Do Professional Traders Exhibit Loss Realization Aversion?

In: Psychology

Submitted By xtrader38
Words 10618
Pages 43
Do Professional Traders Exhibit Loss Realization Aversion?

Peter R. Locke * The George Washington University

Steven C. Mann ** Texas Christian University

November 2000

* Finance Department, School of Business and Public Management, The George Washington University, Washington DC, 20052., (202) 994-3669.

** M.J. Neeley School of Business, Texas Christian University. Fort Worth, Texas 76129 ; (817) 257-7569.
We wish to thank Peter Alonzi, Chris Barry, Rob Battalio, Gerald P. Dwyer, Avner Kalay, Paul Laux, Paula Tkac, Steve Manaster, Arthur Warga, and seminar participants at the 1998 FMA meetings, the 1999 Chicago Board of Trade Spring Research seminar, the 1999 Western Finance meetings, the 1999 Southern Finance meetings, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, TCU, University of Texas at Dallas, and the First Annual Texas Finance Festival for discussions and comments helpful to the evolution of the paper. Pattarake Sarajoti provided valuable assistance. Mann acknowledges the support of the Charles Tandy American Enterprise Center. A good portion of this work was completed while Locke was on the staff of the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission. However, the views expressed are the authors’ only and do not purport to represent the views of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission or its staff.

Do Professional Traders Exhibit Loss Realization Aversion?

Abstract Recent evidence (e.g. Odean, 1998a) describes investor behavior that is at odds with traditional economic theory. These alternative behaviors, such as those consistent with the disposition effect or overconfidence, form the basis for recent "behavioral" explanations for asset returns (e.g. Daniel, Hirshleifer and Subrahmanyam 1998a and 1998b, Odean 1998b, and Shumway, 1998). Notably, the evidence of alternative investor behavior is based largely on…...

Similar Documents

Do Professional Athletes Make Too Much Money?

...Do professional athletes make too much money? Neumann University Daniel Kilpatrick                   Every year player's salaries reach new highs. Athletes are treated as celebrities in American society and idolized by young athletes. The kids who see what their favorite player is doing through the media also are being influenced by them. The example that professional athletes set is very important because they looked up to. The example that many athletes set is unfortunately a negative one. Most people think that athletes make too much money but there are those that believe they are paid fairly. The enormous amount of money that professional athletes receive is having a negative effect on kids today. Athletes should make less money to play a game because the huge contracts that they receive give them power. They are concerned with making money and not the example that they are creating for today’s youth. Professional players feel that they earn every dollar of the millions they make every year to play a game. Those who think that players are paid fairly in professional sports argue that since athletes make so much money for their teams they should compensated accordingly. According to Forbes magazine "The average NFL team is worth $957 million" (Forbes, 2012). Teams generate large profits and as a result can afford to pay athletes large salaries. The past NFL season, players and team owners tried to come to an agreement before the season. According to......

Words: 998 - Pages: 4

Aversion Therapy

...associate the addiction to a negative outcome. Alcohol addiction stems from many factors and cannot, generally, be attributed to one cause.Alcohol dependence often follows a chronic, relapsing course (2) similar to other medical disorders, such as diabetes.Despite its psychological and social antecedents, alcohol dependence, once established, is essentially a brain disorder. Without a pharmacological adjunct to psychosocial therapy, the clinical outcome is poor, with up to 70% of patients resuming drinking within 1 year (3, 4) Whenever the person has a drink, he or she will be reminded of those unpleasant images and sensations. The person develops an aversion to drinking, which means that the taste and even the thought of alcohol become unpleasant. Eventually the person loses the desire for alcohol and drinks less.During aversion Therapy, method, drinking is paired with unpleasant images and experiences.For example, the taste of alcohol may be paired with foul odors or with unpleasant experiences in the person's imagination. When the addictive act is repeated, it creates memories causing the brain to associate the addictive substance with false good memories that can be triggered by stimuli.Addiction is often psychologically based causing the brain to associate the addictive substance to false feelings of wellbeing.Aversion therapy as an alcohol abuse treatment program can be effective because it focuses on stimuli associated with those false positive memories and......

