Free Essay

Bosse V. Brinker

In: Business and Management

Submitted By sydd012
Words 382
Pages 2
a meal at the Chili's restaurant in Dedham, Massachusetts. The tab for the meal came to $56, but the group fled from the restaurant without paying and drove off. A regular patron of the restaurant saw them leave without paying and followed them in his own car. The teenagers saw the patron following them, so they stopped their car and confronted him in a parking lot at a nearby retail center. The pursuing patron yelled that he had seen them skip out on their bill at Chili's and that they would not get away with it. The patron's car was unmarked; it bore no Chili's insignia. He wore civilian clothing and no uniform or other insignia of employment at Chili's.
The teenagers then fled the lot, and a high-speed chase ensued through residential side streets. During the chase, the patron used his cell phone to call a Chili's employee and provided him with a description of the teenagers' car and the path of the chase. The Chili's employee then related this information to a 911 dispatcher. In the course of the high-speed chase, the teenagers collided with a cement wall and were injured. The pursuing patron left the crash scene area and was never identified.

Bosse sued the restaurant owner, Brinker Restaurant Corp. doing business as Chili's Grill and Bar, for damages related to the crash. Bosse argued that the actions of the parties resulted in the Chili's patron being converted to an agent of Chili's, that he conducted his chase as an agent of the restaurant, and that the restaurant should be liable for the consequences of his negligent or reckless pursuit. Brinker filed a motion for summary judgment on the grounds that no genuine issue of fact existed regarding the lack of an agency relationship through express acts or implication.

Page 309
SYNOPSIS OF DECISION AND OPINION The Massachusetts Superior Court granted Brinker's motion for a summary judgment. The court held that an agency relationship requires three elements: (1) consent, (2) right of control, and (3) agent's conduct that benefits the principal in some way. In this case, the court ruled that the evidence was insufficient to create a genuine issue whether Chili's authorized the patron to act as a posse to conduct a chase. No information indi…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay


...Good and bad bosses pose many differences and similarities in how they conduct themselves in work environment, but other factors such as, an employee’s ethics or educational background can determine on how they perceive a good or bad boss. I. Introduction- Everyone has a boss; however, not every boss is qualified to be a boss. II. First main point - How a good boss conducts themselves in a work environment. a. Supporting details - A good boss is one that mentors their employees’ and empowers them. i. Subdetails – Good bosses want to help you learn and grow so you can be the best that you can be. ii. Subdetails – Good bosses listen and assess their employees needs and tries to meet them b. Supporting details – A good boss is a person with good communication skills, morale, and provides resources for their employees and co-workers.. i. Subdetails- A good employer has excellent communication skill and is someone who keeps in touch with their employees, while demonstrating good morale. ii. Subdetails - A good boss is going to want to provide you with the resources you need to get your job done, even if that means thinking outside the box. III. Second main point- How a bad boss conducts themselves in a work environment. a. Supporting details- A bad boss is one that is self serving or belittles you, causing a tense work environment. i. Subdetails – An employer that has an...

Words: 297 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Bad Bosses

...Video Case: Bad Bosses If you saw the movie Office Space, character Bill Lumberg may have reminded you of someone. While many of us have encountered an unreasonable boss like Lumberg, bad bosses are no laughing matter. Having a bad relationship with a boss is one of the major reasons people seek other jobs. Half of all workers say they can do their bosses job better. Unfortunately, says Brent Rasmussen of, leaving is usually the only way to get rid of a bad boss. Just what makes a boss bad? Generally speaking, they lack the people skills necessary to be effective leaders. Bad bosses have been characterized as greedy, condescending, even thieving, stealing good ideas and taking credit for them. Through finger pointing and yelling, bad bosses also create a stressful environment. In fact, studies have shown that stress levels and days lost to illness are lower in work places that are managed fairly. Justin Racz, in his book, 50 Bosses Worse than Yours, provides a profile of bad bosses, some based on his personal experience. The chair thrower, as the name implies, likes to through things. Racz’s advice: duck. The micromanager doesn’t give workers much breathing room, while the back stabber takes credit or places blame. The screamer is pretty much self-explanatory. Then there’s the boss who wants to be your buddy. A recent survey conducted by found that most workers (49%) have buddy bosses; 23% reported having bosses that are never......

