that they are complying with both the financial and ethical guidelines ethical consistent with professional accountancy practices. Generally, companies like Wal-Mart posts ethical policies and procedures both in their stores and on their website. The SEC regulation remains constant; a company has the option of the process it uses to comply with the regulations. The financial health of a company can be determined by analyzing a company’s financial performance and ratios computed over two to three years. Organizations today are different from those in the past; the days when a person would work at the same company until retirement are long gone. Most people desire to work for a company that is people focused, diverse, successful, and conducts business in an ethical manner. Wal-Mart is one of the companies that offer each of those characteristics in addition to a strong ethics program that it closely follows. In fact, Wal-Mart has a Statement of Ethics, which includes the practice of honesty, integrity, and compliance with the law. Compliance with the Statements of Ethics is mandatory for each employee. The company also maintains a separate Code of Ethics for the senior financial officers. Wal-Mart also has in place a Related-Party Transaction......

Words: 808 - Pages: 4

Earning Management

...Earning management is good or not? Introdcution This essay is to examine whether earning management is it good or bad. Though there is so many debate about whether it should be accepted to be good rather than bad, however, this essay will explain the both side of earnings management. Earnings management reduces the quality of financial reporting, it can interfere with the resource allocation in the economy and can bring adverse consequences to the financial market. This essay analyses both, causes and motives of earnings management as well as possible remedies. Therefore, it is not surprising that market participants, legislators, regulators, and academics are concerned with the need to control financial reporting abuses. The following paper will demonstrate how the effect to the good side and the bad side of it and outline the reason for the impact to appreciate the good and the bad of earnings management. Identify what is key driver of motivation either an earning management is good or bad. This will enable us to analyse the good and bad side nature of the earning management. BODY Good Side of Earning Management There is definitely a good side of earning management if it is properly practice for the benefits of the companies prior to achieving the key performance objective of the companies. Good earnings management means ―reasonable and proper practices. ―Accounting Subjectivity and Earnings Management: A Preparer Perspective‖ referred by Parfet (2000)......

Words: 1173 - Pages: 5

Earning Management

...Earnings management is the choice by a manager of accounting policies, or real actions that affect earnings, so as to achieve some specific reported earnings objective. Earnings management involves the artificial increase (or decrease) of revenues, profits, or earnings per share figures through aggressive accounting tactics on all earnings. Aggressive earnings management is a form of fraud which differs from reporting error. Most of this happens when management of the companies need to present and show the earnings at a certain level or certain loopholes in financial reporting standards. These are fraudulent reporting due to unfulfilling the accounting practice principles with the techniques of revenue recognition, accounting policy change, timing adoption of new standards, write-off, asset sales, provisions, accruals (discretionary) and direct changes to retained earnings. Types of Earnings Management: 1) Unsuitable revenue recognition 2) Inappropriate accruals and estimates of liabilities 3) Excessive provisions and generous reserve accounting 4) Intentional minor breaches of financial reporting requirements that tied to material breach. All of this had been used by some companies to influence the figures by bending the rules rather than breaking them, anticipate or increasing the income reduce or delay the recognition of the expenses and shifting way from debt or losses. Pattern of Earnings Management: 1) Big Bath accounting is the process where publicly traded......

Words: 324 - Pages: 2

Earnings Manipulation

...Introduction Earnings management is an important aspect of a firm financial performance and valuation. In this article, Authors study earnings manipulation among corporate firm. He discusses (I) three income benchmarks managers tend to beat or exceeds at all costs; a) managers avoid negative to zero profit, b) earnings below prior period earnings, c) and earnings that fall below analysts’ forecast. Authors called these earnings benchmarks or earnings shortfalls. The article (II) develops two main tools that managers use (1) discretional income accruals and (2) non-operating income to manipulate their earnings. Authors discuss (III) some reasons that motive managers to engage in such practice and behaviors; for instance managers may inflate the firm’s real income to improve the market value of the firm, the stock price and its expected return. Managers may manipulate earnings to maximize their compensation, bonuses, stock options, or simply to secure their position. Others reasons managers mislead earnings is to maintain a loan or a line of credit from a financial institution and to distract and fool the beliefs of firm’s stakeholders as a whole that lead to deceive public trust. I- Managers Earnings Benchmarks In corporate organization especially, financial Managers’ main goal is to maximize shareholders’ firm value, to achieve their goal, managers make various analysis and financial decisions throughout many aspects of the company. One of the aspects is......

