Company Law Issues

In: Business and Management

Submitted By song0126
Words 1530
Pages 7
Question1

(a)
Facts: Due to the global financial crisis, the business of Bling Bling Pty Ltd has declined and the company is in the process of insolvent and under the care of a liquidator. The liquidator has rejected Sue’s claim to the securities, which includes a substantial block of shares that were fully paid, and debentures for further substantial sum secured by charge over all company’s assets.

Issue: Whether Sue can enforce her charge [security interest] against Bling Bling Pty Ltd ?

Relevant case: 
Under corporate law, there is a rule of separate legal entity explained in the case of Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd. Once a company is incorporated, there will be a distinction between private and company’s debts and assets, a company can contract with its members and a company can be liable in tort to a member. As seen in the final decision in the famous case of Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd, “…once the company is legally incorporated it must be treated like any other independent person with rights and liabilities appropriate to itself…”

Application: In this case, because of there is no fraud so the company is a separate legal entity. The debenture given by the company is valid, thus, Ms. Sue should succeed in her claim against the company in her capacity as a secured creditor with priority payment for company’s debt owed to her.

(b)
Fact: Ms. Sue sold her company and took out an insurance policy in her name to cover the goods against fire and theft. After burglars broke into the premises of ‘Bling Bling Pty Ltd’ and stole stock valued at $500,000, Good Luck Ltd refused Amy’s claims for the stolen stock at ‘Bling Bling Pty Ltd’.

Issue: Whether Sue can enforce the claim against Good Luck Ltd?
Relevant case: In the case of Macaura v Nothern Assurance Co Ltd (1925), Mr. Macaura sold his company and took out an insurance policy in his name to…...

Similar Documents

Company Law

...COMPANY LAW – Part 1 By Carl T. Abruquah Introduction The company is a form of business organization that involves a greater number of owners than a sole proprietorship or a partnership. It is a form that has arisen to meet the exigencies, complexity and rapidly expanding dimensions of business. It is a convenient form of business organizations in the sense that it enables investors to contribute to the capital of the organization without taking active part in its management. The rules governing companies and its management have developed over time as disputes arose and were resolved. Eventually, most countries have tended to codify these rules and practices in companies legislation. In Ghana, the two main legislation governing companies are the Companies Act, 1963 Act 179, and the Bodies Corporate (Official Liquidations) Act, 1963 Act 180. Nature of a Company In Salomon V Salomon and Co 1897, the court held that a company has a separate legal personality from that of its owners. A company can therefore sue other parties and be sued by other parties in its own name. A company is thus said to have a juristic personality, in other words a personality created by law. Section 24 of the Companies Code codifies this concept by providing that a company has the powers of a natural person of full capacity. Another term for this concept is the veil of incorporation. Another case that illustrates this concept is Macaura V Nothern Assurance Co. - 1925 in this case, the...

Words: 6420 - Pages: 26

Company Law

...other perspectives of corporate governance. We also hope to introduce to students some of the more pertinent issues and trends in this field. As part of our ‘E-learning week’, there will be online lectures for students to view. Students will also be expected to do some independent study and research into the topic, which will form the base for the mid-term written assignment. At the end of the e-learning sessions, students should have a working understanding of: • What is meant by ‘corporate governance’; • Key milestones in the development of corporate governance in Singapore; • The regulatory framework for corporate governance in Singapore; • The interaction between Company Law and corporate governance; • Key regulatory mechanisms for Corporate Governance in Singapore; and • The provisions and operation of the Singapore Code of Corporate Governance 2012 Readings Many articles have been posted to help you along with writing the essay but you are required to be discerning and make your own selection of which articles to read. You may also do your own research to supplement the articles. Matters for study and independent research / discussion 1. What do you understand by the term ‘Corporate Governance’ and what are its objectives? 2. What are the current issues and debates facing listed companies, and how these issues are resolved, if any by the recent Code of Corporate Governance, 2012? 3. What are some of the key......