Words: 445 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The Cure for Horrible Bosses

...In the recent film comedy Horrible Bosses, three truly dreadful managers make their employees’ lives miserable. The fi rst is a cruel executive who dangles a promotion in front of a subordinate as bait, only to snatch it away once his stupid demands have been met. The second is a mean cokehead who inherits the family business from his kindly deceased father. The third is an orthodontist who sexually harasses her assistant, threatening to tell his fi ancée that it’s his fault. The victims in the movie can’t quit. They need the jobs. Instead, they compose elaborate, farcical plots to eliminate the bosses. In real life, horrible bosses are the stuff of tragedy, not comedy. Workplace discontent is no joke. Some surveys show that as many as half of American workers feel low levels of work engagement, stemming in part from poor management. It’s not insults that cause the greatest harm, but rather callousness about people’s time. Horrible bosses want control. They expect subordinates to be on call 24/7 and to hit unrealistic deadlines with limited resources. When the work product is delivered, horrible bosses may ignore it for long intervals, making it clear that the deadline was artifi cial and the stress unnecessary. To minimize the impact of horrible bosses, companies can ensure that performance reviews are based on objective measures, not subjective ones. They can examine tasks and workloads for relevance and fairness. They can off......

Words: 609 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Bad Bosses

...Unit 1 Assignment: Bad Bosses Kristie Olney Post University Unit 1 Assignment: Bad Bosses 1. Think back on all the jobs you were employed at. Most may seem like a blur unless there was something significant that stuck out, enjoying your boss is a large factor. About “60% of the workers in the survey rated their boss as good, while only 16% rated their boss terrible to poor” (Abbasi, Hollman, & Hayes, 2008). The majority of the working class enjoy their bosses; so what qualifies a boss to be a good one? Being a good boss means going the extra mile for your employees. Keep an open line of communication, lead your team, trust your employees, be understanding, encourage teamwork, be interested in your employees, and have a clear plan of success (RISMedia, 201). The management process, is a four step tool to help bosses implement a plan to get things done. The steps include planning, organizing, leading, and controlling (Kinicki & Williams, 2003). If bosses stick to these functions, they will have the knowledge necessary to please their employees and have a more enjoyable working environment. 2. Henry Mintzberg was curious to know what managers of all levels did throughout their days at work; so he laid his curiosity to rest and followed them around and reported his findings (Kinicki & Williams, 2003). Mintzberg noticed three key elements that overlapped with each manager. “A manager relies more on verbal than written communication; works......

Words: 619 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Describe Good Bosses

...vitally important to open the channels of communication in an organization to allow employees to be informed, ask questions, and share information and to inspire them to share the vision of the company. Demonstrate to employees that the company cares about them, wants them to advance in their careers and will help them satisfy their need for personal growth. "Walk the talk" by not only communicating the corporate strategy but by also ensuring that it is applied consistently throughout the organization, including making the rewards system consistent with strategic goals. Visit the Capella University Library. Use the Summon search box in the middle of the screen and type "good bosses." Read some of the articles available about good supervision. Use the Summon search box again and type "bad bosses." Read some of the articles available about poor supervision. Then complete the following: 1. Summarize an example of a good boss. How do supervisors contribute to employee satisfaction? Do you think this behavior benefits the organization or just one or a few employees personally? 2. Summarize an example of a bad boss. How did this supervisor undermine employee satisfaction? Did this behavior harm the organization or just one or a few employees personally? 3. In the case of the positive behavior you described in Question 1, should the organization promote this kind of behavior among its......

