Do Judges Make Law?

In: Other Topics

Submitted By rajibubiswas
Words 2051
Pages 9
Do Judges Make Law?
A law is an obligatory rule of conduct imposed and enforced by the sovereign. Therefore the law is the body of principles recognized and enforced by the state in the application of justice. The law is mainly made by a parliament, a legislative body given power by the constitution to draft law. However in the last few decades there has been a notion that judges make law. A judge is a public official appointed or elected to hear and decide legal matters in court, Judges exercise judicial power. This involves making binding decisions affecting the rights and duties of citizens and institutions. In carrying out this task, a judge can use any of the following three sources of Ugandan law, Acts of Parliament or legislation, the common law, or previous decisions by the courts and a constitution

Do judges make law?
To ask the question “do judges make law?” Implies that perhaps to some extent they do make law. A great deal of controversy has centered on this question as to how far judges can legitimately make law although a great number such as lord Bentham have referred to it as a “childish fiction” thus judges cannot make law. Many other scholars more so those that are followers of the realist school of thought have placed absolute emphasis on the discretion of judges and relegated the "rules" to an obscure position. It can however not be denied looking closely at the present legal system that judges have played a dominant role in moulding the doctrines of the present law for example the common law which is also referred to as judge made law.
Nevertheless today no informed observer disputes that judges do especially those of the Supreme Court make law. In the same way the likes of lord Denning molded the doctrines of the law of contract and otherwise. To answer if judge make law lets its crucial to analyse how they do so.
The application of…...

Similar Documents

Do Professional Athletes Make Too Much Money?

...Do professional athletes make too much money? Neumann University Daniel Kilpatrick                   Every year player's salaries reach new highs. Athletes are treated as celebrities in American society and idolized by young athletes. The kids who see what their favorite player is doing through the media also are being influenced by them. The example that professional athletes set is very important because they looked up to. The example that many athletes set is unfortunately a negative one. Most people think that athletes make too much money but there are those that believe they are paid fairly. The enormous amount of money that professional athletes receive is having a negative effect on kids today. Athletes should make less money to play a game because the huge contracts that they receive give them power. They are concerned with making money and not the example that they are creating for today’s youth. Professional players feel that they earn every dollar of the millions they make every year to play a game. Those who think that players are paid fairly in professional sports argue that since athletes make so much money for their teams they should compensated accordingly. According to Forbes magazine "The average NFL team is worth $957 million" (Forbes, 2012). Teams generate large profits and as a result can afford to pay athletes large salaries. The past NFL season, players and team owners tried to come to an agreement before the season. According to......

Words: 998 - Pages: 4

Do Bankruptcy Laws Unjustly Favor Lenders?

...Do Bankruptcy Laws unjustly favor Lenders? Intro Bankruptcy is a legally declared inability or impairment of ability of an individual or organizations to pay their creditors. Bankruptcy law provides for the development of a plan that allows a debtor to resolve his debts through the division of his assets among his creditors. Although the goal of the modern bankruptcy is to allow the debtor to have a “fresh start,” and to be granted relief of some liability, there haven’t been any regulators to protect consumers or debtors since the first Bankruptcy Law that the Congress passed in 1797 which lead to imprisonment of thousands of debtors. And it wasn’t till 1841 that the debtor could voluntarily go into bankruptcy and so avail himself of this privilege of discharge. The Federal Bankruptcy Act of 1898 had 3 principal objects in view: 1. To prevent preferences and ensure equality in payment as between the creditors of insolvent debtors; 2. To punish and discourage commercial fraud; and 3. To discharge honest debtors from their debts when overwhelmed by financial misfortune through no fault of their own. The act gave creditors collectively full power over the administration of insolvent estates and placed upon them the responsibility for enforcement of the act. New Legislation The new Legislation enacted by Congress called the Bankruptcy Abuse and Consumer Protection Act was intended to make it more difficult for debtors to file a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy under which most...