Words: 398 - Pages: 2

Company Law

...decades, the issues of corporate social responsibility have become the focus of society. Especially after many company scandals emerged (such as Enron and Libor scandals), the public are more curious about the CSR and the its legal expectation. Some countries have already set mandatory regulation about the CSR. For example, in Australia the Corporations Act 2001 stated that companies need to disclose environmental performance and another Act[1] requires certain companies to provide the information about greenhouse gas emissions. However, in the UK, the regulations mainly govern financial disclosures[2] and there are few regulations about the CSR of company. In the aspect of law, the Companies Act 2006 s.172[3] set some duties for the directors to promote the success of company which are in relation to legal expectation of the corporate social responsibility. The notion of CSR and the relationship between CSR and its legal expectation is the main of this essay. This essay will critically discuss the notion of corporate social responsibility and giving particular attention to minimum legal expectations. The structure is as follows: in the section 1, we are focus on the discussion in relation to many kinds of the definition of corporate social responsibility. In the section 2, we will discuss the notion of CSR through different theory perspectives and the minimum legal expectation. In the section 3, after obtain some results about the problems of currently CSR issue through......

Words: 3607 - Pages: 15

Law Issues

...was left alone by the gate to the farm. The others including people he did not know who were in the company went to the hide. This was around 23 hours. Some people passing by saw a young man standing by this gate and. Asking him why he was standing outside the yard at such a late hour, Kabwe said he was just having some fresh air. Time passed and it was midnight. He went stealthily to the door and knocked. It had been drizzling so he was wet and cold. The woman who answered the door invited him in and made him something to keep him warm before she could ask for more information. She then decided to just let him sleep and together husband decided that they would take him to social welfare at day break. When they were fast asleep, the group that had gone into hiding came out and knocked lightly on the door instructing Kabwe to wake up and open the door which he did. The owner of the house heard some noises and decided to check what was going on. No sooner had he gone out than he was attacked with a panga; the wife was also axed on the head. The children woke up and started shouting for help. They were scared and their parents were seriously injured. The group went on to steal various items from the house and around the yard. In the mean time, the people who had earlier found a young man outside the yard were very suspicious and had gone straight to the police and reported the issue saying it had become common for children to be involved in robberies and housebreaking.......

Words: 3850 - Pages: 16

Company Law

...The Companies Act 2006 ( CA2006) was implement on 1st of October 2009. The Act contains an extensive code of company for United Kingdom and altered most of the aspect of the law in relation to companies. Furthermore, plenty of provisions for public and private had been introduced. Moreover the long term of investment and shareholder engagement has been enhanced. Sole Trader is owned or run a private corporation by one person who can control over decision making. Moreover the owner entitled to receive an all the profits. The drawbacks are unlimited risk for example the owner is entitled to pay off the debenture and damage of his business. It also has finance limited to resources of an individual. Partnership is consists of two or more individual and equally liable for the debts incurred by the business. It can share expensive resources and risks together. Moreover, undertake heavy workload. There would be a problem if the partnership changes. Limited Liability Partnership is a general partner which was introduced by The Limited Libility Partnership Act 2000. It is a separate legal personality and hybrid. Do not need to apply Partnership law. Partners are not directly responsible for debts. Limited Liability Company is a separate legal entity personality with limited liability. Has potential to acess winder range of funding. The disadvantages are accounting arrangement made public. It may be an illusion for small company. Company limited by Shares have ability to increase...

