Discuss Gregory's Top Down Theory of Perceptual Organisation

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By emmaschofield
Words 889
Pages 4
Discuss Gregory’s Top Down Theory of Perceptual Organisation (8 + 16 marks)
Richard Gregory’s 1974 theory of Top Down Processing suggests that perception is an active, constructive process in which both perceptual/sensory input from the environment and previous knowledge interact to produce our perception. Unlike Gibson, Gregory is not reductionist, and stresses the importance of other factors, such as previous knowledge and expectations in accurate perception, rather than just sensory input and ‘affordances’. Sensory input alone, according to Gregory, is insufficient for accurate perception.
The case study of SB – a man who had been blind for the entire 52 years of his life can support Gregory’s assumption of the importance of previous knowledge in perception. SB could tell the time by using the touch vision he learned in childhood, which supports the role of previous experience and learning in accurate perception. While this can be criticized for being un-generalisable due to being a case study, it had a massive importance on Gregory’s theory, which still is one of the most influential theories explaining perceptual organisation today, and can be supported by experimental studies into previous knowledge.
Gregory’s suggestion that we combine sensory information and previous knowledge to form a hypothesis about what we perceive has been supported by Khorasani et al (2007). In this study, the Muller Lyer illusion (which automatically adjusts the apparent size of a more distant object so the second line looks longer) had less of an impact on participants once they knew it was an illusion. This supports Gregory’s claim that previous knowledge (i.e. being told that what they are experiencing is an illusion) can change the way a person perceives something, suggesting the importance of previous knowledge in hypothesis formation. In addition, the Charlie Chaplin…...

Similar Documents

Top Down Process

...Top-Down Process In unknown situations with unfamiliar objects human beings can use contextual information to assume what things are and what is going on around them. This is a process that we all use on a daily basis; we use it unconsciously but do not understand we are using it. Some researchers in the scientific community believe that this unconscious act is controlled in the area of the brain known as the pre-frontal cortex (PFC). The information that follows is an attempt to explain what top-down process is, explain the pre-frontal cortex and will discuss why researchers believe the two are connected. Top-Down Process In simple terms top-down process could be described as large to small thinking. Alleydog.com defines top-down process as: “large chink” processing and states that we form perceptions (or focus attention) by starting with the larger concept or idea (it can even be the concept or idea of an object) and then working our way down to the finer details or that concept or idea (n.d.). This definition leads to the question of where this processing could be taking place. Reasoning leads us to believe that top-down processing occurs in the prefrontal cortex. Prefrontal Cortex According to Miller and Cohen, the prefrontal cortex, “is a collection of interconnected neocortical areas that sends and receives projections from virtually all the cortical sensory systems, motor systems and many subcortical structures” (p. 168, 2001). The......

Words: 999 - Pages: 4

Organisation Theory

...what truly happens in organisations through the categorisation and scientific measurement of the behaviour of people and system. In this way, modernists can develop general theories explaining many different aspects of one overarching reality and make predictions about the future. Symbolic interpretivism relates to interpretive epistemology which assumes that knowledge can only be created and understood from the point of view of the individuals who live and work in the organisation or culture. Hence, an individual acts in situations which make sense based on one’s experience, memories and expectations. Post modernist sees knowledge as not being accurate because meanings cannot be fixed. There is no independent reality and facts but are only interpretations. Organisations are texts produced by and in language. We are able to rewrite them so as to emancipate ourselves from human folly and degradation. Critical theorist relates to subjectivist where ‘knowing’ the ‘truth’ is ‘tainted’ by dominant ideology and values of those seeking ‘truth’. Nature cannot be seen as it ‘really is’ or ‘really works’ except through a ‘value window’. D. Differentiation The division of labour between different departments is known as horizontal differentiation. The division of authority into different hierarchical levels is known as vertical differentiation. Horizontal differentiation can be measured by counting the number of units or departments within the organisation. Vertical......