Words: 759 - Pages: 4

Trader Joe's

...Naomi Piché Professor John Burtt BUS 114 Management May 21, 2013 Case Study 1 : Trader Joe’s 1. In what ways does Trader Joe’s demonstrate the importance of each responsibility in the management process-planning, organizing, leading, and controlling? -Trader Joe’s demonstrates planning by intending to carry unique products at a low cost within a fun, relaxing environment. Their organizing skills were apparent due to their approach to find unusual foods from around the world, contract directly with manufacturers, label their products with catchy phrases and by maintaining a small stock of each product. Their leadership was exemplified by hiring employees with job skills such as being “ambitious and adventurous” and providing a laid-back atmosphere both for their workers and customers. Their employees had higher pay rates than those that worked for their competitors and had great benefits. Because managers were hired from within, they had an ultimate knowledge-base of how the system works. Also, the employees were encouraged to taste and learn about the products to be able to share with their customers, creating a more involved employee to customer relationship. Regarding Trader Joe’s control, they were able to control real estate costs by buying smaller stores and staying away from “prime” locations. Their “one in, one out” policy to get rid of poorly selling products or have rising costs replaced by new products helped to control costs and also showed their customers...

Words: 1438 - Pages: 6

Bodies Exhibit

...are showing in Vienna, Madrid, Buenos Aires, Barcelona, Cincinnati, Santiago, Prague, Branson, Pittsburgh, San Diego, Las Vegas, Fort Lauderdale, Hartford, and Washington D.C. The exhibit is unique, consisting of real human bodies in various forms of disembowelment. Each body system was addressed in its own individual exhibit, starting with the skeletal system and progressing through the muscular, nervous, circulatory, digestive, respiratory, urinary, and reproductive systems plus an exhibit on fetal development. Healthy and diseased specimens were showcased in each exhibit. As you walk through the South Street Seaport, arrows with the word “Bodies” lead you to the exhibit itself. The ticket prices were a little steep, but with a coupon the price came to $21.95 for one adult admission. As soon as you walk into the main building, there are posters and pictures of the exhibits everywhere. Also everywhere were helpful and friendly staff, who lead us to wherever we needed to go eagerly and with a smile. After being informed of the general rules, i.e. no food or drink, no photography, etc, we were allowed inside. Once inside the actual exhibits, it takes a moment to really absorb the fact that the display in front of you is actually a real human body. There are special lights throughout the exhibits that protect the bodies from decomposing and damage that may occur. The individual displays had explanations written out beside them so the observers are able to understand what......

Words: 1043 - Pages: 5

Rogue Trader

...Rogue Trader How many times can you go double or nothing before you wind up a billion pounds in debt? In “Rogue Trader”, a film based on the life on Nick Leeson, we get a glimpse into this real world dilemma. The drama begins with Leeson’s promotion to general manager of Barings Futures Singapore. As general manager, he faces a personal quandary and must decide whether to cover for a friend and coworker who made an honest mistake (one that resulted in the loss of a substantial amount of money) or to turn the same person in to face termination. Leeson chooses loyalty to his friend over loyalty to the bank, and covers up the losses by creating an error account. This account served to hide said losses while Leeson tried to make back the money that was lost. After experiencing additional losses, Leeson hit a lucky streak and was able to make up the money due to market growth. However, the profound effects of making so much money in the market quickly got to his head. Riding on the coattails of this success, coupled with other catalytic factors that created another loss, he was once again put in the same position to make up lost dollars in the market. From this point on, we see Leeson gamble on the market, doubling down and hiding his losses from everyone around him until his debt becomes insurmountable. Based on Leeson’s actions, the two COSO components most violated are risk assessment and control activities, of which many examples can be seen throughout the movie. Risk......