Words: 425 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Bad Bosses

... the quickest to be viewed as bad bosses. This barrier can cause employees to minimize contact, avoid their superiors altogether, fail to share information and withhold their opinions about what really is going on in the operation. Possessing an elevated sense of oneself quickly damages working relationships and ensures less than optimal performance. Nobody is perfect, but leaders who consistently fail are not leaders, no matter how much you wish they were. While past performance is not always a certain indicator of future events, a long-term track record of success should not be taken lightly. Someone who has consistently experienced success in leadership roles has a much better chance of success than someone who has not. It’s important to remember unproven leaders come with a high risk premium.  It is somewhat obvious that bad bosses frequently lack the requisite skill set to be effective as leaders. But when managers do not have the skills or talents necessary to perform their job effectively, their employees lose on several fronts. First, their performance suffers as their boss has not set the stage for success. Second, they frequently are frustrated by the fact that they are being asked to follow a leader who does not have the talent necessary to lead. Third, employees have to deal with the problems created by their bad boss’ incompetence. When taken together, bad bosses lack the technical, managerial and......

Words: 2098 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

V Chip

...The V-Chip Nicholas Vess XCOM/225 8 November 2013 Charles Webster The V-Chip Most television programs are now assigned a rating according to the system established by the television industry and, based on these ratings, the V-Chip can block content deemed not suitable by the owner. This is very effective when trying to block unsuitable programing from children. Since the device blocks anything rated inappropriate, children will not see the offensive material. Parents can now be certain that even when their children are watching television in another room, the content will still be suitable. Live shows may be a little more difficult to censor in this manner, however most live show get coded with a rating as well, based on the nature of the event. Video games, music and movies are harder to censor. As with anything else, the discretion of the parents has to come first. The parents are the ones who have to educate their children on what is and is not suitable to watch, play or listen to. I believe that the V-Chip has become a scapegoat for some parents, making them think it is no longer their responsibility to shield their kids for offensive programming. People are still going to complain, but television stations have done what they have needed to. I feel that any concerns about programming should be cordially denied. If you are not a fan of the program being shown, there are literally hundreds of other television stations......

Words: 278 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Bad Bosses

...Why Do People Hate Work? “Bad Bosses” Conduct your own research and use your textbook to respond to the following. Some movie ideas are listed on Canvas; however, there are many others. 1. List and describe 3 traits/characteristics/styles of a bad boss. 6 pts. A dictator one who intimidates others to get their way, ‘my way or the highway’ A criticizer one who is looking for things to criticize about to their peers and/or any other person. Abrasive communicator one who belittles and humiliates their peers and/or any other person. 2. What are at least 3 reasons why the boss in your movie is a “bad boss”? (Consider what you listed in question #1). 6 pts. My boss was a bad boss because he had used abrasive communication, from the beginning to end of the clip. His accountant came to work arriving three hours late he had used profanity asking him why he was late. The accountant came into his office his boss had treated him like a dog using commands such as sit, good boy. My boss had criticized what the funds were being spent on, medical bills and environmental waste; it’s costing them too much. Another trait that was displayed was a dictator; he didn’t care if the waste management was being done the right way. He looked at it as it was costing the company too much money. He decided he was going with another company not caring of the disadvantages. It cost him less and it was giving him more money in his pocket. Another use of being a dictator was towards the end...

Words: 1230 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Women Are Better Bosses

...Are Women Better Bosses? In "Are Women Better Bosses," Mary Schnack writes, that “Survey shows that two thirds of all Americans would not mind working for a woman.” at the end of the day, she says that the vast majority of the Americans these days can continue with the thought that they are continuously bossed by a lady. Some way or another “Natasha Josefowitz, a professor of business administration at University of California,” was not dumbfounded by such phenomena. She was really expecting that, as her scientists demonstrated that “women are better managers than men”. My response to what I simply read is that, both journalists Mary Schnack and Natasha Josefowitz have mulls over that support their purpose of perspectives about ladies surpassing higher powers at our present time. Notwithstanding that, Josefowitz expresses a few qualities, looking at between the aptitudes that men and ladies adjust in their prior lives. Case in point, men gain the “teamwork skills”, while ladies advance “social and technical skills”. I see that, Josefowitz is right about ordering the distinctive abilities in the middle of men and ladies. As it is exceptionally clear that ladies are more prone to talk more, while men are more prone to lead more. Different specialists offered credit to ladies in light of the fact that; they are agreeable at the work environment than men do. For example, Josefowitz review demonstrated that “women were more likely than their male counterparts to encourage......