Words: 312 - Pages: 2

Company Law

...MEANING, CHARACTERISTICS AND TYPES OF A COMPANY STRUCTURE 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 1.0 Objective Introduction Meaning of Company Characteristics of a Company Distinction between Company and Partnership Types of Company Summary Keywords Self Assessment Questions Suggested Readings OBJECTIVE After reading this lesson, you should be able to: (a) (b) (c) 1.1 Define a company and explain its features. Make a distribution between company and partnership firm. Explain the various types of companies. INTRODUCTION Industrial has revolution led to the emergence of large scale business organizations. These organization require big investments and the risk involved is very high. Limited resources and unlimited liability of partners are two important limitations of partnerships of partnerships in undertaking big business. Joint Stock Company form of business organization has become extremely popular as it provides a solution to (1) overcome the limitations of partnership business. The Multinational companies like Coca-Cola and, General Motors have their investors and customers spread throughout the world. The giant Indian Companies may include the names like Reliance, Talco Bajaj Auto, Infosys Technologies, Hindustan Lever Ltd., Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd., and Larsen and Tubro etc. 1.2 MEANING OF COMPANY Section 3 (1) (i) of the Companies Act, 1956 defines a company as “a company formed and registered under this Act or an existing company”. Section 3(1) (ii) Of the......

Words: 114302 - Pages: 458

Company Law

... This paper was presented at the International Conference on Emerging Issues in Public Law: Challenges and Perspectives, Faculty of Law, Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM), 13th to 14 December 2011, Shah Alam, Malaysia. ABSTRACT In Newton v Birmingham Small Arms Co (1906), the English court made it clear that the rights of auditors cannot be abridged nor restricted by any regulations of the company. This is to ensure that the auditors’ rights are secured. The rights are unqualified and this will enable auditors to discharge their role and duties effectively. Additionally, the Companies Act 1965 (CA) gives substantive powers to enable auditors to carry out their duties effectively. This is because if their hands are tied, they will not be able to uncover any wrongdoings by the company’s management. In fact, any one who obstructs their duties, is in breach of the CA. Auditors have a right of access at all reasonable times to the accounting records and other records, including registers of the company. Moreover, the CA provides that auditors enjoy qualified privilege in certain circumstances. Thus, this study investigates imperative issues on the office of auditors concerning rights, powers and privilege. This is to strengthen the role and duties of auditors to bring about a more meaningful existence of auditors. In doing so, this study will explore the necessary reforms that should be made on the issues concerning the office of auditors. Auditors’ office and powers should......

Words: 5159 - Pages: 21

Company Law

...1. Easy Groceries Pty Ltd: the Company Issue The issue here is Easy Groceries Pty Ltd is liable for the debts incurred as a separate legal entity to its directors and shareholders? Or will its directors be personally liable for its debts? Law Upon incorporation, a company becomes a separate legal entity from its directors and members (s119). It can sue and be sued, acquire assets and debts, and enter into contracts in its own name. Its existence can lasts a lifetime as well. The Doctrine of Separate Legal Entity also known as “corporate veil” entails that the Directors of a Company have no personal liability while its Shareholders are only liable up to the amount they paid for their shares. In Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd Case, Mr. Salomon was the majority shareholder and a secured creditor of the company. Upon winding up, the liquidators argued that Mr. Salomon must not be considered as a secured creditor since he was in control of the company itself. But the Court’s decision recognized Mr. Salomon as a secured creditor since the company has a separate legal personality from the directors and shareholder upon its registration and it has nothing to do with Mr. Salomon being a secured creditor. Application Applying s119 corporations act, Easy Groceries Pty Ltd is a separate legal entity from its directors and shareholders, meaning that Easy Groceries Pty Ltd as a company itself is liable for the debts that occurred. Conclusion As an own legal......

Words: 2658 - Pages: 11

Company Law

...Charles Prospect to |give the required presentation to the client | | |deliver his presentation to Bean & Co. |It should clearly describe the personality of a company | | |The report will be assessed for the |separate from its owners and board | | |demonstrated knowledge of the legal |It should also describe the process by which a company | | |formation of a company, forms of |can be formed and registered | | |corporate body and procedures for company|The different forms of corporate body that can be formed| | |formation. Case Study 1 provides |should be clearly described | | |background information for this. | | | | | | | | | | | |Candidates should give written answers to|Answers should provide clear understanding of how a | | |the three questions on company finance. |company’s financial arrangements can be understood | |2. | |Shares ......