Words: 888 - Pages: 4


...Part 1 After watching the “Rogue Trader”, we can say that the main reason for the collapse of Baring Banks is the lack and inadequate internal controls under COSO combine with Nick’s fraudulent activities. The biggest deviation arises from the control activities, particularly the segregation of duties. When Nick Leeson got the job opportunity in Singapore, he was hired as the general manager of the trading floor and also was the person responsible for the settlement which means that he was making the trading transactions and at the same time recording and reporting them into the accounting system. It is a big problem because the positions assumed by Nick are related to generating revenue and doing the record keeping which are 2 areas that can create a conflict of interest, in retrospect those functions should have been held by two different persons and the communications process between them should be monitor to reduce the possibility of collusion or fraud. Another lack in control activities was the total absence of an authorization system. As we saw in the movie, when BeauMarchais asked him to buy 4000 contracts, even though the market average trade was 20000, he did not need any authorization nor anybody review the transaction to be sure that it was in accordance with the company objective. In another instance, he was able to transfer 7.8 billion yen between accounts. To avoid questionable situations and be able to make people accountable for their actions, they could...

Words: 844 - Pages: 4


...FX OPTIONS TRADER HANDBOOK Understanding the relationship between CME FX Options on Futures and OTC Options. As the world’s leading and most diverse derivatives marketplace, CME Group ( is where the world comes to manage risk. CME Group exchanges offer the widest range of global benchmark products across all major asset classes, including futures and options based on interest rates, equity indexes, foreign exchange, energy, agricultural commodities, metals, weather and real estate. CME Group brings buyers and sellers together through its CME Globex® electronic trading platform and its trading facilities in New York and Chicago, and is in the process of launching a London-based derivatives exchange. CME Group also operates CME Clearing, one of the world's leading central counterparty clearing providers, which offers clearing and settlement services across asset classes for exchange-traded contracts and over-the-counter derivatives transactions. These products and services ensure that businesses everywhere can substantially mitigate counterparty credit risk. FX PRODUCTS CME – The Premiere Global Marketplace For FX Averaging $109 billion in daily liquidity and $220 billion in open interest,*CME is not only the world’s largest regulated FX marketplace, we are also the leading FX platform of choice for an increasingly diverse and global customer base. Our high-volume futures and options markets are growing at rates that continue to outperform the......

Words: 4582 - Pages: 19

Trader Joes

...[pic] TRADER JOE’S Description: Trader Joe’s has become a multi-billion dollar national chain partly through its ability to find cheap real estate, skip name brands and smartly manage its supply chain. It’s also due to its workforce management practices. Below, excerpts from a book Trader Joe’s Adventure, review the company’s management compensation, encouragement of multitasking, screening and wages, careful use of money, fun culture, sense that its people are its brand, and communication style. Learning Objective: Our focus with this case is on immersing students in the fundamentals of organizational culture. Organizational culture is defined as a complex set of shared beliefs, guiding values, behavioral norms, and basic assumptions acquired over time that shape our thinking and behavior; they are part of the social fabric of the organization—its genetic code. As such, culture drives the organization and guides the behavior of everyone in that organization—how they think, feel, and act. In other words, the culture forms a behavior template. Davis and Landa succinctly captured the essence of culture when they say, The factors which define culture are in part internal, deriving from the unique character of the organization and, in part external, determined by the background and experiences managers and employees bring to the enterprise. Culture is a major determinant of productivity; it shapes organizational responses to external pressures; and suppresses or......

Words: 5558 - Pages: 23

Trader Joe

...Case Study 1 - Trader Joe’s Patrice Coleman BUS520 – Leadership and Organizational Behavior Instructor: Dr. Anthony Muscia January 11, 2015 1. Examine the approach Trader Joe’s uses to promote a positive work environment for its employees. Trader Joe’s is able to increase job satisfaction and performance in the following ways. I. Compensation Trader Joe’s offers new employees a generous compensation package inclusive of above market wages, retirement contributions, medical benefits, dental vacation, paid vacation time and a 10% discount. The competitive wages offered to part-time and full-time employees alike makes Trader Joe’s one of the highest paying employers in the retail grocery store industry, with part-time employees earning close to 20k annually, full time employees earning between 40k to 60 annually and store managers average compensation over six figures. “According to Glassdoor, the average Trader Joe’s crew member earns $13.20 an hour. Pay starts at around $9, but raise opportunities come often, and employees have the opportunity to earn a $2 per hour raise every year.” (Mazzoni, 2014) II. Collaborative Environment The overall work environment at Trader Joe Markets is very informal with employees donning Hawaiian Shirts as part of their work uniform, and a smile as they greet and engage customers to enhance their overall shopping experience. Daily tasks are routinely shared amongst all staff, and it is not uncommon to see store managers...