Words: 377 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Good Bosses

...Good Bosses Versus Bad Bosses Paula Chipman COM/170 July 21, 2014 Dr. Adams Good Bosses Versus Bad Bosses The management style of a boss can definitely shape an individual’s day and/or career depending upon his/her techniques. In the society we live in offers a diverse and wide range of job opportunities, Most people need to work to survive in these hard times. People want to hang on to the jobs they already have. For some people, this means dealing with a bad boss. The perception of whether a boss is considered a good or bad boss depends on the outlook of the employees Bosses come in all flavors and styles. Most bosses have a pleasant mood and are easy to work with. Unfortunately some, bosses are not pleasant. The moods of a bad boss make it where you don’t want to deal with him. Even in a good mood a bad boss can make his/her employees hate their job. A bad boss is one that has no respect, no knowledge, does not like his/her job and takes it out on the employees. The employees become stressful t and tense while at work. The stress due to dealing with a bad boss can cause many health problems. These problems can include stress overload, Heart problems, aggravated asthma, allergies, lack of sleep and depression. It cost business seventy nine billion dollars annual due to loss of productivity and absenteeism due to the stress caused by bad management (U.S surgeon General’s......

Words: 2029 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Bosse vs Chili Case Study

...Case Name: Bosse vs. Brinker Restaurant d/b/a Chili’s Which court is making this decision? Who did what to whom? Bosse was a customer who ran out on his bill. Another patron, who is unknown, chased Bosse. During the chase the unknown patron called and informed an employee at Chili’s of the situation, who then called 911. While being chased Bosse was involved in an auto accident and was injured. What relief (claim) was sought by plaintiff in the lower court? Bosse claims the unknown patron was working on behalf of the restaurant, he therefor caused the accident which makes the restaurant liable for damages. What was the lower court’s decision? And, if applicable, the Court of Appeals’ decision? N/A Who prevailed in the lower court(s)? N/A What is the specific legal question, based on what facts, is this court is being asked to address? Did the unknown patron’s actions create an agency when they contacted Chilis? There is no genuine issue to prove Bosse claim of the patron working as an agent for Chili’s. What law(s) and specifically, which legal element(s) is (are) at issue? The common law of agency. Specifically the implied agency due to the patron pursuing the plaintiff. What is the court’s reason (interpretation) for the application of, change in, or exception to the law? There was no implied agency due to no consent, no control and there was no relationship or benefit for the restaurant, between them and the unknown......

Words: 364 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Cure for Horrible Bosses

...Supercorp (Crown, 2009). Kanter The Cure for Horrible Bosses I n the recent film comedy Horrible Bosses, three truly dreadful managers make their employees’ lives miserable. The first is a cruel executive who dangles a promotion in front of a subordinate as bait, only to snatch it away once his stupid demands have been met. The second is a mean cokehead who inherits the family business from his kindly deceased father. s The third is an orthodontist who sexually rthodontist harasses her assistant, threatening to tell stant, his fiancée that it’s his fault. ’s The victims in the movie can’t quit. They need the jobs. Instead, they compose bs. elaborate, farcical plots to eliminate the cal bosses. In real life, horrible bosses are the stuff orrible of tragedy, not comedy. Workplace discontent is no joke. Some surveys show that as many as half of American workers feel low levels ers of work engagement, stemming ment, in part from poor management. or It’s not insults that cause the ts greatest harm, but rather callousness about people’s time. t Horrible bosses want control. s They expect subordinates to ubordinates be on call 24/7 and to hit unrealistic deadlines with limited res sources. When the work product is delivered, horrible bosses may orrible ignore it for long intervals, makong ing it clear that the deadline was at artificial and the stress unnecessary. he To minimize the impact of horze rible bosses, companies can ensure that performance reviews are based on......