Words: 430 - Pages: 2

Fin Earnings

...1 Why don’t my Abnormal Earnings and Abnormal ROE model answers come out to be the same? It is mechanically not possible to do everything right and still get two different answers because ROE, Net Income and Book value are different ways of looking at the same thing. Here are some common mistakes that causes a difference to creep in.  Take a look at the second formula in Appendix B for Chapter 7.  It is a formula for Market to Book value of equity. That is, in order to get the market value of equity, one needs to multiply the answer from the right-hand side of that formula by the current book value of equity.  The ROE in this model is calculated as: o ROE = this year’s net income/last year’s book value of equity.  This is different from the normal way of using numbers from the same year in the numerator and denominator of the formula.  The growth rate in equity is not the growth from the equity value previous year to this year, it is cumulative growth from year zero to the last year.  For every year t: o GBE at t = Book value of equity at year t-1/ Book value of equity at year zero  You have to add 1 to the present value of all abnormal ROE*GBE terms before multiplying the resulting answer by the current book value. To recap, in order to get the answer from the abnormal ROE model, you do this: Market value of equity = Book value of equity today * [1+ abnormal ROE1*GBE0/(1+r)1 + abnormal ROE2*GBE1/(1+r)2 + abnormal ROE3*GBE2/(1+r)3+…+ abnormal...

Words: 1087 - Pages: 5

Earning Management

...The reason for and benefits of good earnings management Earnings management is a strategy used by the management of company to manipulate the company’s earnings so that the figures match a pre-determined target. This practice is carried out for the purpose of income smoothing. Thus, rather than years of exceptionally good or bad earnings, companies will try to keep the figures relatively stable by adding and removing cash from reserve accounts. One of the good earnings management activities is describe as income smoothing. It is involve that management taking actions to try to create stable financial performance by acceptable, voluntary business decisions in the context of competition and market developments. Income smoothing can be used by management that the entity when making sufficient profit to allow it. And the reason is why the management using income smoothing that the main reason is its remuneration for controlling shareholders. The benefits lie in transferring wealth to the old shareholders from new shareholders The accounting policy choice would be whether from company should be a voluntary early adopter of a new accounting standard or wait two years until adoption of the new accounting standard is required of all companies. An example of a proper management operating decision would be whether or not to implement a special discount or incentive program to increase sales near the end of a quarter when revenue targets are not being......

Words: 470 - Pages: 2

Quality of Earnings

...Cumulative effect of change in accounting for goodwill -15 Net income 688 584 710 830 838 Total assets 11,527 13,392 13,812 15,385 19,134 Common stockholders' investment 4,785 5,900 6,545 7,288 8,036 ROE 11.4% 12.0% 10.9% ROA 5.9% 6.2% 5.4% ROE Comparison ROE can be defined as how effectively a company's management uses investors' money. ROE shows whether management is growing the company's value at an acceptable rate, the percentage given by this ratio tells the profit on every dollar invested by shareholders. In this case we can see that UPS is getting a 24.4% average on the 3 evaluated periods, but FedEx is just getting an average of 11.4%, this means that investors for UPS are getting double the earnings as those from UPS. ROA Comparison ROA can be defined as a value that reveals how much profit a company earns for every dollar of its assets. It tells how much is earned compared to the resources the company owns. In this case we can see that UPS again does a better job with the resources it owns, it is twice as efficient compared to FedEx. So, we can conclude that UPS is doing a better job based on these two indicators. Solvency Ratios UPS Debt/Equity 0.15 0.31 0.45 0.28 0.21 FedEx Debt/Equity 0.37 0.32 0.28 0.23 0.35 Solvency ratios are measures of a company’s ability to meet its long-term obligations and thereby remain solvent and avoid bankruptcy. The debt to equity ratio is a measure of a company’s......