Words: 3692 - Pages: 15

Company Law

...Contents Task 1: Understanding the nature of a Company 3 1.1. Concept of corporate Personality 3 1.2. Lifting the veil 3 1.3. Advantages and disadvantages of incorporation 3 1.4. Promoters 4 1.5. Pre-incorporation contract 5 1.6. Requirements of registration of an incorporated business entity 5 1.7. Requirements for trading commencements 5 Task 2 Memorandum, Articles of Association, ultra Vires and their Effects and contents of Prospectus 6 2.1 Requirements for memorandum of association 6 2.2 Articles of Association 6 2.3 Evaluation of doctrine of ultra vires and its effects 6 2.4 Contents of a prospectus and listing particulars 7 Task 3 types of capital, laws relating to issue of shares and dividends, capital maintenance and insider dealings 8 3.1 Types of Share Capital 8 3.2 Law regarding Issue of shares, class rights and dividends 8 3.3. Capital maintenance 9 3.4. Insider dealings 10 Task 4: Understanding about shareholders, directors, charges and insolvency 10 4.1-The Role and powers of the directors: 10 4.2-Different Types of Meetings: 11 4.3-Law on Minority Protection: 11 4.4-Rights of Stakeholders and Debenture Holders: 12 4.5-Liquidation: 12 Bibliography 13 Task 1: Understanding the nature of a Company 1.1. Concept of corporate Personality Corporate personality means that “the company’s liabilities are the legal responsibility of the company and the members will not be liable for the company’s debts” (Talbot,......

Words: 4463 - Pages: 18

Company Law

...if in fact the shares had not been paid for, and if the company later became insolvent the creditor could claim that he had been misled and could compel shareholders who had not paid in the par value of their shares to do so...” (Hanks and Manning, p.50, 1990). This representation makes a clear message that unless the company become insolvent there is no action against the shareholder by the creditor since there is no damages taken by the creditors. While the trust fund theory states that the shareholder’s equity which the capital stock is in the nature of a ‘trust fund’ for the creditors hence the shareholders are not allowed to withdraw their asset from the company in order to remain the company to be insolvent as per the landmark opinion of Justice Story in Wood v. Dummer (Hanks and Manning, p.50, 1990). In the event if the shares get transferred the creditor’s remedy should be against the initial share purchaser who has underpaid if at all the creditor could find him (Hanks and Manning, p.49, 1990). Under the contract theory, shareholders must be held to the terms upon which they have acquired the shares and the creditor of the insolvent company must be permitted to enforce obligations of the shareholders (Mwenda, 1999). However this justification doesn’t applies for a no liability companies where the principal activity of the company is that of mining or oil exploration. The difference is that ordinarily a company can sue shareholders for the balance when they are......

Words: 1088 - Pages: 5

Company Law

...INTRODUCTION Company law has now put on a broad scope as a result of global economic and technological advancement in this era thus touching on a number of disciplines. Issues pertaining to the company and its administration has been clearly spelled out in the Companies Act 1963 (Act 179) of Ghana. Company law (or the law of business associations) is the field of law concerning companies and other business organizations. This includes corporations, partnerships and other associations which usually carry on some form of economic or charitable activity. The most prominent kind of company, usually referred to as a "corporation", is a "juristic person", i.e. it has separate legal personality, and those who invest money into the business have limited liability for any losses the company makes, governed by corporate law. The largest companies are usually publicly listed on stock exchanges around the world. Even single individuals, also known as sole traders may incorporate themselves and limit their liability in order to carry on a business. All different forms of companies depend on the particular law of the particular country in which they reside. MEMBERS MEETINGS AND RESOLUTIONS Members of a company are, according to section 30 of the Companies Act are; (1) The subscribers to the Regulations shall be deemed to be members of the company and on its registration shall be entered as members in the register of members referred to in section 32 of this Code (Section 30 (1)). ...