Words: 845 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...Framework: The COSO Standard 23 3.1 3.2 23 25 Importance of Effective Internal Controls Internal Controls Standards: Background (a) Internal Control Definitions: Foreign Corrupt Practices Act of 1977 (b) FCPA Aftermath: What Happened? 3.3 Events Leading to the Treadway Commission (a) Earlier AICPA Standards: SAS No. 55 (b) Treadway Committee Report 3.4 COSO Internal Control Framework (a) Control Environment (b) Risk Assessment (c) Control Activities (d) Communications and Information (e) Monitoring 26 28 28 30 30 31 33 39 41 43 46 v vi Contents 3.5 3.6 Other Dimensions of the COSO Internal Controls Framework Internal Audit CBOK Needs Notes 50 51 51 Sarbanes-Oxley and Beyond 53 4.1 CHAPTER 4 54 4.2 4.3 4.4 CHAPTER 5 Key Sarbanes-Oxley Act Elements (a) Title I: Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (b) Title II: Auditor Independence (c) SOx Title III: Corporate Responsibility (d) Title IV: Enhanced Financial Disclosures (e) Title V: Analyst Conflicts of Interest (f) Titles VI through X: Fraud Accountability and White-Collar Crime (g) Title XI: Corporate Fraud Accountability Performing Section 404 Reviews under AS 5 (a) Section 404 Internal Controls Assessments Today (b) Launching the Section 404 Compliance Review AS 5 Rules and Internal Audit Impact of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act Notes Another Internal Controls Framework: CobiT 55 60 62 68 72 72 74 75 75 76 84 87 87 89 5.1 Introduction to CobiT 5.2 CobiT Framework (a) CobiT Cube Components: IT Resources (b)......

Words: 357645 - Pages: 1431

Premium Essay

Horrible Bosses 2 Reaction Paper

...SARAÑA, JULYA KARA B. BSA-5 BA 102 TTH 9:00-10:30 08/04/2015 A Movie Reflection on “Horrible Bosses 2” The movie Horrible Bosses 2 was an entertaining movie in a rated kind of way. Although some parts are too vulgar, I was able to pick up a few good lessons. The story revolves around the life of three gentlemen namely Nick Hendricks, Kurt Buckman, and Dale Arbus. It started when they were able to create a product which is a car wash inspired shower head, the “Shower Buddy”. After capturing the attention of well-known investors who are Bert Hanson, they had a compromise that instead of Mr. Hanson’s company producing their product, Mr. Hanson will provide them a loan to put up a warehouse and the three men in return, will produce 100,000 units of shower buddies for the former. This scenario portrayed the importance of belief in one’s self. Producing something that has not yet been introduced to the public is a talent and skill of being innovative. I admire the three men’s choice of not agreeing to sell their product but to stick with their plan of being the ones to put up their own business. I find this scenario somewhat the same with the previous film being shown in the classroom. On the day Nick, Kurt, and Dale presented their product to Mr. Hanson, he immediately denied them saying that he will be cancelling his order. He only did this so that the three men could not pay the loan thereby resulting to an auction in the “Shower Buddy” products at a lower price. This......

Words: 659 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Horrible Bosses

...REFLECTION PAPER: “Horrible Bosses” One of the worst scenarios that an employee may dream of is having a difficult boss to work under. Bosses that are too strict, give too much work, insensitive or impatient are some of the characteristics that employees don’t like. Let’s face it, I don’t think anyone would like bosses or superiors like that. The film “Horrible Bosses” shows three friends – Nick Hendricks, Dale Arbus and Kurt Buckman struggle working under their own “horrible” bosses. Nick works under David Harken who reprimands Nick and saying that Nick isn’t fit yet for a promotion so he awards it on himself. On the other hand, Dale works as an assistant for Dr. Julia Harris who continues to sexually harass Dale despite of him being engaged. Julia even threatens to show Stacy (Dale’s fiancé) some intimate pictures of her and Dale if he wouldn’t have sex with her. Lastly, since Kurt’s original boss died, he now works for his boss’ son whose name is Bobby that is a drug addict and doesn’t really care about the company at all. With these circumstances, they’ve decided to kill their respective bosses. Over the course of studying Human Resource Management (HRM), I have realized that Human Resource, in its simplest form, is about improving an employee’s work environment in order for the organization to maximize its employee’s skills and potential. The film “Horrible Bosses” illustrated how an employee’s work environment – in this case, their respective employers - can......

Words: 436 - Pages: 2