Words: 3930 - Pages: 16

Top Down Cisco

... Top-Down Network Design Third Edition Priscilla Oppenheimer Priscilla Oppenheimer Cisco Press 800 East 96th Street Indianapolis, IN 46240 ii Top-Down Network Design Top-Down Network Design, Third Edition Priscilla Oppenheimer Copyright© 2011 Cisco Systems, Inc. Published by: Cisco Press 800 East 96th Street Indianapolis, IN 46240 USA All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the publisher, except for the inclusion of brief quotations in a review. Printed in the United States of America First Printing August 2010 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication data is on file. ISBN-13: 978-1-58720-283-4 ISBN-10: 1-58720-283-2 Warning and Disclaimer This book is designed to provide information about top-down network design. Every effort has been made to make this book as complete and as accurate as possible, but no warranty or fitness is implied. The information is provided on an “as is” basis. The author, Cisco Press, and Cisco Systems, Inc. shall have neither liability nor responsibility to any person or entity with respect to any loss or damages arising from the information contained in this book or from the use of the discs or programs that may accompany it. The opinions expressed in this book belong to the author and are not necessarily those of......

Words: 79785 - Pages: 320

Top- Down Design Scenario

... Top-Down Network Design Third Edition Priscilla Oppenheimer Priscilla Oppenheimer Cisco Press 800 East 96th Street Indianapolis, IN 46240 ii Top-Down Network Design Top-Down Network Design, Third Edition Priscilla Oppenheimer Copyright© 2011 Cisco Systems, Inc. Published by: Cisco Press 800 East 96th Street Indianapolis, IN 46240 USA All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the publisher, except for the inclusion of brief quotations in a review. Printed in the United States of America First Printing August 2010 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication data is on file. ISBN-13: 978-1-58720-283-4 ISBN-10: 1-58720-283-2 Warning and Disclaimer This book is designed to provide information about top-down network design. Every effort has been made to make this book as complete and as accurate as possible, but no warranty or fitness is implied. The information is provided on an “as is” basis. The author, Cisco Press, and Cisco Systems, Inc. shall have neither liability nor responsibility to any person or entity with respect to any loss or damages arising from the information contained in this book or from the use of the discs or programs that may accompany it. The opinions expressed in this book belong to the author and are not necessarily those of......

Words: 79785 - Pages: 320

Describe and Discuss Social Facilitation Theory

...Describe and discuss social facilitation theory. Refer to empirical evidence in your answer Social facilitation is the tendency people have to perform better on tasks when in the presence of others than when alone. Social inhibition, on the other hand, is the tendency people have to perform worse on certain tasks when in the presence of others. When in the presence of other people, we automatically become alert, or aroused. The body’s usual response in such situations is called the dominant response. The dominant response refers to the response that is the most likely response in a given situation. It can be thought of as such: if you’re very good at a task e.g. kicking a ball, then most of the time, when you try to kick the ball, you will kick it well. This might be a result of having practised a lot. In any case, it is the response that you’d most expect the body to give. However, if you were asked to perform a task that you’re very bad at, such as juggling, then the most natural response for the body to give would be to perform badly, because you don’t know how to perform the task very well. In short, for a task that you’re good at, or one that you’ve practised a lot, you will be very good, and so the dominant response will be to perform the task well. For one that you’re not very good at, the dominant response will be to perform badly People are aroused as a result of being watched by others. Arousal brings out the dominant response in a person. Hence, if a person is...

Words: 553 - Pages: 3

Discuss Kohlberg’s Theory of Gender Development.