Words: 1056 - Pages: 5

Earnings Forecasts

...Earnings Forecasts: A Primer By Ben McClure AAA | investopedia.com Anyone who reads the financial press or watches CNBC on television will have heard the term "beat the street", which really just means to beat Wall Street earnings forecasts. Wall Street analysts' consensus earnings estimates are used by the market to judge stock performance. Here we offer a brief overview of the consensus earnings and what they mean to investors. What are Consensus Earnings? Consensus earnings estimates are far from perfect, but they are watched by many investors and play an important role in measuring the appropriate valuation for a stock. Investors measure stock performance on the basis of a company's earnings power. To make a proper assessment, investors seek a sound estimate of this year's and next year's earnings per share (EPS), as well as a strong sense of how much the company will earn even farther down the road. (For further reading, see Earnings Guidance: The Good, The Bad And Good Riddance?) That's why, as part of their services to clients, large brokerage firms such as Citigroup and Merrill Lynch (the "sell side" of Wall Street and other investment communities) employ legions of stock analysts to publish forecast reports on companies' earnings over the coming years. A consensus forecast number is normally an average or median of all the forecasts from individual analysts tracking a particular stock. So, when you hear that a company is expected to earn $1.50......

Words: 1132 - Pages: 5

Earnings Mgmt

...Earnings Management The issue of earnings management is one of the most controversial topics in accounting. There isn’t one universal agreed upon definition for earnings management and different views tend to perceive it in different ways. What makes earnings management such a provocative topic is its direct link to earnings quality. Earnings quality is such an important factor to investors when coming to make their investment decisions because it reflects the integrity of the firm. The higher the quality of earnings, the more relevant and accurate the earnings figure become a reflection of the true financial position of the firm. We have seen many corporations manipulating their earnings using various earnings management techniques in order to report consistent and positive yet fictions earnings to their stakeholders, like for instance in the case of Enron. This draws attention and suspicion towards earnings management and that is why the investment community is concerned with detecting earnings management behavior within corporations and seeing how managers can negatively use earnings management to report falsified information in their financial reports. This essay is aimed at showing how corporations intentionally use earnings management to deceive their investing public and what corrective action can be done to resolve this issue. Some people argue that certain accounting behavior done by the firm which is perceived to be manipulative earnings management,......

Words: 675 - Pages: 3

Earnings Management:

...© 2000 American Accounting Association Accounting Horizons Vol. 14 No. 2 June 2000 pp. 235-250 Earnings Management: Reconciling the Views of Accounting Academics, Practitioners, and Regulators Patricia M. Dechow and Douglas J. Skinner Patricia M. Dechow is an Associate Professor and Douglas J. Skinner is a Professor, both at the University of Michigan. SYNOPSIS: We address the fact that accounting academics often have very different perceptions of earnings management than do practitioners and reguiators. Practitioners and reguiators often see earnings management as pervasive and probiematic—and in need of immediate remediai action. Academics are more sanguine, unwiiiing to beiieve that earnings management is activeiy practiced by most firms or that the earnings management that does exist should necessarily concern investors. We explore the reasons for these different perceptions, and argue that each of these groups may benefit from some rethinking of their views about earnings management. INTRODUCTION Despite significant attention on earnings management from regulators' and the financial press,^ academic research has shown limited evidence of earnings management. While practitioners and regulators seem to believe that earnings management is For example, SEC Chairman Levitt delivered a major speech on earnings management in the fall of 1998 in which he advocated a niunber of initiatives to improve the quahty of financial reporting (Levitt 1998). As......

Words: 7836 - Pages: 32

Earning Management

...SUMMARY ON EARNINGS MANAGEMENT Earnings management, is the creative use of different accounting techniques to make financial statements look better. There are two types of earnings management, which may be income increasing (positive EM) and income decreasing (negative management). The modest earnings management has its positive side. View of the role of the signal from the information point of view, earnings management is an internal information management will be communicated to other stakeholders as a tool. A reasonable choice of accounting policies and disclosure of accruals, can be business-related internal information passed on, and thus affect the cost of capital. Earnings management also avoids excessive fluctuations in the profits of enterprises, profit-oriented itself is stable and long-term trends of the future of the enterprise as a good explanation. In addition, the operator can also use the surplus to manage the situation is not expected to make a flexible response, to a certain extent, to avoid breach of contract, thereby reducing the corporate cost of capital. However, there are also drawbacks of earnings management. First, earnings management is a non-effective short-term behavior, it will not increase their profits, they may even aggravate the enterprises operating difficulties, damage to the interests of shareholders. Earnings management deliberately distorts some of the accounting data, thereby reducing the financial statements, information,......