Words: 1064 - Pages: 5

Do Food Labels Make a Difference?. .. Sometimes

...store chain, for instance, is labeled with a “cage free” claim, the grocery store “quality and satisfaction money-back guarantee” logo, the Orthodox Union symbol of kosher certification, and a long list of nutrient claims, including “25% of the daily value of vitamin E; 185 mcg of lutein per egg; and 100 mg of omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids per egg.” A byproduct of the explosion of labeled attributes is that consumers learn to “read between the labels” and make deductions about unlabeled products. For example, confronted with one can of tuna labeled “dolphin friendly” and one with no such claim, consumers would likely assume that the unlabeled tuna was caught with dolphin-endangering practices. In a competitive marketplace, the presence of a label is a signal of quality, and the lack of a label on competing brands implies the absence of the quality attribute. Consumers’ ability to make inferences about quality further spurs the proliferation of labels. Companies in a competitive marketplace are motivated to make explicit claims for all positive “sellable” product attributes since they know that consumers may interpret the lack of labeling as a lack of the attribute. It is almost impossible, for example, to find a can of tuna in the United States without a dolphin-friendly label. Ultimately, the company’s bottom line sets limits on product differentiation and labeling. Not all attributes are worth the cost. “Predator-friendly” labeling, a campaign to promote......

Words: 2711 - Pages: 11

Discuss the Extent to Which Judges Do Create and Develop the Law.

...Discuss the extent to which judges do create and develop the law. Nowadays, law is not strange with all people. Similarly, almost people know the importance of judges. However not at all people can understand clearly how judge impact on creating and develop law. The purpose of this essay is providing some clear information and helping some people recognize the role of judges. To understand the role of judge, people should know who judges are or what they do. Firstly, judges are people who supervise a court of law. Exactly, the role of a judge depends on what country that judge works in, and what kind of court they preside over. Judges must be fair and honest. They must make decisions and give guidance based on the most authentic to the law, even if he or she does not personally agree. Because of this, the job of a judge is very important (Kagan, 2010). Next topic is the role of judges in creating law. With the assumption that the positive law has limits and sometimes the judges are supposed to expand its borders, people must understand what a positive law is, why it has limits and why and how a judge can change the and expand the law when it is necessary. The positive law mean the law that is sanctioned by the Parliament and Legislature, produced by legitimate and democratically elected representatives, systematized and accepted by the society. In democratic societies and countries, this law is a result of the work of elected officials and it reflects the political......

Words: 1110 - Pages: 5

Should Businesses Do Anything They Can to Make a Profit?

...When it comes the issue of the business development strategy, some people suggest that one company should do everything it can to make money, while others maintain the opposite view. As far as I am concerned, business should not be entirely profit oriented. I take this view on account of the following reasons. First of all, totally profit oriented companies may make decisions and develop some industries, which may extremely destroy the environment, and overlook the health problems of human beings. For example, one chemical factory may outlet its high polluted materials directly into a river for the purpose of reducing its cost. With the new law and the development of social awareness, such kind of companies will be swept out sooner or later. Second to take into account is that making money not in proper methods will eventually hinder the development or even destroy the company. To make best profit, companies may be dishonest, cheat their partners, or do something illegally. Probably, they can achieve the temporary prosperity but can never develop constantly by using such tricks. Last but not least, employees are the fundament of the company‘s success. How can expect such dishonest and totally profit oriented companies have outstanding and real honest people. However, just as English proverb goes, ˜ coin has two sides? those who take the opposite view are partly reasonable that making profit really plays a crucial role in the company`s existence and......

Words: 264 - Pages: 2

Do Cfo's Make Better Ceo's?