...Discuss Kohlberg’s theory of gender development. (8 marks + 16 marks) June 2013 Kohlberg’s theory on gender development offers a cognitive approach. He proposes that a child’s understanding of gender comprises of three stages. He believes that it is only when the child has developed a full understanding of gender at about 6-7 years of age that they will begin to display gender appropriate behaviour. The first stage of the Gender Constancy theory is the gender labelling stage (2-3 years of age). At this stage, a child will be able to judge themselves or others based on their appearance only. For instance, they will judge that a man with long hair is a woman. In the later stages of this period, children will not only be able to label others, but also themselves. Evidence for the age of the children in this stage comes from Thompson (1975). He found that 76% of 2 years olds could correctly identify their own sex, and this rose to 90% of 3 year olds. This shows that an increasing number of children can identify their gender at the ages of 2-3, as outlined by Kohlberg’s Gender Constancy Theory. At stage 2 (3-5 years of age) , and around the age of about 4, children realise that gender is also consistent over time, boys become men and girls become women. Therefore, their concept of gender is one of stability but consistency is not yet recognised, hence the reason why this stage is called the gender stability stage. Kohlberg also suggests that children cannot yet......

Words: 823 - Pages: 4

Discuss Theories and Research in Ell Development

...and academic language skills in English and provide support by using comprehensible input and scaffolding. Accommodations should be based on current theories and research in language and literacy development, and they should address the interrelationship between culture and language. For this assignment, you will read the "Classroom Scenario" from Pathways to teaching series: Practical strategies for teaching english language learners. In a five-to eight-page paper, complete the following: Part 1: Analysis Analysis the scenario by addressing the following: Identify the strategies used in the scenario to help ELLs develop social and academic language skills in English. Explain if these strategies are effective. Why or why not? Explain how instructional input and scaffolding are used to support ELLs. Discuss current theories and research in ELL development. Give specific examples of how the teacher used theory and research to support his practice. Provide specific examples to support your points. Make sure to discuss the teacher's or student's actions in the scenario, and align them to specific concepts learned during the course. Whenever appropriate, use course vocabulary to demonstrate your knowledge of how it is applied and activated in the field. Part 2: Action Plan Discuss next steps the teacher should take to best facilitate effective language development for the ELLs in his classroom. Be sure to properly cite......

Words: 325 - Pages: 2

Human Capital Theory Regards People as Assets and Stresses That Investments by Organisations in People Will Generate Worthwhile Returns. Discuss.

...The human capital theory emphasises the need to educate and maintain the workers that an organisation has as they are assets to the company. The human capital is seen as a source of competitive advantage that it is in the theory and proper management of the human capital will lead to greater productivity and efficiency. ‘The educating of the workers is an investment which is equally worthwhile as that of capital.’(Woodhall, 1997) Beeker (1993) asserts that ‘education and healthcare are a key to improving human capital and thence increasing the economic outputs of a nation’. These factors are the ones stressed by the human capital theory and this shows that the human capital theory recognises the need to invest in human capital inorder to generate worthwhile returns. The human capital theory brings out the value that the workers have to an organisation and to increasing shareholder value to the company and thus authorities summaries the human capital theory as ``workers having a set of skills developed by educating and training that generates stock of productive capital``(Armstrong, 2009:238). The human capital theory helps improve and increase skill to the valued workers or human capital that the company has therefore showing the cognisance that the theory takes on investing in human capital as they generate worthwhile returns. The human capital theory encourages the creation of innovative ideas and products to gain advantage over other players in the market by educating......

Words: 1130 - Pages: 5

Discuss Theories on the Maintenance of Romantic Relationships

...Discuss theories on the maintenance of romantic relationships (24 marks) The social exchange theory was developed by Thibaut and Kelly, who suggested that social behaviour is due to the result of an exchange process, where people try to maximise rewards (Such as self-esteem and happiness) from a relationship and minimise costs (such as time, effort and emotional support). The exchange process changes when an individual receives rewards from others; they feel the need to return the favour. If the rewards outstrip the costs, this is seen as a positive sign in the maintenance of a relationship, but if the costs outweigh the rewards, the theory suggests that this could have a damaging effect on maintaining relationships. Thibaut and Kelly claimed that we create a comparison line (a standard against which all our relationships are judged). This referred to whether one person would offer something better or worse in accordance to what we expect from them. So if our current relationships exceed our comparison level, it’s a worthwhile relationship to stay in. However, if our current relationships fail to exceed our comparison level, this means we are dissatisfied with the relationship and may look for an alternative partner. Simpson et al conducted evidence supporting the social exchange theory. They found that participants in existing relationships rated people of the opposite sex as less attractive than participants not in relationships. This suggested that people judge......