Words: 3175 - Pages: 13

My Realization

...REALIZATION Moral Development To my realization about the topic of moral development that was discussed in the class highlighted me as a person. There to know that there are people having the same aspects as what I do. As we grow we develop ourselves a person that which we are responsible to it. From our innocent minds, our parents were the first one in guiding and teaching us the good morals. As we grow we get connections to our surroundings especially to our fellow human. Our surroundings are one of the most influential models in developing ourselves as a person. We can't avoid such moral if we focus ourselves to such things like the ones around us. Avoiding is hard if you find it hard to understand and discipline yourself. In developing ourselves, discipline is the most important for us to learn to have because when we are disciplined we have control of ourselves. There we have already the respect, good morals, decision making, budgeting money, time management and choosing what is right to consider than wrong. We can never be perfect as God, but as a person we have the ability to make ourselves perfect in a reason that we commit mistakes and our responsibility is to try to do it again until we have done such a mistake a wonderful success. IDENTIFYING PERSONALITY This activity made me think again about what makes a person to have a certain attitude, values or all over let's call it a personality that gives them opportunity to hurt others, like to......

Words: 1412 - Pages: 6

Rogue Trader Assignment

...Rogue Trader: postmortem You recently graduated and just started employment at the New York office of one of the Big Four accounting firms. Your first week at the firm included presentations on the organization of the firm, as well as firm policies and procedures. Tomorrow morning, you begin a two-week training program on internal controls and you have a whole binder of information that you must read in preparation for the exercises and role-playing that are included in the training. You recognize most of the materials in the binder because you studied them in your ACC 409/609 class: The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations Report, Internal Control—Integrated Framework. You also notice that there are several cases addressing internal control issues. One case is the Barings Bank collapse and there is a video of this case that you and the other staff auditors will view as part of the training. You want to be prepared for the discussions during the training sessions, so you conduct some research on these topics, especially Barings Bank, because you are not familiar with that case. The COSO Framework You search the COSO website and find the 2013 Internal Control—Integrated Framework that outlines five essential components of any internal control system: (1) control environment, (2) risk assessment, (3) control activities, (4) information and communication, and (5) monitoring. This updated version of the Framework introduces 17 principles associated with the......

Words: 2441 - Pages: 10

7 Habits of Highly Profitable Traders

...7 Habits of Highly Profitable Traders. Habit #1 - The Habit of Trading ONLY with Risk Capital Many people have entered the activity of trading with money they could not afford to lose and as a result they started off trading with "scared" money. They' re fear of loss was bigger than they're desire for gain and they traded with a nervous and anxious state of mind. Scared money never wins. It's wrong to borrow money to trade or take out a second mortgage on your home for trading capital. The way to begin is to determine how much you could afford to lose financially and then from that amount determine how much money you could afford to lose emotionally. Many beginning traders will look to their accountant, financial planner or spouse for advice regarding the amount they could lose financially without considering the emotional side. If your accountant says you could afford to lose Rs. 5, 00, 000 without it severely impacting your financial status, the next thing to do is ask yourself "How would I feel if I lost Rs. 500000 trading in the next 12 months"? As you can see, financially allocating an amount of money for risk capital is very different form emotionally allocating it. Anything can and will happen in the market. Develop the habit of only trading with money you can afford to lose financially and emotionally. Habit #2 - The habit of accepting full responsibility for their own trades. Successful traders always take full responsibility for their own actions in all...