Words: 364 - Pages: 2

Csr and Earnings Quality

...between the Alternative Earnings Quality Measures and their Association with Stock Return: an Empirical Study on Non-financial Firms listed in ASE Introduction: Statement of financial accounting concept No. 1 (SFAC No. 1) state that “Financial reporting should provide information about an enterprise’s financial performance during a period.” Borrowing language from SFAC No. 1, we define earnings quality as follow: Higher quality earnings provide more information about the features of a firm’s financial performance that is relevant to a specific decision made by a specific decision maker. (Dechow&Schrand, 2010) In accounting and finance literature, several proxies for earnings quality have been used in empirical research. This may create problems in comparison the results of these studies, since these studies have used different measures for earnings. It is not clear whether these earnings quality measures are good proxies for each other. The purpose of this is to examine empirically the extent to which the alternative earnings quality measures are correlated, and whether they are good proxies for each other. In addition, the studies will investigate the association between earnings quality measures and firm’s realized stock return individually to find out which earnings quality measure is the most associated with stock return. And which measure explains the largest proportion of the variation in stock returns. The study will examine two set of earnings quality measures......

Words: 254 - Pages: 2

Earning Management

...104 Jurnal Akuntansi & Keuangan Vol. 2, No. 2, Nopember 2000: 104 – 115 EARNINGS MANAGEMENT: SUATU TELAAH PUSTAKA Tatang Ary Gumanti Dosen Fakultas Ekonomi Jurusan Manajemen dan Akuntansi - Universitas Jember ABSTRAK Earnings management atau manajemen laba merupakan suatu fenomena baru yang telah menambah wacana perkembangan teori akuntansi. Istilah manajemen laba muncul sebagai konsekuensi langsung dari upaya-upaya manajer atau pembuat laporan keuangan untuk melakukan manajemen informasi akuntansi, khususnya laba (earnings), demi kepentingan pribadi dan/atau perusahaan. Manajemen laba itu sendiri tidak dapat diartikan sebagai suatu upaya negatif yang merugikan karena tidak selamanya manajemen laba berorientasi pada manipulasi laba. Secara teoritis ada banyak cara atau metode yang dapat ditempuh oleh manajer (pembuat laporan keuangan) untuk mempengaruhi laba yang dilaporkan (reported earnings) yang memang memungkinkan ditinjau dari teori akuntansi positif (positive accounting theory). Teori akuntansi positif menjelaskan bahwa manajer memiliki insentif atau dorongan untuk dapat memaksimalkan kesejahteraannya. Bukti-bukti empiris menunjukkan bahwa praktek manajemen laba ditemui dalam banyak konteks. Hal ini menunjukkan bahwa peristiwa atau variabel-variabel ekonomi tertentu dapat dijadikan sebagai sarana untuk memanaje laba. Kenyataan tersebut memberikan peluang bagi para peneliti akuntansi khususnya, dan peneliti manajemen umumnya, untuk meneliti kemungkinan munculnya......

Words: 5010 - Pages: 21

Online Earning

...Introduction Online earning is a fastest-growing global vartual job marketplace and a series of tools targeted at businesses that intend to earning money by using the Internet technology via information and communications technology. Online earning Online earning is a new concept for earning money by using the Internet technology. Basically it is involves electronic means of earning that deliveries the digital content to earner which is facilitated and supported via information and communications technology. So online earning as a broad set of applications and processes which include web-based earning. Websites for online earning Well there are many ways to earn money by online leaving being in Bangladesh. But be careful in this online world there are many false sites. You only work for them, but those sites never pay you. When you need to cash out your money they will never pay you and show you many reasons like sharing IP, more then one account in same IP, Country problems etc & much more faults. The following websites are top and most reliable websites to make money online.these websites will really give you the opportunity make money online.  Google Adsense : It offers the easiest way to make money online. You need to have a website or a blog, a little programming knowledge for big success. - 4.5 by 410 alexa reviews.  oDesk : The best site for freelancers. If you have skills, you can even earn 300$ per hour. Odesk really does change how the......

Words: 1753 - Pages: 8