Words: 1023 - Pages: 5

Discuss Two Theories of the Breakdown of Relationships

...Discuss two theories of the breakdown of relationships There are some common reasons for the breakdown of a relationship. For example; dissatisfaction or boredom with the relationship, breaking agreed rules and interference from other relationships. In our culture, relationships are considered ‘successful’ if partners stay together, and those relationships that end ‘prematurely’ are considered failures. This is despite the fact that many so-called successful relationships continue even though neither partner is really committed to the relationship. Likewise, ending an unhappy relationship may help each partner to find a new and happy life elsewhere with a new partner. Duck developed a four phase model to describe the termination of close or intimate relationships. Firstly, the intra-psychic phase is where one of the partners or friends becomes more and more dissatisfied with the relationship. They do not tell their partner. If the dissatisfaction is great enough, there is progression to the next phase. The next phase is called the Dyadic phase. Here the other person becomes involved. In this phase the partners discuss their discontent and talk about the different parts in their relationship and seeing if there is a way to get around the problems. If the dissatisfaction is not acceptably resolved, there is progression to the next phase. This phase is known as the Social phase. This is where the break up is ‘aired’ and made public, e.g. to family and friends. It is also......

Words: 1006 - Pages: 5

Discuss Theories of Communication

...The theories of communication are many people’s opinions on how communication works within healthcare settings. Bales’ theory is based on how behaviour is listed and explain under 2 main categories. These are the task based people and the socio-emotional ones. He believes those who are tasked based are the ones who want to get the task completed as soon as possible, without asking other team members how they want things done. Whereas those who focus on the socio- emotional section are those who aren’t too fussed on getting the work complete but are there to motivate the other members into completing the work. An example of this is in a school during group activities. If the pupils have to do a group activity for a project, then certain pupils are more focussed on getting the work done and ensuring they complete it to a good standard, whereas other group members are more focussed on having a good time and motivating them to the work that they can not be bothered to do themselves. This can be seen as useful within health and social care settings because it helps us to understand how people think while working in group tasks and it gives us a reasonable explanation to why certain group members also do more work than others. It would work in most if not all group settings as this tends to always happen. Overall Bales’ theory is useful to some degree in health and social care settings as it gives us an overview to the structure of group tasks and how people work while......

Words: 1746 - Pages: 7

Top Down vs Bottom Up

...Top-Down, Bottom-Up and Metacognition – Discovering the Mind Angelica Lipscomb PHYC102-1402B-10 Robin Redfern June 15, 2014 Abstract In scientific psychology the question of how information is processed is achieved by asking to what amount a psychological procedure is motivated by top-down as opposed to bottom-up information. The difference between top-down and bottom-up processing is commonly used in experimental psychology. Top-down processing proposes that we form our observations starting with a bigger objective, thought, or knowledge before working our way in the direction of more thorough information. Bottom-up processing, also identified as "small chunk" processing, proposes that we attend to or identify essentials by beginning with the slighter, finer specifics of that component and then move upward until we have a firm illustration of it in our minds. Top-down processing is also identified as conceptually-driven processing, because your observations are swayed by anticipations, beliefs, and perceptions. Sometimes people are mindful of these encouragements, but in other cases this procedure happens without mindful cognizance. Top-down processing can be useful when we are searching for similarities in our environment, but it can also obstruct our capability to recognize things in diverse ways. Our prejudice toward observing things in a particular way is recognized as a perceptual set. A good example of top-down processing is the sentence that is traveling......