...Do CFO's make better CEO'S? Introduction The CFO possesses many significant advantages as well as disadvantages if he/she is chosen to become the CEO. Recently an increasing number of company boards have decided that in order to best serve shareholders it is prudent to promote the CFO to CEO. CFOs themselves remain reticent about any personal ambitions beyond the CFO role - at least in public. But given this recent string of high profile promotions there is an increasing recognition that they have what it takes to take over the CEO role. To understand why CFOs are more frequently getting the top job it is important to know what the contemporary holder of the post does with his time. Article entitled “CFO to CEO” explains that the Monty Python image of an accountant sitting in a corner counting beans has disappeared, says Ian Graves, district director of continental Europe, at recruitment agency Robert Half International. Bluntly put, CFOs are now a much more exciting breed. In the 1990s, the CFO role became more dynamic and strategic, moving from being merely a functional head to also being a corporate leader (“CFO to CEO”, 2005). CEOs can benefit greatly from a CFO background. They will have a well grounded idea of how the financial laws affect the company as well as how official documents are created and how they are submitted. In short, the CEO with this background will be another possible safety net and another eye looking for deceit in the lower ranks. There are...

Words: 1257 - Pages: 6

What Can Information Technology Do for Law?

...Harvard Journal of Law & Technology Volume 21, Number 2 Spring 2008 WHAT CAN INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY DO FOR LAW? Johnathan Jenkins∗ TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION ..............................................................................589 II. INCENTIVES FOR BETTER INTEGRATION OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND LAW ............................................................591 III. THE CURRENT STATE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY IN LEGAL PRACTICE .......................................................................594 IV. THE DIRECTION OF LEGAL INFORMATICS: CURRENT RESEARCH .................................................................................597 A. Advances in Argumentation Models and Outcome Prediction ..............................................................................597 B. Machine Learning and Knowledge Discovery from Databases ..............................................................................600 C. Accessible, Structured Knowledge ...........................................602 V. INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY AND THE LEGAL PROFESSION: BARRIERS TO PROGRESS ......................................604 VI. CONCLUSION ..............................................................................607 I. INTRODUCTION MUCH CURRENT LEGAL WORK IS EMBARRASSINGLY, ABSURDLY, WASTEFUL. AI-RELATED TECHNOLOGY OFFERS GREAT PROMISE TO 1 IMPROVE THAT SITUATION. Many professionals now rely on information technology (“IT”) to simplify, automate, or......

Words: 9086 - Pages: 37

How Do Social Media Make Money

...How Do Social Media Companies Like Facebook and Twitter Make Money http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article42647.html Oct 11, 2013 - 12:44 PM GMT By: Money_Morning Tara Clarke writes: Over the last month we've seen Facebook's (Nasdaq: FB) dramatic share price rebound, Twitter's stock IPO announcement, and LinkedIn (NYSE: LNKD) stock on fire, but have you ever wondered... how do social media companies make money? To find out, we turned to Money Morning E-commerce Director Bret Holmes. Part of Holmes' job is to utilize web advertising via social media platforms to best market Money Morning. As a result, he's on top of what's going on inside of today's social media giants. Holmes said the key to unlocking value for social media companies is successful advertising models. "Social media companies are legitimate advertising websites, no different than, say, Google or Yahoo. The same way Google made its money is the same way Twitter and Facebook will make their money," Holmes explained. Web advertising is a growing market. In a 2013 Nielsen report, data showed that 89% of advertisers use free social media advertising, and 75% use paid social media advertising. The report also highlighted that 64% of advertisers expect to increase their paid social media advertising budgets over the course of 2013. That means a lot of opportunity for social media companies to make major money. The trick for social media companies looking to profit as ad platforms is to find the best way......

Words: 2392 - Pages: 10

Do Violent Video Games Make a Person Violent?