Words: 1080 - Pages: 5

Company Law

... Unit 18: Advertising and Promotion in Business 83 Unit 19: Marketing Planning 89 Unit 20: Sales Planning and Operations 95 Unit 21: Human Resource Management 101 Unit 22: Managing Human Resources 107 Unit 23: Human Resources Development 113 Unit 24: Employee Relations 117 Unit 25: English Legal System 121 Unit 26: Business Law 125 Unit 27: Further Aspects of Contract and Tort 131 Unit 28: European Law 135 Unit 29: The Internet and E-Business 139 Unit 30: Internet Marketing 145 Unit 31: E-Business Operations 151 Unit 32: Quality Management in Business 157 Unit 33: Small Business Enterprise 163 Unit 34: Operations Management in Business 169 Unit 35: European Business 173 Unit 36: Employment Law 177 Unit 37: Company Law 181 Unit 38: Business Events Management 185 Unit 39: Financial Investment Opportunites 191 Unit 40: Business Work Experience 195 Unit 41: Contemporary Issues in Marketing Management 199 Unit 42: Project Management for Business 205 Unit 43: Administrative Services 211 Unit 44: Business Psychology 217 Unit 45: Business Ethics 221 Unit 46: Corporate Environmental and Social Management 225 Unit 47: Employability Skills 231 Unit 48: Project Design Implementation and Evaluation 237 Unit......

Words: 55219 - Pages: 221

Company Law

...Company Law Assignment Tak Wing Ho Alvin Part A 1.The concept of corporate personality Corporate Personality refers to a legally established company, which itself is authorized by law "person", in addition to the company itself, it does not belong to any individual, group. In other word, the company is a legal entity separate from its members. The company was established by law, will be awarded on a legal independent personality, the company became an independent entity and its members are independent of personality, which is the basic content of corporate personality. Accordingly, an independent company with its own name, in recognition of its independent existence Subsidiary refers to a company certain amount of shares of another company controlled by or pursuant to the agreement is actually controlled by another company, dominated. A subsidiary of an independent legal entity, with all his property, his own company name, articles of association and the board of directors, in their own name to carry out business activities, are engaged in various civil activities, independent bear all the consequences and responsibilities arising from corporate actions, but major decisions involving the interests of the company or major personnel arrangements, still determined by the parent company. Although the subsidiaries controlled by the Evergreen Co. Ltd. , but legally independent subsidiary companies still have legal status. It has its own name...

Words: 1697 - Pages: 7

Company Law

...Given name Surname Student number Email Unit name Unit code Assignment title Date submitted Student’s comment to tutor Shin Huey Tan 7E1A8643/ 15582218 7e1a8643@student.curtin.edu.my Company Law 266 10841 Seminar Essay 23 March 2012 Marker’s comments Recorded mark Marker Comments Step 1: Identify the Areas of Law The areas of law applicable to this problem are relationship between partners which particularly based on partner expulsion and liability to third parties or outsiders. Step 2: Discuss the Principles of Law Under Section 7(1) of Partnership Act 1895 WA, partnership refers to a structure where two or more persons in a business are acting in common with a view of profit. Partnerships can be formed formally by written agreement which contains the rights and obligations of the partners and facilitates the resolution of disputes within a partnership. However, if the agreement is deficient, Partnership Act will be referred for resolutions. Partnership can also be formed by oral agreement or implied by the conduct of the parties (Harris, Hargovan and Adams, 101-103). Partners in a partnership are in a fiduciary relationship which partners have the duty to act in good faith, including avoid conflicts of interests, not make private profits, not compete with the firm and not disclose confidential information. The rules related to interests, rights and duties of partners will be provided in the written or oral agreement. (Harris, Hargovan and Adams, 131).......

Words: 1919 - Pages: 8