Words: 1040 - Pages: 5

Discuss Advantages and Disadvantages of Top-Down Processes in Speech Comprehension and Refer to Relevant Cognitive Research in Your Answer.

...Discuss advantages and disadvantages of top-down processes in speech comprehension and refer to relevant cognitive research in your answer. The purpose of this essay is to discuss both the advantages and disadvantages of top-down processes in speech comprehension, with supporting evidence for both arguments being shown through applicable cognitive research. The first section of this essay will briefly look at what is meant by top-down processing and how this is applied to speech comprehension. The second section will cover the advantages of using top-down processes and will present supporting research, on the benefits of employing this approach. Factors such as the listening environment, education and age will be looked at in some detail in relation to speech comprehension and top-down processes. Following on from this, the disadvantages of top-down processes will be presented in the third area of this essay. The concluding section will look at how both top-down and bottom-up processes can work together for optimal speech comprehension and final conclusions will also be presented. Speech comprehension is how we make sense of and interpret the messages that we hear. This can be through dialogue in face to face interactions, but it is very often communicated through mobile telephone conversations, the television, the computer, the radio and through announcement tannoys at the tube station and in other such public places...

Words: 2343 - Pages: 10

Top Down Ecology Worksheet

...EcoBeaker: Top-Down Control Student Name: Please complete all questions on this worksheet, save and upload to Canvas. Please format your answers in bold font or a different color so that your instructor can find them. Exercise 1: Interactions in a Two-Level System [ 3.1 ] Which of the two is the better competitor under most conditions—green algae or 
cyanobacteria?
 [ 3.2 ] Which of the two can grow to the larger size—Daphnia or Bosmina? [ 4.1 ] Examine the graphs of population size and record the number of each species in the DATA TABLE 1 below, in the Trial 1 column. You can click on the bars on the graph to obtain exact values. [ 5.1 ] Record the population sizes for Trial 2 and Trial 3 in the respective columns in DATA TABLE 1. [ 5.2 ] Calculate the average population size for each species from your three trials and record in DATA TABLE 1. DATA TABLE 1. POPULATION SIZES PRESENT IN THE LAKE TRIAL 1 TRIAL 2 TRIAL 3 AVERAGE Green Algae Cyanobacteria Daphnia Bosmina [ 5.3 ] Are your results consistent with what you learned about each species from the library entries? Explain. Exercise 2: Adding Alewife [ 3.1 ] Examine the graphs of population size and record the number of each species in DATA TABLE 2 below. [ 4.1 ] Record your data in the Trial 2 and Trial 3 columns in DATA TABLE 2. [ 4.2 ] Calculate the average population size for each species from your three trials and record in DATA TABLE 2. DATA TABLE 2. POPULATION SIZES......

Words: 671 - Pages: 3

Organisation Theory Case Study

...important to understand how organisations operate and why they are structured in the ways in which they are. Organisations do not evolve by chance, or are they structured in a random manner. They are structured in a way in which organisations can obtain maximum power and control, which ultimately leads to their goals being achieved at a much more efficient rate. The purpose of this essay is to analysis the two theoretical perspectives of Modern and Post-modern which have different ways of understanding power, control and resistance in organisations. This will be achieved by comparing the two different perspectives and of distinctive contributions to the power, conflict and resistance which are key determinants of organisational life. It is stated that “Organizational structure... describes both the prescribed frameworks and realized configurations of interaction, and the degrees to which they are mutually constituted and constituting. (Stephen P. Robbins and Barnwell 2002) Power is an important concept in organisation theory. Organisations are built up of many factors from culture, structure, technology, and power. However power is inter-related to every factor in organisation theory (Daft, R.L. 2007). Two perspectives will be used to present the understanding of power and how power adds to culture and structure. Basic use of the word ‘POWER’ is used as a synonym of influence, strength, authority, and control over others. In organisation theory there are many different......

Words: 2436 - Pages: 10