...Do Violent Video Games Make A Person Violent? Violent video games have been evolving for years. The first violent video game to ever be released was Death Race made in 1976 (Suddath). This game brought a controversy that would follow all video games for years to come. Although many people say that violent video games cause a person to become violent, many people will argue that violent video games do not cause a person to be violent. Both sides of the “violent-video-game” argument, examples to both points being made, and who should not play violent video games will be analyzed or examined in order to determine the effects of gaming. First, many people believe that violent video games do not cause violence. People believe that violence in video games is the cause of violence, but most video games depict and reflect the real world (Rynne). The world is full of violence, and it was full of violence long before video games started to make their way to popularity. People will counter this point and say that violent video games bring stabbing, shooting, running people over, drugs, alcohol, theft, etc… into people’s lives, but if a person turns the television to a news station, he/she will see all of the same things. War games depict wars in other countries, Grand Theft Auto reflects how people in bad neighborhoods can act, and medieval games give people and understanding about the past. People will say that because of these games mass murders will evolve; for example,......

Words: 2650 - Pages: 11

Free English Do/Make

...Seiss English DO/MAKE compared with German TUN/MACHEN Problems of German Learners of English Sarah Heydeck Alemannenweg 12 79793 Wutöschingen Tel.: 01634253082 Email: sarah.heydeck@uni-konstanz.de Student ID: 01/813879 LA English/History Semester: 8 Wutöschingen, 31st August 2014 Table of Contents 1. Introduction to the Phenomenon under Consideration.. 1 2. Description of the Linguistic Concept Involved .............. 2 3. Description of the Study .................................................... 3 4. Results of the Study - Interpretation and Conclusion .... 4 5. Impacts on Teaching English ............................................ 5 6. List of References ............................................................... 7 7. Appendix…………………………………………………..8             1. Introduction to the Phenomenon under Consideration “Those elements that are similar to his native language will be simple for him, and those elements that are different will be difficult.” (cf. Larsen-Freeman/Long 1991:53) This controversial statement by linguist Dr. Robert Lado in 1957 was already refuted by a number of linguists a long time ago. (cf. Larsen-Freeman/Long 1991) The issue to be examined in this term paper illustrates that Lado’s first half sentence is not adequate to be transferred to real life. The intention of the paper at hand is to investigate the difficulties learners of English face in using and recognizing the high-frequency verbs “to do” and “to make”. The......

Words: 2844 - Pages: 12

Do Fences Make Good Neighbors

...Fences Make Good Neighbors If a fence is between two houses, it is usually there to help keep the peace and to aid in keeping different peoples’ lives separate, usually resulting in two happy, ordinary lives. As Robert Frost says in “Mending Wall”, “Good fences make good neighbors.”(27), which implies exactly what it’s saying, a fence between two people will keep them in good terms. Although it talks about fences between neighbors, it can go into a further context, such as a mental barrier between two friends or a wall between nations. The reason a barrier or wall between two people is good for them is because it helps keep conflicting ideas and beliefs separate and makes lives easier. Fences do make good neighbors because of different outcomes it can help achieve. A mental barrier between two people is healthy in any type of relationship for various reasons. In Robert Frost’s “Mending Wall” he says, “We keep the wall between us as we go / To each the boulders that have fallen to each” (15-16). It may be that the first line gives the thought that wherever two people go, there will always be a wall between them, keeping each other’s ideas separate, but keeping them, as people, together. “Boulders” may symbolize heavy events that have happened to a pair that caused the wall between them to strengthen and help them achieve greater things further in life. The poem also reads, “Before I built a wall I’d ask to know / What I was walling in or walling out,” (33-34). This can......

Words: 728 - Pages: 3

Judges

...not our country can or cannot do a particular thing. This power, however, requires that the judicial branch have effective judges for everything to work properly.   Judges have immense responsibility. In criminal trials, they are responsible for making sure that the lawyers follow all of the rules of evidence, and insuring that defendants get every right afforded to them. They make sure that everything is fair, and that the jury is given adequate information to decide the factual guilt or innocence of a party. In civil trials, judges must decide hard cases. In other words, where the law is not exactly clear on a subject, and a novel case comes up, they have the responsibility of interpreting precedent and deciding, in some cases, what the best policy to adopt is. Judges are "bound" by precedent. In every case, the judge must write down his decision, explaining why he decided the way he did, and that decision is published in what are called reporters. These decisions become law. Then, when a similar case comes up, the judge must know the law that has been decided in previous cases, and must evaluate his or her case in light of those previous decisions. This is what is called "precedent." An effective judge will be guided by precedent. They will interpret those cases decided before the one at hand, and will decide what those precedents dictate. In cases where precedent does not dictate a ruling, an effective judge will look at what will result......