Words: 1318 - Pages: 6

Myopic Loss Aversion, Disappointment Aversion, and the Equity Premium Puzzle

...Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization Vol. 64 (2007) 250–268 Myopic loss aversion, disappointment aversion, and the equity premium puzzleଝ David Fielding a , Livio Stracca b,∗ b a Department of Economics, University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand European Central Bank (ECB), Kaiserstrasse 29, 60311 Frankfurt am Main, Germany Received 7 March 2003; accepted 5 July 2005 Available online 24 May 2006 Abstract This paper takes a close look at the “behavioural finance” explanations of the equity premium puzzle, namely myopic loss aversion [Benartzi, S., Thaler, R.H.,1995. Myopic loss aversion and the equity premium puzzle. Quarterly Journal of Economics 110, 73–92] and disappointment aversion [Ang, A., Bekaert, G., Liu, J., 2005. Why stocks may disappoint. Journal of Financial Economics 76, 471–508]. The paper proposes a simple specification of loss and disappointment aversion and brings these theories to the data. The main conclusion is that a highly short-sighted investment horizon is required for the historical equity premium to be explained by loss aversion, while reasonable values for disappointment aversion are found also for long investment horizons; stocks may not only lose in the short term, but also disappoint in the long term. © 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. JEL classification: G11; G12 Keywords: Myopic loss aversion; Disappointment aversion; Equity premium puzzle; Investment horizon; Reference dependence 1. Introduction The...

Words: 9185 - Pages: 37

Rogue Trader Coco Assignment

...Rogue Trader Name(s) ___________________________ Accounting information systems ____________________________ I understand that this exam is to be completed by myself or in a team of two and that any assistance received from other students or any unauthorized source is cheating and subject to the appropriate disciplinary action as deemed by the Office of the Dean of Albers School of Business and Economics. I (we) am aware of the exam policies / rules provided and agree to abide by them. _____________________________________ Student's Signature – Date _____________________________________ Student's Signature – Date Important: Make sure you read all the way through this assignment. Information regarding grading is included in the assignment instructions. “ROGUE TRADER” You are a new graduate, and you just got the job of a lifetime at the New York office of one of the big accounting firms. Yesterday, the managing partner, Connie Rise, set up an appointment for you to meet with her today. “Good morning,” she says, as you wonder what you have done to be summoned to her office at 8 a.m. You are still reeling from relocating to New York and working in this fast-paced environment. Here you are, plucked from a small city located among wine farms and rolling hills on the central coast of California and plunged right into the thick of things in New York City. But you love your new environment. You earn a great salary, pay exorbitant rent......

Words: 2531 - Pages: 11

Professional Communication - Do You Agree with the View That Such Abusive Happenings on the Telephone Do Not Have Any Impact on Business

...WE PROVIDE CASE STUDY ANSWERS, ASSIGNMENT SOLUTIONS, PROJECT REPORTS AND THESIS ARAVIND - 09901366442 – 09902787224 Professional Communication 1. Comment on the appropriateness of the sender’s tone to a customer. 2. Point out the old – fashioned phrases and expressions. 3. Rewrite the reply according to the principles of effective writing in business. 1. What is non – verbal communication? Why do you suppose that this commercial relies primarily on non-verbal communication between a young man and a gorgeous woman? What types of non – verbal communication are being used in this case? 2. Would any of the non-verbal communications in this spot (ad) not work well in another culture? 3. What role does music play in this spot? Who is the target market? 4. Is the music at all distracting from the message? 5. How else are radio stations advertised on TV? 1. Do you find Mr. Sinha’s responses to various questions effective? Give reasons for your view on each answer given by Mr. Sinha. 2. Rewrite the responses that you consider most effective to the above questions in a job interview. 3. Mr. Sinha has observed the norm of respectful behavior and polite conversation. But, do you think there is something gone wrong in his case? Account for your general impression of Mr. Sinha’s performance at the interview. 1. Assume you are working as an operator at a call centre in India and are receiving irate......

Words: 610 - Pages: 3