Words: 797 - Pages: 4

You Be the Judge Law/531

...Ebony Law/531 November 2, 2015 Aaron Gershonowitz In the case of “You the Judge” The defendant was under the assumption that he was denied a promotion due to actions of his coworker the plaintiff because of an inappropriate screen saver that was sent to his computer. In the defense of the defendant this screensaver was completely inappropriate and the behavior from his coworker was not professional by any means and due to those actions alone she should have been reprimanded or even fired if it could have been proven that she was the one that sent the screensaver. The defendant also stated in his argument that he often participated with other members in the office when they joked around about things that were not work appropriate. The judge’s decision was made very easily due to evidence and the defendant’s testimony. The evidence showed what the employee’s job description was and what is expected of them as employees along with guidelines for any sexual harassment that may been seen or expected. The defendant basically shoot himself in the foot by not reporting any of the incidents that occurred in the workplace. When the initial incident occurred he should have reported the employees and the appropriate actions would have been handled by management. The plaintiff’s testimony was truthful and she even exploited more of the truth than what the defendant initially stated in his testimony. The sexual harassment was done both ways and he made it seem like......

Words: 852 - Pages: 4

How Do You Make an Essay Argument

...this issue. Your argument should demonstrate effective use of the strategies from Chapter 14 of the textbook, the Classical Argument structure, and accurate citations of summarized, paraphrased, or quoted material from your sources. The basic requirements are: SPECIFIC REQUIREMENTS: Your essay will use the Classical Argument structure in class. Each of the six sections should be clearly identifiable and contribute effectively to the essay. I expect that each section will be at least one paragraph, but you may need more paragraphs to fully develop your ideas. You will also need to effectively incorporate a minimum of four credible sources according to the following outline and cite them properly in MLA style. (You may use more sources, but make sure you cite them!) 1. Exordium: an introduction that emphasizes the importance of your topic and announces your thesis (main point and purpose) that you will develop in the essay. The challenge of this section is framing your argument: is it “judicial,” determining some truth about the past? Is it “epideictic,” evaluating some aspect of a present condition/situation, or is it “deliberative,” asking your readers to consider a plan or policy for the future? 2. Narratio: the “backstory” of the topic, including an overview of the existing viewpoints on it. This section uses the “acknowledging other viewpoints” strategy from Chapter 14 in the textbook. Here you also deploy the skills of summary and paraphrase that we have......

Words: 1143 - Pages: 5

Had to Do This to Make an Account

...Vincent Harding realize his profession of historian and minister and rebel for a cause. He was able to make his own choice and he changed ideas, career ideas, and actual professions, many times. But his community was a steady rock for him to come back to, and to take advice from. They were invested in him, and he gave back to them in whatever profession he had. As individuals we do owe our communities, yet it isn’t in the sense of a debt. It’s more of a sense of human compassion we are expected to give back to our community, but we are also supposed to really feel when we are giving back. It’s the thought that counts. When you do something good for someone else, it’s supposed to make you feel blissful that they are happy and also that you did something good. Journal 4: Bonhoeffer in LLM Bonhoeffer describes the makeup of responsible life with the concepts of displaced representative action, harmony with reality, taking on guilt, and freedom. ‘The structure of responsible life is determined in a dual manner, namely by life’s bond to human beings and to God, and by the freedom of one’s own life it is this bond of life to human beings and to God that constitutes the freedom of our own life.” Responsible action ‘involves both willingness to become guilty and freedom.’ So, for example, there will be unexpected circumstances that dictate that one cannot strictly perceive laws of state.  This is acceptable because Christians have ‘free responsibility’ before God. Journal......

Words: 664 - Pages: 3